Skip to main content

What? No PNE players?

What? No PNE players?

Joined
Feb 12, 2005
Messages
6,007
The PFA SkyBet Championship Team of the Year 2016

GK- Tom Heaton (Burnley)
RB - Bruno Saltor (Brighton)
CB - Michael Keane (Burnley)
CB - Michael Dawson (Hull City) / Daniel Ayala (Middlesbrough)
LB - George Friend (Middlesbrough)
Mid - Alan Judge (Brentford)
Mid - Joey Barton (Burnley)
Mid - Barry Bannan (Sheff Wed)
Mid - Adam Clayton (Middlesbrough)
CF - Andre Gray (Burnley)
CF - Ross McCormack (Fulham)
 
Cunningham or Gallagher would have been likely, but when you have Friend, Robertson who play for the big clubs. What chance have we got?! Same with Gally, look at the midfield all up there albeit Judge. Who is a cracking player anyway.
 
The PFA SkyBet Championship Team of the Year 2016

GK- Tom Heaton (Burnley)
RB - Bruno Saltor (Brighton)
CB - Michael Keane (Burnley)
CB - Michael Dawson (Hull City) / Daniel Ayala (Middlesbrough)
LB - George Friend (Middlesbrough)
Mid - Alan Judge (Brentford)
Mid - Joey Barton (Burnley)
Mid - Barry Bannan (Sheff Wed)
Mid - Adam Clayton (Middlesbrough)
CF - Andre Gray (Burnley)
CF - Ross McCormack (Fulham)

Who would you replace for one of our players and why? I think if they made a 2nd XI we still wouldn't have a player in.. no big deal.
 
I cant see any of our players displacing any of that lot. That team would be able to hold its own in the Premier League. Our season has been more about the collective more than any stand out players. Maybe Pickford would have been in if he had been with us all season?
 
No arguments with that team to be honest.

As good as Cunningham has been for us, George Friend is better.
 
The PFA SkyBet Championship Team of the Year 2016

GK- Tom Heaton (Burnley)
RB - Bruno Saltor (Brighton)
CB - Michael Keane (Burnley)
CB - Michael Dawson (Hull City) / Daniel Ayala (Middlesbrough)
LB - George Friend (Middlesbrough)
Mid - Alan Judge (Brentford)
Mid - Joey Barton (Burnley)
Mid - Barry Bannan (Sheff Wed)
Mid - Adam Clayton (Middlesbrough)
CF - Andre Gray (Burnley)
CF - Ross McCormack (Fulham)

Can't argue with many of those names, apart from Heaton. IMO he is an average goalkeeper, yes he's not conceeded many this season, but he's had a great defence in front of him. You just need to look at Will Keane's goal against him at Turf Moor, very poor goalkeeping. How he is on the England list is madness & shows how much attention they pay to individual performances rather than just seeing goals conceeded. That or there isn't many other English GK options. I think already Pickford is a much better GK and the England set up see him first hand, he does a great job for the U21's.
 
Can't argue with that team. Looks spot on.

Heaton is quality, but if Pickford would've remained here for the season I reckon he would've been in with a shout for the keeping spot.

Who would you replace for one of our players and why? I think if they made a 2nd XI we still wouldn't have a player in.. no big deal.

I think the thread title was tongue in cheek.
 
If Pickford had stayed he would have been chosen. Far superior to Heaton in every department. Other than that, nobody would come even close.
 
Surprised Bannan is in there tbh.

Talking to dingles fans at work, they say Gray will definitely not be their player of the year. Most likely be Mee or Barton.
 
Surprised Bannan is in there tbh.

Talking to dingles fans at work, they say Gray will definitely not be their player of the year. Most likely be Mee or Barton.

Gray has been superb but Barton has been the heartbeat of our team all season long, absolutely my player of the year.

In reference to Heaton further up, he is an exceptionally consistent goalkeeper, rarely if ever makes an error and is a commanding presence in the box. Having been a part of the England set up for a year now (third choice or not) proves his performance levels.

One omission for me in that team is Beram Kayal from Brighton, I would have had him in the middle alongside Barton - fabulous player.
 
No doubt Heaton deserves his place. No slight on him whatsoever. Just saying that Pickford is a much better keeper. Has the potential to be world class and that's not an overstatement.
 
No doubt Heaton deserves his place. No slight on him whatsoever. Just saying that Pickford is a much better keeper. Has the potential to be world class and that's not an overstatement.

Can only comment on him in the 0-2 win for you but what struck me with Pickford (besides making a phenomenal point blank save from Vokes) was his kicking. I am not exaggerating when I say I have never seen distribution like that from a keeper at this level before, so I totally saw his potential.
 
Can only comment on him in the 0-2 win for you but what struck me with Pickford (besides making a phenomenal point blank save from Vokes) was his kicking. I am not exaggerating when I say I have never seen distribution like that from a keeper at this level before, so I totally saw his potential.

Agreed. That wasn't a one off. He did that every game. Incredible talent.
 
Can only comment on him in the 0-2 win for you but what struck me with Pickford (besides making a phenomenal point blank save from Vokes) was his kicking. I am not exaggerating when I say I have never seen distribution like that from a keeper at this level before, so I totally saw his potential.

Interesting article from City's head coach for goalkeeping http://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/spor...an-city-monitoring-sunderlands-young-10812283 mentioning his passing skills and not just clearances.
 
What? No PNE players?

Can only comment on him in the 0-2 win for you but what struck me with Pickford (besides making a phenomenal point blank save from Vokes) was his kicking. I am not exaggerating when I say I have never seen distribution like that from a keeper at this level before, so I totally saw his potential.

It was weird, in his first game he launched one from the penalty spot to the edge of the other box with amazing accuracy and there was almost a collective "wtf was that?" from the crowd?

He repeated it the next time as well... And the time after...

Oh and Bannan is the best player in the league. According to the Sheff Wed fans.
 
Can't argue with many of those names, apart from Heaton. IMO he is an average goalkeeper, yes he's not conceeded many this season, but he's had a great defence in front of him. You just need to look at Will Keane's goal against him at Turf Moor, very poor goalkeeping. How he is on the England list is madness & shows how much attention they pay to individual performances rather than just seeing goals conceeded. That or there isn't many other English GK options. I think already Pickford is a much better GK and the England set up see him first hand, he does a great job for the U21's.

Seems to me like you are paying too much attention to individual performances. No doubt he has made a mistake there, doesn't make him a bad keeper.
 
Back
Top