Skip to main content

Where did it all go wrong?

Where did it all go wrong?

Joined
May 11, 2009
Messages
5,667
The simple answer is the sheer limitations of the squad. And I think Grayson was all too well aware of that fact going into these playoffs. We were a work in progress who simply werent as good as the top four teams in the division. Caning relegation boys like Carlisle and Shrewsbury last month, is not the same as a play off semi final against a hungry and hard working Rotherham side.

Grayson did a great job of pruning the team he inherited in the past year. The fact utter gash like Beardsley, Mousinho, Byrom, Cummins, Procter etc were ever signed in the first place is what iritates me. Grayson certainly seemed to know who to get rid of and who to retain. [Hopefully he can make similar wise decisions this coming summer]

Obviously, some of grayson's signings have been abject failures. Kevin Davies will hopefully retire this summer (3 league goals is a pitiful return for a target man). Wiseman will hopefully be moved on (he is an utter liability defensively). Humphrey has been hit and miss which I could forgive if he was a youngster. But he turns 27 years old later this year - he simply isn't going to improve.

But, on the positive side: Clarke has been a man mountain at the back and is comfortable at both CB and RB - a really good signing. Kilkenny is a solid midielder at this level who can make us tick on his day - I just think he needs the right partner (Welsh isn't that man). Browne seems like an excellent signing who could be a crucial player for us next season.

If we can move on more of Westley's crap signings then we may be able to come back much stronger next season. I think we all know the likes of Keane, Holmes, King, Huntingdon etc are fairly limited footballers skill wise. They aren't exactly suitable for a team seeking automatic promotion. Squad members at best. But more like League Two fodder IMHO much like many GW's 'die hard, walk through walls' signings.

If we can keep hold of Rudd it would be great and Stuckmann is solid back up. Keep Bailey-Wright, Clarke, Laird, Buchanen in defence. Keep Kilkenny, Brownhill, Browne, Welsh in midfield and offer Gallagher a deal if he wants one. Keep Garner and Beavon as striking options. (although Grayson doesnt seem to give Beavon much of a look in)

I would try to offload the rest. (maybe keep King and Keane out of the rejects if need be - simply because they can both play multiple positions) I think we could certainly see a drastically different looking starting XI playing here next season. I do hope so anyway. I just don't think the squad we have right now, is capable of much more than what they acheived this year.

We desperately need a steady right back who can overlap and maybe score the odd goal. The midfield is crying out for some pace and ability to beat a man on the flanks. Whilst up front we need a mobile target man who can turn faster than a London bus. But someone not called Davies would be a start.

Tonight was a nightmare of a game to watch. Felt numb for a few hours afterward. And I am disappointed with the team selection and tactical mentality. But there are a lot of positives about this season as a whole. And whilst we may have sadly lost our one true legend this year, we certainly regained some of our lost pride.
 
Think we're all the same RE the numbness, but if we needed to look at were things went wrong, for me, it was our home form.

Time and time again conceding in the last minutes, Coventry, Colchester, Tranmere amongst others. Almost happened v Vale when we were comfortably ahead, we're our own worst enemy at times, I hate to say it I do, but we don't learn from our mistakes.

Edit: Agree with some of your post though, the Clarke bit especially.
 
Last edited:
Graysons pussy-footing around cost us dearly in the end.

Not calling for him to be fired off but next season I want to see more fight/attack and less defend.
 
Graysons pussy-footing around cost us dearly in the end.

Not calling for him to be fired off but next season I want to see more fight/attack and less defend.

A leopard doesn't change his spots. That is Grayson's game, he is a cautious man and he won't change his style.

We need to stick with him, changing managers doesn't do much good in the long run. I think he should be a bit more analytical in his signings, tends to go for players who have played for him before, and that hasn't worked out.

I think he inherited a pretty dire squad from GW, but now season is over there will be mass departures and hopefully some decent additions. Signing the likes of Humphrey, Kilkenny, Davies and Wiseman are only papering over cracks. Don't think any of them have been inspirational, just mediocre but better than the ones loaned out.
 
I agree we have witnessed the team capitulate leads at Deepdale far too often. Partly this is because of Graysons style of defending leads, rather than going for another goal. But he does have those three previous promotions from this league in the bag so I am not sure he can be totally to blame.

I just think we have a squad that simply isn't good enough to overpower teams for 90 mins whether that be home or away. We don't score enough league goals from across the team. Laird scored once in the league all season. Humphrey got 3. Keane got 1. Welsh got 2. Kilkenny got 2. Holmes got 3. Don't get me started on K Davies three measly goals. Apart from Garner and Gallagher we don't really have anyone who can score regularly from open play.

Some may argue this is down to Grayson's tactics. And to some degree thats fair to say. But I still feel the current squad is extremely limited in terms of its individuals. Grayson has to remedy this problem over the summer.
 
It sounds really harsh, and I hate singling one player out, but I genuinely believe that if Kevin Davies didn't play for us this season we'd have gone up automatically. Beginning of the season he played and kept Garner or Beavon out of the side... when he plays we play in a totally different fashion and it cost us in a lot of the home games that he was playing in. I'll probably get grief for this post, but it's true.

It's no excuse either because it must be the same for all teams in this league (or at least you would think) but the standard of officiating in this league over the course of the season has been an absolute disgrace. I've never seen as many bad officials in one season.

Last one is luck. Mainly against Rotherham last night, we had zero luck. They had 2 shots which hit the post and went in, we hit the post twice and it bounced out twice, and also the Welsh shot/keeper fumble was ridiculously lucky. That kinda luck goes for us and we score 4 goals on the night. Over the season we've not had much luck at all when it comes to them kinda things. (Mike Bassett England Manager is just in my head with this point)

In all fairness to Grayson & the lads, our points total this season would've sent us up as Champions last season, other teams have just stepped up as well and there's been some fantastic sides at the top of the league. Nothing we can do about that.

As long as we stick with Simon, I think he'll change the minority of things that need changing in pre-season and we'll have a squad capable of going up automatically... or at least I hope we do, there's no way I can hack them damned play offs again.
 
It sounds really harsh, and I hate singling one player out, but I genuinely believe that if Kevin Davies didn't play for us this season we'd have gone up automatically. Beginning of the season he played and kept Garner or Beavon out of the side... when he plays we play in a totally different fashion and it cost us in a lot of the home games that he was playing in. I'll probably get grief for this post, but it's true.
I agree with the statement in bold completely. At our best we play some one touch passing through midfield into our strikers feet and this works when the likes of Kilkenny, Gallagher, Garner, Beavon and Brownhill are involved. But with Kevin Davies upfront it becomes all about knockdowns and winning 50/50 balls, which against a team like Rotherham is always gonna be difficult. Our play becomes one dimensional and the overall game becomes more direct because the opposition clear their lines and we continue to try to find Kevin's head. Am I right in thinking Davies did not score one header this season? I know I saw him miss about 15 at deepdale. For someone who is supposed to be a towering prescence in the box, he seems to struggle to beat any one to the ball these days.
 
I agree with the statement in bold completely. At our best we play some one touch passing through midfield into our strikers feet and this works when the likes of Kilkenny, Gallagher, Garner, Beavon and Brownhill are involved. But with Kevin Davies upfront it becomes all about knockdowns and winning 50/50 balls, which against a team like Rotherham is always gonna be difficult. Our play becomes one dimensional and the overall game becomes more direct because the opposition clear their lines and we continue to try to find Kevin's head. Am I right in thinking Davies did not score one header this season? I know I saw him miss about 15 at deepdale. For someone who is supposed to be a towering prescence in the box, he seems to struggle to beat any one to the ball these days.

It's going to cost a few bob to get shut of him, yet I don't think he is needed and should be moved on.
 
It's going to cost a few bob to get shut of him, yet I don't think he is needed and should be moved on.

How long was his contract? Also I agree with the OP. The way to get promotion IMO is with a fast paced keep it on the deck style of play. KD is not suited for this and as such we become very one dimensional. Although he did steady our play at the start of the season, even in defence but we do need to change and quick.
 
How long was his contract? Also I agree with the OP. The way to get promotion IMO is with a fast paced keep it on the deck style of play. KD is not suited for this and as such we become very one dimensional. Although he did steady our play at the start of the season, even in defence but we do need to change and quick.

Two years I believe, so 12 months left.
 
The sad fact of the matter is that we haven't got enough quality in our squad. We need to improve. Rotherham United looked far stronger than us over the two play off matches and fully deserved to beat us. Back to square one once again. PNE reaching the play offs ?? It's a recipe for utter disaster.
 
They wanted it more.

From their chairman, to their board of directors, through to their management and their players, they wanted it more and fought harder for it.

Give it a shake up Trevor, from yourself downwards.

Not just about players.
 
Rotherham were a better side over 46 matches. It clearly didn't take a corporate-greedy-bastards-milk-the-gullible-fans bullshit play-off tournament to prove it.
 
I honestly feel we are not far away. 3 or 4 additions, a bit of luck with injuries again and I feel we'll be challenging the for top 2!!!
 
It's probably easy to look at players and who needs to go etc but sg needs to look at performances against specific sides. Two things strike me most.
1. Lost points with last minute draws. We have to develop a better strategy for closing games out.
2. Certain teams play well against us.why? How did Crewe do the double over us? They, Rotherham, wolves and brentford played us with high intensity and we couldn't cope. We didn't answer that with our own intensity.
Time to look at injecting pace and that intensity with a Steiger approach to last ten minutes.
I don't think we're far away with the players.
 
I said as soon as the game had finished walking from the ground, our first mistake was not getting a result at Crewe, 2nd was playing wiseman and buchs last night, they had not had 90 mins between them for a long time, someone said on a different thread that Grayson didn't know his best eleven, I would agree with that going off the fact that in the first leg he played C Davies and Browne and then second leg they weren't even in the squad, Brownhill comes on in the second leg who hasn't been in the squad and as I've already said he starts with Wiseman and Buchs, easy to play manager tho, I believe we will go up automatically next season as long as there is an infection of pace into the side.
 
Last edited:
The simple answer is the sheer limitations of the squad. And I think Grayson was all too well aware of that fact going into these playoffs. We were a work in progress who simply werent as good as the top four teams in the division. Caning relegation boys like Carlisle and Shrewsbury last month, is not the same as a play off semi final against a hungry and hard working Rotherham side.

Grayson did a great job of pruning the team he inherited in the past year. The fact utter gash like Beardsley, Mousinho, Byrom, Cummins, Procter etc were ever signed in the first place is what iritates me. Grayson certainly seemed to know who to get rid of and who to retain. [Hopefully he can make similar wise decisions this coming summer]

Obviously, some of grayson's signings have been abject failures. Kevin Davies will hopefully retire this summer (3 league goals is a pitiful return for a target man). Wiseman will hopefully be moved on (he is an utter liability defensively). Humphrey has been hit and miss which I could forgive if he was a youngster. But he turns 27 years old later this year - he simply isn't going to improve.

But, on the positive side: Clarke has been a man mountain at the back and is comfortable at both CB and RB - a really good signing. Kilkenny is a solid midielder at this level who can make us tick on his day - I just think he needs the right partner (Welsh isn't that man). Browne seems like an excellent signing who could be a crucial player for us next season.

If we can move on more of Westley's crap signings then we may be able to come back much stronger next season. I think we all know the likes of Keane, Holmes, King, Huntingdon etc are fairly limited footballers skill wise. They aren't exactly suitable for a team seeking automatic promotion. Squad members at best. But more like League Two fodder IMHO much like many GW's 'die hard, walk through walls' signings.

If we can keep hold of Rudd it would be great and Stuckmann is solid back up. Keep Bailey-Wright, Clarke, Laird, Buchanen in defence. Keep Kilkenny, Brownhill, Browne, Welsh in midfield and offer Gallagher a deal if he wants one. Keep Garner and Beavon as striking options. (although Grayson doesnt seem to give Beavon much of a look in)

I would try to offload the rest. (maybe keep King and Keane out of the rejects if need be - simply because they can both play multiple positions) I think we could certainly see a drastically different looking starting XI playing here next season. I do hope so anyway. I just don't think the squad we have right now, is capable of much more than what they acheived this year.

We desperately need a steady right back who can overlap and maybe score the odd goal. The midfield is crying out for some pace and ability to beat a man on the flanks. Whilst up front we need a mobile target man who can turn faster than a London bus. But someone not called Davies would be a start.

Tonight was a nightmare of a game to watch. Felt numb for a few hours afterward. And I am disappointed with the team selection and tactical mentality. But there are a lot of positives about this season as a whole. And whilst we may have sadly lost our one true legend this year, we certainly regained some of our lost pride.

I can't disagree with much of that, if any really.

We were lacking up front, we all knew that, without a sensational run from Garner from November onwards we wouldn't have been near the PO's in the first place. Thats why we brough C Davies in.

A small clear out needed, the entire right side needs a big looking at for me and an injection of pace and power is needed. Something we lack right across the midfield.

For me it's always difficult to tell who our captain is during a game, there are rarely any rollockings - even when we concede there's the odd finger pointed but thats it. There's no one to drag us out of a sticky situation in a game with a massive tackle or a surging run.

2 new CB's needed for me. King has to be a squad player at best next season, and it seems Huntington will be leaving.

So, new RB, 2 new CB's, a RW and a striker needed.

I wouldn't sign Gallagher. Too many flicks and tricks in situations when its not needed, and his missed header last night summed him up a little bit, it was almost like he expected to be clattered so didn't attack it with any purpose.

Hard not to knee jerk a little bit after that defeat but we've come a long way, but there's still a fair way to go yet.
 
I can't disagree with much of that, if any really.

We were lacking up front, we all knew that, without a sensational run from Garner from November onwards we wouldn't have been near the PO's in the first place. Thats why we brough C Davies in.

A small clear out needed, the entire right side needs a big looking at for me and an injection of pace and power is needed. Something we lack right across the midfield.

For me it's always difficult to tell who our captain is during a game, there are rarely any rollockings - even when we concede there's the odd finger pointed but thats it. There's no one to drag us out of a sticky situation in a game with a massive tackle or a surging run.

2 new CB's needed for me. King has to be a squad player at best next season, and it seems Huntington will be leaving.

So, new RB, 2 new CB's, a RW and a striker needed.

I wouldn't sign Gallagher. Too many flicks and tricks in situations when its not needed, and his missed header last night summed him up a little bit, it was almost like he expected to be clattered so didn't attack it with any purpose.

Hard not to knee jerk a little bit after that defeat but we've come a long way, but there's still a fair way to go yet.

Think I'm just going to copy and paste this on every thread.
 
Back
Top