Anyone explain to me why Welsh isn't starting games? Don't get me wrong, I'm not bashing Pearson here but Welsh affects the game so much more in that position. Put more tackles in than the rest of the midfield combined. We only got going once he came on. Brought some much needed bite and urgency.
Welsh
Agreed he needs to start gamesAnyone explain to me why Welsh isn't starting games? Don't get me wrong, I'm not bashing Pearson here but Welsh affects the game so much more in that position. Put more tackles in than the rest of the midfield combined. We only got going once he came on. Brought some much needed bite and urgency.
He is literally a level below Pearson Gally and DJ.
Why can no one see this? All he does is fly into tackles. He cant pass the ball well enough, cant score goals, cant run with the ball, gives away too many free kicks in dangerous areas (one of which was inches away from the top corner today) and his positional play isnt great (see Nakhi Well's goal for Huddersfield vs us at home this season as a good example).
He's being phased out because he's no better than a squad player at this level.
Why can no one see this? All he does is fly into tackles. He cant pass the ball well enough, cant score goals, cant run with the ball, gives away too many free kicks in dangerous areas (one of which was inches away from the top corner today) and his positional play isnt great (see Nakhi Well's goal for Huddersfield vs us at home this season as a good example).
He's being phased out because he's no better than a squad player at this level.
He is literally a level below Pearson Gally and DJ.
Why can no one see this? All he does is fly into tackles. He cant pass the ball well enough, cant score goals, cant run with the ball, gives away too many free kicks in dangerous areas (one of which was inches away from the top corner today) and his positional play isnt great (see Nakhi Well's goal for Huddersfield vs us at home this season as a good example).
He's being phased out because he's no better than a squad player at this level.
Strange that because we often look at much better side once he comes on. Strange coincidence.
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2010
- Messages
- 850
He played well today
He's better than Pearson for sure. Although Pearson looks like he'll be a good one given time.
I'm a big fan of Welsh. Rarely a stray pass, solid distribution, excellent positioning and the best tackler we have by a country mile. He keeps the game ticking over as well. Horses the courses use whilst Pearson and the likes bed in.
On another note - I thought DJ was poor today.
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2004
- Messages
- 1,825
We needed Welsh to steady the ship today, and for the record Johnson and Gallagher shouldn't be played as a pair in midfield again. No wonder QPR ran through us with ease once we took Pearson off, neither Johnson or Gallagher were going to win the ball back.
Welsh is being phased out, I think that's clear for all to see, but we do need a player like him in the team to break up play, and distribute it simply to a team-mate. As much as I do want to see us playing quick football along the ground, you still need players like Welsh in your team, players who aren't bothered about kicking the opposition up in the air, as long as it prevents a goal.
Welsh is being phased out, I think that's clear for all to see, but we do need a player like him in the team to break up play, and distribute it simply to a team-mate. As much as I do want to see us playing quick football along the ground, you still need players like Welsh in your team, players who aren't bothered about kicking the opposition up in the air, as long as it prevents a goal.
- Joined
- May 30, 2014
- Messages
- 4,821
I thought Pearson had a really good game. I thought DJ was lucky to stay on today.He's better than Pearson for sure. Although Pearson looks like he'll be a good one given time.
I'm a big fan of Welsh. Rarely a stray pass, solid distribution, excellent positioning and the best tackler we have by a country mile. He keeps the game ticking over as well. Horses the courses use whilst Pearson and the likes bed in.
On another note - I thought DJ was poor today.
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2010
- Messages
- 850
I thought Pearson had a really good game. I thought DJ was lucky to stay on today.
The effort is there for me. He's sharp and neat on the ball. Although his decision making is a bit hit and miss and he plays the wrong ball too often. But mostly he's a few paces out of position for all the action - it'll take time for him to get used to his role - Browne or Welsh would have given us so much more.
- Joined
- May 30, 2014
- Messages
- 4,821
To me he looks class he made a terrific pass to Hugill second half that Welsh and Browne wouldn't have had the ability to make.The effort is there for me. He's sharp and neat on the ball. Although his decision making is a bit hit and miss and he plays the wrong ball too often. But mostly he's a few paces out of position for all the action - it'll take time for him to get used to his role - Browne or Welsh would have given us so much more.
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2004
- Messages
- 13,345
We needed Welsh to steady the ship today, and for the record Johnson and Gallagher shouldn't be played as a pair in midfield again. No wonder QPR ran through us with ease once we took Pearson off, neither Johnson or Gallagher were going to win the ball back.
Welsh is being phased out, I think that's clear for all to see, but we do need a player like him in the team to break up play, and distribute it simply to a team-mate. As much as I do want to see us playing quick football along the ground, you still need players like Welsh in your team, players who aren't bothered about kicking the opposition up in the air, as long as it prevents a goal.
We do have his successor - Grimshaw
- Joined
- Jul 5, 2004
- Messages
- 5,199
Welsh was great today. Cracking sliding challenge that was bizarrely pulled up for a free kick. Pearson was great too though. Massive competition in midfield.
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2010
- Messages
- 850
To me he looks class he made a terrific pass to Hugill second half that Welsh and Browne wouldn't have had the ability to make.
There he has potential, no doubt. I thought Woods continued to impress.
Pearson was excellent, particularly on the ball, which is why he's starting and Welsh is on the bench.
Welsh is getting on a bit, and in certain points in games can be useful to bring on as a substitute, but his lack of quality/composure on the ball means he shouldn't be a regular at this level imo.
Let's not confuse popularity with quality.
Welsh is getting on a bit, and in certain points in games can be useful to bring on as a substitute, but his lack of quality/composure on the ball means he shouldn't be a regular at this level imo.
Let's not confuse popularity with quality.
- Joined
- Aug 5, 2009
- Messages
- 1,150
Pearson did nothing all game. I wouldn't exactly call him the invisible man because he moves about looking for the ball but all he's capable of doing with it is to knock is straight back to whoever gave it him or to turn under pressure and knock it back to a centre half.
He offers nothing that Welsh of Kilkenny don't, in fact I'd say he offers less. I'm not writing him off because he's a young lad and new to this level but I've seen nothing so far to suggest he should be above Brownhill in the pecking order, never mind Welsh or Kilkenny.
He offers nothing that Welsh of Kilkenny don't, in fact I'd say he offers less. I'm not writing him off because he's a young lad and new to this level but I've seen nothing so far to suggest he should be above Brownhill in the pecking order, never mind Welsh or Kilkenny.
Sometimes you just need someone to take the game by the scruff in midfield and that's what Welsh did today. Nothing fancy, just got his foot in, broke up play and provided some urgency. Tidy as Pearson and DJ are, sometimes you need that
Last edited:
Pearson did a good job, today. Always on the ball and his distribution was good. Shows a lot of promise.
Exactly raefil. I completely agree.
And when you see comments on Twitter like "Pearson is a charlatan", who is "stealing a living", it really does make you wonder whether some people actually face the pitch when the game is going on. Especially with him being just 21 and only having played about 5 games at Championship level.
Folk are very quick to call for the addition of young players, but like we have seen with the DJ thread, as soon as they hit a rough patch or take a bit of time to settle in, the exact same folk call straight away for the return of the likes of Welsh who has proven himself to be very average at the level. Let the young lads develop for goodness sake.
Grimshaw will be probably in front of the back 4/5 in the Welsh role with Pearson further forward. I'd like to see DJ on the wing and curling crosses in like Beckham did on the right. Welsh is part of the squad like Kilkenny and will have apart to play in the remainder of the season. Whether they'll be in next year's is unlikely imo.