Skip to main content

What else do we need?

What else do we need?

IMO creativity wasn't the problem last season. Some games we created enough chances to win two or three games. From what I saw, we couldn't hit a cows arse with a banjo.

I'd agree but Beavon was creating alot of those chances... How many fell to Jack King at the end of the season? He works his socks off and is a good utility player but he can't finish those chances, in terms of bringing other people in to play he did well though.
 
IMO creativity wasn't the problem last season. Some games we created enough chances to win two or three games. From what I saw, we couldn't hit a cows arse with a banjo.

Most chances however in those games were half chances that fell to the likes of King who is a very poor finisher and who in all honesty shouldn't be more than a back up. Not many however were created for Beavon. These games where chances were created apparently in abundance were also very few and far between throughout the season, and usually coincided with when we faced the more poor quality opposition in the league. In some games last season it must also be noted that the players at times couldn't retain possession for any reasonable length of time and never looked like scoring. These games were also not just when Westley was here. Even under Grayson although slightly improved, we still weren't exactly an attacking force that was anywhere near good enough to challenge against the more technically able sides in the league.
 
What a ridiculously good week this has been so far. Everything is coming together nicely. In so far as the squad is concerned, what more do we need?

GK

Rudd
Stuckmann

Defence

RB - Keith Keane
RB - Tom Clarke
LB - Scott Laird
LB - David Buchanan
CB - Paul HUntington
CB - Bailey Wright
CB - Shane Cansdell-Sherriff
CB - Chris Robertson (TL)
LCB - Ben Davies

Midfield

RM - Jeff Monakana
RM - Chris Humphrey
LM - Will Hayhurst
LM - Lee Holmes
CM - Jack King
CM - Nicky Wroe
CM - Jon Welsh (C)
CM - John MOusinho
CM - Joel Byrom (TL)
CM - Andy Procter (TL)
M - Ryan Croasdale


Forwards

Stuart Beavon
Iain HUme (TL)
Graham Cummins (TL)
Joe Garner
Chris Beardsley (TL)

(C) = Captain
(TL) = Transfer Listed / Available to offers (as i understand it to be)


When you look at that squad, i think we are two players away from being a top 4 side.

I don't get it !!

Everyone is saying that the squad looks excellent and will definitely be pushing for a Top 6 place BUT most of those players are the ones that Graham Westley brought in !!!

So are we saying that apart from his people managment skills , he didnt actually do a lot wrong ??
 
I don't get it !!

Everyone is saying that the squad looks excellent and will definitely be pushing for a Top 6 place BUT most of those players are the ones that Graham Westley brought in !!!

So are we saying that apart from his people managment skills , he didnt actually do a lot wrong ??

I would agree whole-heartedly with that statement. He made a right balls of it but he significantly reduced the wage bill and brought in very able players, of the correct demeanour to form quite a well-rounded squad considering.
 
I don't get it !!

Everyone is saying that the squad looks excellent and will definitely be pushing for a Top 6 place BUT most of those players are the ones that Graham Westley brought in !!!

So are we saying that apart from his people managment skills , he didnt actually do a lot wrong ??

Yes , he assembled a decent squad but was then utterly incapable of getting anywhere near the best out of it .

His man-management , tactical nous and training regime all fell well short of the mark . SG has already shown what that squad is capable of.
 
I don't get it !!

Everyone is saying that the squad looks excellent and will definitely be pushing for a Top 6 place BUT most of those players are the ones that Graham Westley brought in !!!

So are we saying that apart from his people managment skills , he didnt actually do a lot wrong ??
He was tactically naive (when plan A was found out, there was no plan B) and his fitness regime knackered the players out which brought poor results on the pitch and lead to him being sacked. But away from that his eye for a midfield and defensive player was reasonable. Huntingdon, Rudd, Laird, Buchanan, Keane, Robertson, Welsh, Holmes, King and Wroe all all good signings and I even think Mousinho and Monakana could come good. Up front he was a poorer judge with only Beavon looking like a good signing.
So basically a good FOOTBALL manager with a couple of tweaks to the squad should be able to form a decent League 1 team from the squad developed by Westley, which also brought the finances into a more reasonable state. So although he had to go and he really was not a likable bloke who brought with him a poor reputation I don't Westley was all bad for PNE, especially if you take a longer term view.
 
We need 1 maybe 2 strikers.

And depending on who they can get shut of, bring in a creative midfielder.
 
Last edited:
Hooray! Somebody gets it. Beavon is more than good enough to be the main source of goals, it's creativity that the team lacks.

Lacked, with the proper coaching Beavon could score a hatful, he needs to be further up the field when we get the ball and not dropping back into his own half to collect the ball. He did that for the majority of last season and scored 9 which in my opinion is a cracking return.

Vs Bournemouth
Vs Doncaster
Vs Shrewsbury
Vs Hartlepool

He scored cracking goals from outside the area, unless I am missing anymore.
 
He was tactically naive (when plan A was found out, there was no plan B) and his fitness regime knackered the players out which brought poor results on the pitch and lead to him being sacked. But away from that his eye for a midfield and defensive player was reasonable. Huntingdon, Rudd, Laird, Buchanan, Keane, Robertson, Welsh, Holmes, King and Wroe all all good signings and I even think Mousinho and Monakana could come good. Up front he was a poorer judge with only Beavon looking like a good signing.
So basically a good FOOTBALL manager with a couple of tweaks to the squad should be able to form a decent League 1 team from the squad developed by Westley, which also brought the finances into a more reasonable state. So although he had to go and he really was not a likable bloke who brought with him a poor reputation I don't Westley was all bad for PNE, especially if you take a longer term view.

Bang On
 
Most chances however in those games were half chances that fell to the likes of King who is a very poor finisher and who in all honesty shouldn't be more than a back up. Not many however were created for Beavon. These games where chances were created apparently in abundance were also very few and far between throughout the season, and usually coincided with when we faced the more poor quality opposition in the league. In some games last season it must also be noted that the players at times couldn't retain possession for any reasonable length of time and never looked like scoring. These games were also not just when Westley was here. Even under Grayson although slightly improved, we still weren't exactly an attacking force that was anywhere near good enough to challenge against the more technically able sides in the league.

King Back Up? He scored 6 and had 9 Assists, which is a good return for a Non League Player.
 
King Back Up? He scored 6 and had 9 Assists, which is a good return for a Non League Player.

How many chances he missed was the problem though. Also when I say back up I mean not in the starting eleven. Obviously he provides a threat, but the question is where would he be played where he would be most effective. I don't think he is good enough technically to start either in centre midfield or as a striker. He is however a good alternative to have on the bench to cover a few positions reasonably effectively.
 
How many chances he missed was the problem though. Also when I say back up I mean not in the starting eleven. Obviously he provides a threat, but the question is where would he be played where he would be most effective. I don't think he is good enough technically to start either in centre midfield or as a striker. He is however a good alternative to have on the bench to cover a few positions reasonably effectively.

Good target man to wear down the opposition centre halfs and then someone can come of the bench and benefit.

As well as his goals and assists there were a few games where he was instrumental in some of the goals, controlling the ball from the goal kicks or laying it off to the wingers for them to attack people 1 on 1 for example the Tranmere at home game where his cushioned header set Garner to run at his man and lay it off to Hayhurst on the overlap.
 
King is simply not quick enough on his feet in tight situations to be effective as a centre forward however good he might be - and he is at times surprisingly good - at other aspects of the role. It is useful to have him as a stopgap if need be but ultimately he is a central midfielder - probably his best role is as a less pacy but more physically assertive alternative to Wroe.
 
Lacked, with the proper coaching Beavon could score a hatful, he needs to be further up the field when we get the ball and not dropping back into his own half to collect the ball. He did that for the majority of last season and scored 9 which in my opinion is a cracking return.

Vs Bournemouth
Vs Doncaster
Vs Shrewsbury
Vs Hartlepool

He scored cracking goals from outside the area, unless I am missing anymore.

As I've said on more than one occasion, even with the massive drag factor of Westley, we were knocking in a fair few goals early last season with a number of players contributing. The problem came when Westley utterly failed to compensate for the loss of Laird and Keane and from then on we offered very little going forward.

Grayson's challenge is to maintain the improvements made at the back whilst making is a more potent attacking force. No doubt Laird could be important in this.

More bodies would be nice but I wouldn't be unhappy going in to the season with what we've got now. I don't see a hugely pressing need for a big man.

Another thought. How did we get out of this division under Moyes?

1 Solid goalkeeping (for Tepi read Rudd)
2 Central midfield authority (for Gregan read Welsh)
3 Fast and skilful wing play (for Eyres/Cartwright read Monakana, Holmes, Hayhurst and Humphrey)
4 Mobile, skilful forward players (for Macken and Nogan read Beavon and, hopefully, Garner)

Admittedly the introduction of Angell late in the season was an ultimately inspired move and it may be nice to have that option. But I don't think its absolutely necessary at present. If I see a weakness, its probably central midfield where we've yet to see a combination with the potential of Rankine and Gregan. Maybe Mousinho can step up and partner Welsh to provide the box to box energy that Rankine provided with the some of the stauture of a Gregan. I don't think we particularly need creativity there as we have plenty on the flanks, esp with Laird returning. Wroe is a luxury player in my opinion but we need that solid base through the centre.

I think that we have the right types of players to succees - the question is whether Grayson can get the consistent required quality out of the likes of Garner and Mousinho. I'm not prepared to write either of them off just yet - if they are fit and ready for pre-season and fail to make an impact before Christmas then they're under question but, for now, they're in the frame and deserve a chance as far as I'm concerned.
 
As I've said on more than one occasion, even with the massive drag factor of Westley, we were knocking in a fair few goals early last season with a number of players contributing. The problem came when Westley utterly failed to compensate for the loss of Laird and Keane and from then on we offered very little going forward.

Grayson's challenge is to maintain the improvements made at the back whilst making is a more potent attacking force. No doubt Laird could be important in this.

More bodies would be nice but I wouldn't be unhappy going in to the season with what we've got now. I don't see a hugely pressing need for a big man.

Another thought. How did we get out of this division under Moyes?

1 Solid goalkeeping (for Tepi read Rudd)
2 Central midfield authority (for Gregan read Welsh)
3 Fast and skilful wing play (for Eyres/Cartwright read Monakana, Holmes, Hayhurst and Humphrey)
4 Mobile, skilful forward players (for Macken and Nogan read Beavon and, hopefully, Garner)

Admittedly the introduction of Angell late in the season was an ultimately inspired move and it may be nice to have that option. But I don't think its absolutely necessary at present. If I see a weakness, its probably central midfield where we've yet to see a combination with the potential of Rankine and Gregan. Maybe Mousinho can step up and partner Welsh to provide the box to box energy that Rankine provided with the some of the stauture of a Gregan. I don't think we particularly need creativity there as we have plenty on the flanks, esp with Laird returning. Wroe is a luxury player in my opinion but we need that solid base through the centre.

I think that we have the right types of players to succees - the question is whether Grayson can get the consistent required quality out of the likes of Garner and Mousinho. I'm not prepared to write either of them off just yet - if they are fit and ready for pre-season and fail to make an impact before Christmas then they're under question but, for now, they're in the frame and deserve a chance as far as I'm concerned.

I am not willing to write off Mousinho as well, against Colchester in the first game of the season he looked decent and think he has either been played without the correct midfield partner or has suffered from lack of confidence because of the boo boys, also he has had a torrid time with injuries.

The problem lies with that Welsh is a better player and I would have him playing there any day of the week, but if we were to play 4-5-1 with 2 sitting midfielders and Wroe pushed further forward Mousinho could be a useful player as he has a good shot on him and always makes himself available. I just hope people don't boo him come the beginning of the season because that helps nobody.

Rudd

Keane - Huntington - Wright - Laird

Welsh - Mousinho

Humphrey - Wroe - Holmes

Beavon

That looks a good starting line up for the tough games away from home (Wolves, Coventry, Bristol) at home I would expect us to go more attacking with either 4-4-2 or 4-1-2-1-2
 
Rudd

Keane - Huntington - Wright - Laird

Welsh - Mousinho

Humphrey - Wroe - Holmes

Beavon

That looks a good starting line up for the tough games away from home

No - that looks like Beavon running himself silly upfront with no support. Nothing wrong with the idea of a lone striker in some games but that formation requires a centre forward who can hold the ball up - precisely the type of forward player we don't possess. But why be so negative. Why not go out with the confidence to play a 4.4.2 formation with two stikers upfront. With Welsh and, say, either of King or Mousinho in the centre and at least one or other of Holmes and Hayhurst on oneo of the flanks that ought to be possible.
 
As I've said on more than one occasion, even with the massive drag factor of Westley, we were knocking in a fair few goals early last season with a number of players contributing. The problem came when Westley utterly failed to compensate for the loss of Laird and Keane and from then on we offered very little going forward.

Grayson's challenge is to maintain the improvements made at the back whilst making is a more potent attacking force. No doubt Laird could be important in this.

More bodies would be nice but I wouldn't be unhappy going in to the season with what we've got now. I don't see a hugely pressing need for a big man.

Another thought. How did we get out of this division under Moyes?

1 Solid goalkeeping (for Tepi read Rudd)
2 Central midfield authority (for Gregan read Welsh)
3 Fast and skilful wing play (for Eyres/Cartwright read Monakana, Holmes, Hayhurst and Humphrey)
4 Mobile, skilful forward players (for Macken and Nogan read Beavon and, hopefully, Garner)


Admittedly the introduction of Angell late in the season was an ultimately inspired move and it may be nice to have that option. But I don't think its absolutely necessary at present. If I see a weakness, its probably central midfield where we've yet to see a combination with the potential of Rankine and Gregan. Maybe Mousinho can step up and partner Welsh to provide the box to box energy that Rankine provided with the some of the stauture of a Gregan. I don't think we particularly need creativity there as we have plenty on the flanks, esp with Laird returning. Wroe is a luxury player in my opinion but we need that solid base through the centre.

I think that we have the right types of players to succees - the question is whether Grayson can get the consistent required quality out of the likes of Garner and Mousinho. I'm not prepared to write either of them off just yet - if they are fit and ready for pre-season and fail to make an impact before Christmas then they're under question but, for now, they're in the frame and deserve a chance as far as I'm concerned.

Much as I admire your optimism, we have no-one in this squad of the class of Gregan, Eyres, Macken or Nogan.
 
well i'm assuming we're getting a striker as a premier league striker on loan has been promised for some time now. Beavon got twenty odd goals for a relegated side the season before he joined us so i'd like to think if he avoids injuries and gets good service from midfield he can be a 20+ goal a season striker for us.
i wouldn't mind another central midfielder who can get around 10 goals that's why i'm disapointed we were never in for Steven Schumacher (as far as i know) he is far too good for league 2.
 
1 Solid goalkeeping (for Tepi read Rudd)
2 Central midfield authority (for Gregan read Welsh)
3 Fast and skilful wing play (for Eyres/Cartwright read Monakana, Holmes, Hayhurst and Humphrey)
4 Mobile, skilful forward players (for Macken and Nogan read Beavon and, hopefully, Garner)

I don't think I've pissed myself so hard in years - nice one fella!
 
Back
Top