Skip to main content

Whaley Substitution????

Whaley Substitution????

Joined
Nov 11, 2004
Messages
1,012
Location
Bamber Bridge
couldnt figure out why he brought whaley off so early?? he didnt look injured and i thought he had a half decent start to the game. He looked as puzzled as anyone else when the fourth official held the board up with his number! can anyone elaborate??😕
 
whaley wasnt tracking back much and they was killing us down that side so i think he wanted sedgewick their to help alexander out more. was surprised at 1st i must admit.
 
He s looked knackered for the last 2 games, we've got a lot of fixtures coming up, hes one of our best players and hes getting stick off his own fans.

Theres 4 reasons for you. Wasn't at the game but Glad Simmo has finally given the lad a break.
 
good attacking but we were being overun in the midfield, looked slightly more solid with miller in his better position and Sedgwick looked much better in his old position, danny pugh ended up at left back to often to make up for the actual left back who was sat on his arse to often !!. Still robbed by more than one crap decision and an off day that Carlo has rarely ever had, the result embarrasses them more than us, when it went 2-2 and we were all chanting we only have 10 men and that said it all ... the futures still bright !!
 
Ever thought that with Whaley just passing a fitness test AM and Miller not allowed to play v Sunderland,that Whaley was subbed as a precaution having been clattered. We would be fucked if Whaley left injured later on with the Sunderland game coming up next.

Think about the bigger picture.

The midfield is bare as it is.

Good call Simmo.
 
Was an okay decision at the time but the absurd sending off sadly unbalanced the side and so the decision rebounded on us, unlucky but here's hoping Whalley takes his frustration out on Sunderland.
 
Ever thought that with Whaley just passing a fitness test AM and Miller not allowed to play v Sunderland,that Whaley was subbed as a precaution having been clattered. We would be f**ked if Whaley left injured later on with the Sunderland game coming up next.

Think about the bigger picture.

The midfield is bare as it is.

Good call Simmo.

That is something that I and probably others had not thought of pornstar, but if that is the case, why risk Whaley to start with???????????

If you want to ensure that a player avoids injury, with the circumstances forcing him to pass a pre-game fitness test, it doesn't quite make sense to start him in a tough away game in the first place, does it?

It is almost as if Simpson needed a reminder that Whaley could be injured, and hence our midfield versus Sunderland would really be stretched.

Sounds more of a tactical substitution to me, and that is the way the WBA commentary team also read the situation. With Jarret more or less now forced into duty for the Sunderland game, it would not have been a bad idea to put him on the bench for today's game, play Miller from the start, and give Whaley a complete rest and a view from the stands, but then again, I guess hindsight is a wonderful thing.
 
Whaley has been bobbins recently, that's probably why Simmo took him off early.

As for our central midfield situation, I'm not sure that we have anyone on the books who is capable of solving our woes in this area - unfortunately Billy Davies signed so many mediocre performers that Simpson has had a tough job strengthening.

If it hadn't been for the club's (and I'm not just pinning this on Simmo) blind faith in McKenna then McCormack may have been afforded an opportunity and perhaps gone some way to solving this but alas it wasn't to be.
 
The Manager explains his decision on WW on the 15 minute view of the match and the interview after.

He substituted Simon Whalley because he did not get a satisfactory signal back from Simon (when asked) that he was ok, so he subbed him, he said may have been a mistake. 🙁

Simmo also goes on to say how angry at the officials he was. He said at half time he spoke to the ref about some of the decisions and was told "yes, write them down and if I have time in a couple of weeks I will look at them"😡. Simmo said he was furious at that response and who can blame him?
 
I personally think if whaley had of stayed on it would have bin alot better.I dont no how many times whaley got past there left back.
I was puzzled at the time and im still puzzled now.You could see on Nugents face that he didnt no why whaley went off
 
I thought it was a good move when I eventually calmed down and thought about it.

Having seen McKenna clattered (and then looked completely f**ked for the rest of the game) I was shocked and thought it was a mistake when Whaley's number was raised.

But I quickly realised that Whaley was providing absolutely no defensive cover whatsoever and Koumas was running riot down the left. Bringing on Miller and putting the more defensive minded Sedgewick suddenly made sense.

Then Dichio got sent off! :-(

tg
 
Back
Top