Skip to main content

What else do we need?

What else do we need?

Joined
Jan 27, 2012
Messages
4,558
Location
Manchester
What a ridiculously good week this has been so far. Everything is coming together nicely. In so far as the squad is concerned, what more do we need?

GK

Rudd
Stuckmann

Defence

RB - Keith Keane
RB - Tom Clarke
LB - Scott Laird
LB - David Buchanan
CB - Paul HUntington
CB - Bailey Wright
CB - Shane Cansdell-Sherriff
CB - Chris Robertson (TL)
LCB - Ben Davies

Midfield

RM - Jeff Monakana
RM - Chris Humphrey
LM - Will Hayhurst
LM - Lee Holmes
CM - Jack King
CM - Nicky Wroe
CM - Jon Welsh (C)
CM - John MOusinho
CM - Joel Byrom (TL)
CM - Andy Procter (TL)
M - Ryan Croasdale


Forwards

Stuart Beavon
Iain HUme (TL)
Graham Cummins (TL)
Joe Garner
Chris Beardsley (TL)

(C) = Captain
(TL) = Transfer Listed / Available to offers (as i understand it to be)


When you look at that squad, i think we are two players away from being a top 4 side. I think we need another QUALITY central midfielder to help Wroe and Welsh. I am not sure whether Wroe will score the same amoutn of goals next season and i am sure that Welsh won't play all 46 league games so we need some quality to come in when they are not available. I don't have faith in Byrom, Procter or Mousinho.

Thereafter, i think the only other player we need is a good old fashioned bustling centre forward!
 
For me in all honesty, very very little.

I am delighted with the squad except the forwards, possibly, but even then I believe Cummins can do the target man job as well as most and was starting to look good towards the end of last season. I would maybe like to see a youngster come from the PL with genuine pace up top but other than that I am confident.
 
For me in all honesty, very very little.

I am delighted with the squad except the forwards, possibly, but even then I believe Cummins can do the target man job as well as most and was starting to look good towards the end of last season. I would maybe like to see a youngster come from the PL with genuine pace up top but other than that I am confident.

Can't disagree. Just shows how we did have a squad that is well capable to achieve what we set otu to achieve under Wacky Graham but the players just needed a bit of TLC, respect and freedom.
 
Can't disagree. Just shows how we did have a squad that is well capable to achieve what we set otu to achieve under Wacky Graham but the players just needed a bit of TLC, respect and freedom.

Westley did a similar job to Brown just in a VERY different way, he has bought a mjority of good players just could not get them working properly. He also brought Tumble in as well which was a very good move IMHO as well. Fingers crossed this should be a promising season
 
We're short of a big mobile forward and a clever , creative midfielder to unlock packed defences .

Other than that , this looks like a definite top 6 squad now .
 
Have I missed something ? I understood that only 3 players were named as "open to offers" - Robertson, Procter and Beardsley. Hume we also understand to be available due to his wages. I have not seen any indication that Byrom and Cummins are available.
I believe that getting Hume away (either transfer or loan) and bringing in a good young centre forward from a Premiership reserve team would give us an excellent squad capable of challenging for the top six places.
 
We just need someone who can bag 25 goals+. Simple as.

How about A. Miracle. He's a free agent guaranteed to get the goals and all the big teams have decided they'd rather let a goalscorer go to a team in a lower division. I honestly don't know why we've never signed him before. Then again, it's not like those 25+ goals a season strikers are hard to come by.
 
Its no good being sarcastic,the question was "what do we need" ?
The blunt answer is a striker who can score goals in what was the old THIRD division, its not asking a lot really.we need somebody who can do the job who isnt happy where he is.
Look what a cracking player Donny got last season for next to nowt !

How about A. Miracle. He's a free agent guaranteed to get the goals and all the big teams have decided they'd rather let a goalscorer go to a team in a lower division. I honestly don't know why we've never signed him before. Then again, it's not like those 25+ goals a season strikers are hard to come by.
 
The lack of an out and out goal scorer has been a massive concern of mine. I like Beavon as he works his socks off ( a bit like Hume) but his goals won't get us promoted. Like everyone else, I don't know of a 25 + goals a year striker who we could afford or who would want to earn their keep in the third tier of English football.Let's hope Grayson does.
 
Its no good being sarcastic,the question was "what do we need" ?
The blunt answer is a striker who can score goals in what was the old THIRD division, its not asking a lot really.we need somebody who can do the job who isnt happy where he is.
Look what a cracking player Donny got last season for next to nowt !

Personally I think Beavon is capable of getting the goals should he be given sufficient chances. Whenever I saw Beavon play last season he seemed to have the potential to be a good goalscorer but he always seemed to be dropping deep to make something happen, as a result of our lack of creativity. Even if it's not a target man type player that we go for I think a way needs to be found for the team to create chances. Any striker that is brought in should be in my opinion either and unknown quantity who will have the ability to surprise the opposition or a striker with a presence on the field who can hold the ball up. I just don't feel that it is likely that we will get a free scoring brilliant all round striker so simply, and I don't believe that the striker we do get would be unsatisfactory should they somehow fail to reach the 25 goal mark. Overall, I think we need a striker who can have an impact on the success of the players around him, while scoring a few goals when the chances present themselves.
 
Personally I think Beavon is capable of getting the goals should he be given sufficient chances. Whenever I saw Beavon play last season he seemed to have the potential to be a good goalscorer but he always seemed to be dropping deep to make something happen, as a result of our lack of creativity. Even if it's not a target man type player that we go for I think a way needs to be found for the team to create chances. Any striker that is brought in should be in my opinion either and unknown quantity who will have the ability to surprise the opposition or a striker with a presence on the field who can hold the ball up. I just don't feel that it is likely that we will get a free scoring brilliant all round striker so simply, and I don't believe that the striker we do get would be unsatisfactory should they somehow fail to reach the 25 goal mark. Overall, I think we need a striker who can have an impact on the success of the players around him, while scoring a few goals when the chances present themselves.

Hooray! Somebody gets it. Beavon is more than good enough to be the main source of goals, it's creativity that the team lacks.
 
Hooray! Somebody gets it. Beavon is more than good enough to be the main source of goals, it's creativity that the team lacks.

IMO creativity wasn't the problem last season. Some games we created enough chances to win two or three games. From what I saw, we couldn't hit a cows arse with a banjo.
 
IMO creativity wasn't the problem last season. Some games we created enough chances to win two or three games. From what I saw, we couldn't hit a cows arse with a banjo.

Yeah, and we were peppering the opposition goal with shots all season weren't we?

It was our final ball, it was shocking.
 
Back
Top