Skip to main content

Westley's Progress

Westley's Progress

Joined
Aug 23, 2009
Messages
4,397
Location
nostros vires variis
Much has been written in recent weeks about whether Westley should remain in charge. After the Bury game on Boxing Day I said he should be given more time with the next four games being key in regards to the feelings of the majority of fans.

The bad loss against Doncaster could have been the tipping point, however, the silence from the boardroom suggested that Westley's position wasn't under threat. In a way, that surprised me, given the comments that Westley made himself after the Leyton Orient loss in regards to his discussion with Ridsdale.

The win at Hartlepool wouldn't have convinced many people and the defeat at Millwall, whilst hardly embarassing, doesn't exactly help matters. The prize money of a 4th round tie could have been the difference between signing a decent player in January and scrimping around with loan signings and free agents.

For me, the season now rests on Thursday's game at Coventry. Lose that, and the season's over. In the league, even if form picks up, a top 10 finish would be an achievement at the moment.

So, looking on the positive side; is a Johnstone's Paint Trophy win and a top ten league finish good enough for the club? At the start of the season I'd have said "yes".

However, in almost 12 months in charge of the club Westley has taken the club backwards on the pitch and off the pitch attendances have dropped significantly. However, we are being linked to quite a few players, especially strikers, so in a few weeks time results might have picked up and things settled down a bit.

Whilst I might be in the minority, and have my intelligence questioned, I still believe that Westley should remain in charge until at least the first 10 games of next season. The club needs stability. And like it or not, the best person to bring stability to the club at the moment is Westley.
 
We beat Hartlepool..... 3 points in offer and we took all 3 and today we lost 1-0 to a strong Championship side so I doubt these two games would have any impact on Westley's position as manager....

I lost my patience after the Doncaster game but now every game is a cup final.... The next month is as much about Mr Hemmings than it is Westley.... If Risdale and came out with a statement about us having money to spend and we end up with ex Stevenage lads currently playing none league then we have a serious problem with Westley..... I think he will have to be shrewd in the market as wont be given a bean
 
We beat Hartlepool..... 3 points in offer and we took all 3 and today we lost 1-0 to a strong Championship side so I doubt these two games would have any impact on Westley's position as manager....

I lost my patience after the Doncaster game but now every game is a cup final.... The next month is as much about Mr Hemmings than it is Westley.... If Risdale and came out with a statement about us having money to spend and we end up with ex Stevenage lads currently playing none league then we have a serious problem with Westley..... I think he will have to be shrewd in the market as wont be given a bean
 
If TH had a burning desire for this football club to achieve, not just survive, he would have been sacked by now - in fact he would never have been employed. I expect more bargain basement signings in January. Please, to avoid disappointment, forget about any promotion push anytime soon.
 
I would say we have made a lot of progress off the pitch with costs heavily reduced compared to last season, and although there has been a reduction in gate receipts the proportional decrease in wages far outweighs it.

We have to be realistic about what can be achieved and in what space of time.

As I have said before until we consistently perform badly there is no reason to sack the manager, Westley is inconsistent at best or worst.
 
Progression in the token cup (the Johnstone's Paint Trophy) does nothing for me.

Whatever happened to the team of leaders we were meant to have with a winning mentality?

Keeping up will now be success for this season.
 
If TH had a burning desire for this football club to achieve, not just survive, he would have been sacked by now - in fact he would never have been employed. I expect more bargain basement signings in January. Please, to avoid disappointment, forget about any promotion push anytime soon.

Whilst I'm not expecting a promotion push this season, next season a play-off place should be the absolute minimum. Another season like the one we're having and the club will be heading for a return to the days of Les Chapman when the club seem content to finish 18th in front of less than 4,000 fans every week.
 
Whilst I'm not expecting a promotion push this season, next season a play-off place should be the absolute minimum. Another season like the one we're having and the club will be heading for a return to the days of Les Chapman when the club seem content to finish 18th in front of less than 4,000 fans every week.
Exactly. Which is why this shouldn't and cannot be allowed to continue.
 
I would say we have made a lot of progress off the pitch with costs heavily reduced compared to last season, and although there has been a reduction in gate receipts the proportional decrease in wages far outweighs it.

We have to be realistic about what can be achieved and in what space of time.

As I have said before until we consistently perform badly there is no reason to sack the manager, Westley is inconsistent at best or worst.

Some people will point to the fact that Charlton virtually re-built their squad under Chris Powell and walked the league last season, so clubs can be turned around very quickly.

The reduction in the wage bill is a positive for the club, but the longer we stay in League One then the longer we're going to be hampered by the 65% ruling, going down to 60% I believe next season.

The Premiership has become almost a closed shop for most clubs unless they have a multi-millionaire investor willing to spend big and the Championship may well go the same way.
 
Is this Westley's fault? Maybe he isn't up to the PNE job but I would rather see something change at the top before another manager is cast aside.

Hemmings should know as well as any fan on here as to what the club was like before the BAXI era. I too feel that Hemmings is just as much a part of the problem as Westley is. However, I would rather see Hemmings remain in control rather than some hypocrite investor who rips the club off.
 
Some people will point to the fact that Charlton virtually re-built their squad under Chris Powell and walked the league last season, so clubs can be turned around very quickly.

The reduction in the wage bill is a positive for the club, but the longer we stay in League One then the longer we're going to be hampered by the 65% ruling, going down to 60% I believe next season.

The Premiership has become almost a closed shop for most clubs unless they have a multi-millionaire investor willing to spend big and the Championship may well go the same way.

The longer Westley stays though the more we can spend on wages will drop. Crowds will get lower, next seasons Season Tickets sales will be lower. Less income means less can spend on wages.
 
The longer Westley stays though the more we can spend on wages will drop. Crowds will get lower, next seasons Season Tickets sales will be lower. Less income means less can spend on wages.

Thing is though, bringing in a new manager doesn't guareentee that we'd improve. In fact, the last three managers we've brought in have all taken us backwards. The club's history suggests that the best option for replacing Westley was allowed to take over at Fleetwood.
 
The longer Westley stays though the more we can spend on wages will drop. Crowds will get lower, next seasons Season Tickets sales will be lower. Less income means less can spend on wages.

And changing Westley will cure that ?
What if the new manager struggles to put together a competitive squad with the financial restrictions that Hemmings has set inside 12 months, do we sack him then too ?
 
For me, the season now rests on Thursday's game at Coventry. Lose that, and the season's over.

So you are 100% certain are you that a team 8 points out of a play off spot at this time of year cannot make up the gap? Please confirm that this is your stance. Because if it is, I would like you to PM me with the winning lottery numbers for next week. I simply can't afford to miss an opportunity like this to hit the jackpot.
 
We never once played in front of less than 4k under Chapman.

14th April 1992 against Reading was the last time we played in front of less than 4k under Chapman. In fact, 3,203 turned up to see us draw 1-1. However, that was on a Tuesday night, but the previous Saturday only 3,926 saw us beat Leyton Orient 2-1.

In total, 11 home attendance during the 1991/92 season we less than 4,000 and 3 in the 1990/91 season.
 
If we improve and start to score goals then fineWestley could be the man , however in the last 10 games weve had 1 victory over a side with 1 win in 22 games and were still struggling to score . Threads like these after every gameare just pointless .
 
Back
Top