Skip to main content

Weak link?

Weak link?

Joined
May 30, 2014
Messages
4,821
Anyone of the same opinion that Goalkeeper is slight weak link in the side. I've not been overly impressed with Jones and I most certainly wasn't with Stuckmann tonight. I can't believe the gulf in class between them and Rudd.
One would assume that Kelly coaches them and doesn't advocate being glued to the line every time the ball is crossed into the box? Goalies nowadays, Shaky would have a field day ?
 
I think Stucky was Shaky tonight literally! And Jones is a competent keeper at this level and is also proven. My weak link would be tackling midfielders!! Good to see Welsh back tonight and I did notice Kilkenny put in a few sliders!!!
 
Stuckmann wasn't great last night but needs a run of at least 10 games as any keeper does. Hes played about 4/5 stop start since Rudd signed.He's proven he can do it when he was player of the year a a few seasons back. He's commanding, organises and is a decent distributor.

Jones is one of the worst I've seen in a while probably bar Arestidou. He stays on his line when a ball is floated into the six yard box, never anticipates coming off his line, has poor distribution and on saturday his handling looked very poor. I know if i was a centre half id rather be playing in front of Stuckmann.

When i saw Jones a couple of times last season and thought he was Orients main weak link and that was backed up by their fans comments after we signed him. Definitely time to give Stuckmann a good run in my opinion,he cant do any worse.
 
Bit harsh on jones. He came off his line when needed caught several crosses taking the pressure off the defence. I don't know what game you watched but it wasn't the same one as me.
 
We've just won 4 on the bounce playing some decent football and with a hatful of goals and we choose to focus on criticising a player who wasn't even on the pitch by comparing him with a player who isn't even at the club.

Wonder if the player who took Beckham's shirt after his return to United faced the same comparisons?
 
If you think Jones came off his line when needed then i don't think we have watched the same games all season lol. I remember him catching one ball when no one was within 5 yards of him in the second half to ironic cheers then standing like a statue with it as Reid and Robinson made runs down the flanks.

In my opinion Jones is a dangerous keeper that will cost you points by just standing on his line. A lot of people will think oh he did ok only because he didn't commit a huge error (missed kick,dropped ball etc), but the biggest error for any goalkeeper is not commanding your area. I think its a huge reason in the defence looking shaky for large parts of this season already.

Maybe i am harsh on keepers, but we have 2 experienced at the club and in my opinion the best of 2 isnt playing every week.
 
Rudd was a hard act to follow.

We had, in my eyes, a future England goalkeeper playing for us for a year and a half. Thus, we were spoilt a little bit.

Jones is a League 1 goalkeeper from what I have seen of him, admittedly not all that much. Nothing more, nothing less.

I would like to see Stuckmann given a run in the side but I can't see Grayson dropping Jones for a league game, barring any howlers.
 
Rudd is better than both of them I think that's obvious but the simple facts are we couldn't afford him unless he took a big drop in wages.

The only thing in our favour is that we could offer him guaranteed 1st team football but the lad is still young so he was probably willing to bide his time at Norwich.
 
Rudd is better than both of them I think that's obvious but the simple facts are we couldn't afford him unless he took a big drop in wages.

The only thing in our favour is that we could offer him guaranteed 1st team football but the lad is still young so he was probably willing to bide his time at Norwich.

From what I have seen, Rudd has the potential to be a better goalkeeper than Rudd.
 
Obviously spoilt with Rudd but he to was prone to costing us points.

How dare you talk about the Messiah like that? He was perfect and was never at fault for any goals. Indeed any that looked like he could have done better with was usually the defenders fault for giving a free kick away 35 yards from goal.
 
I was just thinking to myself last night, now that Humphrey and Gallagher have hit form and are putting in good displays consistently, who would be the next scapegoat? my money was on holmes but i guess i was wrong.
 
I was just thinking to myself last night, now that Humphrey and Gallagher have hit form and are putting in good displays consistently, who would be the next scapegoat? my money was on holmes but i guess i was wrong.

Humphrey and Gallagher have never been 'scapegoats'. Both have attracted critical comment in the past - Gallagher for apparent lack of commitment despite his creative abilities, Humphrey for lack of creativity despite his obvious commitment - that has often been justified. But Gallagher does now appear to be putting a bit more effort in, while Humphrey is benefitting from being played further forward where he can pose a greater threat to the opposition - his goal on Saturday was the perfect example. Hopefully both will now continue in the sam vein because teams that win promotion don't carry consistently under-performing players.
 
Anyone of the same opinion that Goalkeeper is slight weak link in the side. I've not been overly impressed with Jones and I most certainly wasn't with Stuckmann tonight. I can't believe the gulf in class between them and Rudd.
One would assume that Kelly coaches them and doesn't advocate being glued to the line every time the ball is crossed into the box? Goalies nowadays, Shaky would have a field day ?

Aren't we splitting hairs a bit here? 11 goals conceded in the lague. Only 3 teams have conceded fewer.
 
Jamie Jones may have his flaws but did I just read someone saying he is on a par with Cardiac Arestidou?!?

Words fail me.
 
If you think Jones came off his line when needed then i don't think we have watched the same games all season lol. I remember him catching one ball when no one was within 5 yards of him in the second half to ironic cheers then standing like a statue with it as Reid and Robinson made runs down the flanks.

In my opinion Jones is a dangerous keeper that will cost you points by just standing on his line. A lot of people will think oh he did ok only because he didn't commit a huge error (missed kick,dropped ball etc), but the biggest error for any goalkeeper is not commanding your area. I think its a huge reason in the defence looking shaky for large parts of this season already.

Maybe i am harsh on keepers, but we have 2 experienced at the club and in my opinion the best of 2 isnt playing every week.

I think you're way off the mark. As I commented on a similar thread, I have seen Jones play for Orient a great deal over the last four years or so as I am quite a frequent spectator, with orient supporting mates. He is nowhere near as good as Rudd but he is plenty good enough for league one. Rudd wasn't flawless but he will be a regular premiership keeper in time and we have been spoilt over the last season and a half. Comparing any keeper in league 1 to Rudd is pointless. Jones will serve our purpose IMHO.
 
Back
Top