Skip to main content

Why do we moan so much?

Why do we moan so much?

Status
Not open for further replies.

northendmanc

Analytical annoyance
Joined
Jun 7, 2015
Messages
1,593
Location
Manchester
So. I'm bored of our stupid moaning. Almost every thread explains how stupid our club's commercial team is, because they haven't figured out that simply adopting Bradford-esque season ticket prices to generate huge amount of cash. Or how if only we didn't have such a useless manager/chairman/owner then we'd be putting in a bid for Ronaldo. So let's bust some myths.

Myth 1. Our season tickets are too expensive, and we'd make lots more money if they were cheaper. So, it might be true that charging less would increase sales. But imagine a situation where we sold tickets at the same price as Bradford City, £149. If we sold every single seat in the ground, except the Kop (all 17,404 - which, by the way, would be terrible for the club), then we'd make £2.6m in ticket sales. I'm not sure the average season ticket price, but it's probably around £450. We need to sell 5,763 to make the same income, lower than the number we currently sell (6,072 in 2014/15). And the real kicker is that if you sell all your seats for £149, you can't sell any of the rest of them. So once the club has made the same revenue as Bradford off the 5,763 seats it sells at £450, it can also sell the other c.5,000 it sells each week (some as season tickets, and some as on the day - probably generating almost £100k per home game - another £2m).

The facts: while it might be nicer to have a ground with fewer empty seats, the club probably have the commercial arrangements right - generating the maximum possible money from the fan base we have.

Myth 2. Our useless owner/chairman/manager stop us being in the big league. The club made a loss of £3.2m in 2014/15. Every so often the owner very kindly puts his hand in his pocket and writes off the debts that these losses make us. That means that every penny we spend on players, both in wages and transfer fees, is cash that Trev has to dip into his pocket. So far from him meanly stealing the Joe Garner transfer fee, if we didn't buy anyone else he doesn't get to keep it - he just doesn't have to cough up quite as much to plug the gap this year... If we buy a £10m striker, and pay them £20k per week for three years, that's £13m of Trev's money he has to stump up. He's supposed to be worth £900m and he's already spending something like £5m each year.

The facts: we're bloody lucky to have someone willing to plug the gap to the extent that they are. We would be bankrupt if we weren't supported to the extent we are, let alone asking for more. The alternative is to find a new owner. We could rename the club, stadium, sell our soul, and probably go bankrupt, after some multi-billionaire that made their money in the Middle East or Russia comes in for a while. And maybe one day that will happen, but we'll be lucky to have Trevor until then.

Myth 3. We are so small time because we don't have electronic tickets. GET OVER YOURSELVES. See the point above. Given a choice between the investment that Trev is making going into players and other things, I know what I'd choose.

The facts: it's a choice. We already moan about the lack of investment in the playing team. Would you rather they spent it on a turnstile? There are so many things that are more important than this. A scouting system. A decent academy. A proper training facility. Need I go on?


Add yours below...
 
Some good points about the season ticket comparison to Bradford - whatever Bradford are doing, it hasn't made their team successful as they are still in the 3rd tier.
But I don't recall anyone ever suggesting uncle trev has 'stolen' the garner transfer money.
 
Myth 1 - a fair percentage of our season ticket holders are concessions or free gratis. I am wondering why we had bigger attendances in league one than so far in the championship this year. We seem to be losing fans by the season. I'd say we are 2k down ATM - pricing is significant. Hudds sold their tickets at £179 and now average just under 20k. Worth a thought at least. We have a MK Dons atmosphere at Deepdale and it's getting worse.

No problem with Myth 2 or 3.
 
Some good points about the season ticket comparison to Bradford - whatever Bradford are doing, it hasn't made their team successful as they are still in the 3rd tier.
But I don't recall anyone ever suggesting uncle trev has 'stolen' the garner transfer money.

If not stolen, there are certainly suggestions of misappropriation (sp?) at the very least...
 
Basically because of the lavish spending of other clubs people think we should follow suit when in fact we have had recent success without spending outside of our means.

Grayson didn't get to sign players like Gallagher, Beckford, DJ, Cunningham, Lindegaard, Pearson and Grimshaw as soon as he got here we had to build that steadily by spending within our means, increasing revenue or saving what we have so we don't go into debt.

I think the nervousness of possible relegation makes people panic and think we have to sign sign sign, the possibility is always there spending money doesn't make it disappear.
 
So. I'm bored of our stupid moaning. Almost every thread explains how stupid our club's commercial team is, because they haven't figured out that simply adopting Bradford-esque season ticket prices to generate huge amount of cash. Or how if only we didn't have such a useless manager/chairman/owner then we'd be putting in a bid for Ronaldo. So let's bust some myths.

Myth 1. Our season tickets are too expensive, and we'd make lots more money if they were cheaper. So, it might be true that charging less would increase sales. But imagine a situation where we sold tickets at the same price as Bradford City, £149. If we sold every single seat in the ground, except the Kop (all 17,404 - which, by the way, would be terrible for the club), then we'd make £2.6m in ticket sales. I'm not sure the average season ticket price, but it's probably around £450. We need to sell 5,763 to make the same income, lower than the number we currently sell (6,072 in 2014/15). And the real kicker is that if you sell all your seats for £149, you can't sell any of the rest of them. So once the club has made the same revenue as Bradford off the 5,763 seats it sells at £450, it can also sell the other c.5,000 it sells each week (some as season tickets, and some as on the day - probably generating almost £100k per home game - another £2m).

The facts: while it might be nicer to have a ground with fewer empty seats, the club probably have the commercial arrangements right - generating the maximum possible money from the fan base we have.

Myth 2. Our useless owner/chairman/manager stop us being in the big league. The club made a loss of £3.2m in 2014/15. Every so often the owner very kindly puts his hand in his pocket and writes off the debts that these losses make us. That means that every penny we spend on players, both in wages and transfer fees, is cash that Trev has to dip into his pocket. So far from him meanly stealing the Joe Garner transfer fee, if we didn't buy anyone else he doesn't get to keep it - he just doesn't have to cough up quite as much to plug the gap this year... If we buy a £10m striker, and pay them £20k per week for three years, that's £13m of Trev's money he has to stump up. He's supposed to be worth £900m and he's already spending something like £5m each year.

The facts: we're bloody lucky to have someone willing to plug the gap to the extent that they are. We would be bankrupt if we weren't supported to the extent we are, let alone asking for more. The alternative is to find a new owner. We could rename the club, stadium, sell our soul, and probably go bankrupt, after some multi-billionaire that made their money in the Middle East or Russia comes in for a while. And maybe one day that will happen, but we'll be lucky to have Trevor until then.

Myth 3. We are so small time because we don't have electronic tickets. GET OVER YOURSELVES. See the point above. Given a choice between the investment that Trev is making going into players and other things, I know what I'd choose.

The facts: it's a choice. We already moan about the lack of investment in the playing team. Would you rather they spent it on a turnstile? There are so many things that are more important than this. A scouting system. A decent academy. A proper training facility. Need I go on?


Add yours below...

Welcome to the forum Peter. 😉

People have a right to moan as it is your right to support everything the club do.

The reason people moan is because they love the club. The club which we put hundreds if not thousands of pounds a year into. A club which whilst is heavily reliant on the owner would not survive without the supporters either. If the football club remain unchallenged then they can do what ever they please.

Point one - Season tickets.

Personally I understand why we do not sell season tickets for £149, however the football clubs reliance on the core support renewing is a poor strategy. We do absolutely nothing to entice new fans on Deepdale, the failed ambassador scheme being the number one supporter of this. Our stadium is more than half empty most weeks. The weekly attendance is dropping not improving the longer we are in this league. This HAS to be addressed or the club we die on its arse. We simply can not afford to just assume that the 5/6000 will renew every year which seems to be what they are doing at the moment.

Football is too expensive full stop.

Point Two - The Owner

I believe that TJH is still reeling from the money that Alan Irvine wasted, a time when the former chairman operated a unsustainable financial model in which he assumed we could spend what ever and just get Trevor to loan us more money. This has done to death though, we are where we are. Without the owner we would have no club. I'm grateful for his backing, it is his money and he can do what he wants with it. However I wish he would do more, he could bank roll us, he chooses not to. Like I say that is his choice. However i find it totally understandable that folk get frustrated when we piss clubs about with derisory offers for players that we clearly could actually afford to buy and then lose out at the last minute. Selling Joe Garner makes sense but only if that money is reinvested in the team.

I'll end this point with the note that PNE have sold season tickets with Premier League logo's all over the adverts, offering FREE Premier League football if we get there. We all know its hard for us to compete but whilst the club do offers like this it only puts more pressure on them to show some ambition.

Point 3 - Electronic Ticketing.

This should have been introduced many years ago. Everyone can see that our ticketing service is out dated. We couldn't cope when 500 folk turned up at 7:15 for a match when 4,000 attended. Our online ticket site is shite and hardly ever works. We have massive paper season ticket books whilst the half time draw is computerised. Relating back to point one, we could offer far better incentives for fans if everyone who wanted one could get a ticket card. Match by Match uploading online, avoiding queuing, tracking which games folk attend. Sell tickets in blocks, half/full season tickets. It would take huge pressure off the ticket office, reduce staff levels, save money. The putting money into the team argument is flawed. This should be something that is done to compliment the fact we should be a forward looking football club. You talk like it would cost millions, it wouldn't. It is 2016 not 1968.

Yes there are many things Peter has got right since coming to PNE, ultimately the club is in a far better place, obviously the league shows that. However this shouldn't stop us from commenting on areas where things can be improved.
 
Last edited:
..... But I doubt any of the garner money has actually hit the bank account yet.

In all honesty , that money won't be used to buy any players...

We are only getting the first 750k upfront and then another 750k in 12 months.....
 
Couldn't agree more with what JK has said. People don't moan because they have an agenda against the club blah blah blah etc. It's because the love the club and want to see it move forwards and do as well as it can.

The last few years have been a resounding success on the pitch in terms of results.

However the club is still lagging behind in many ways off the field. Commercially I don't feel that we're in a great place right now and as someone said on another thread, sometimes it seems like we're a Championship football team with League 2 standard ticketing, customer service and marketing/social media presence. It saddens me to see the ground half empty at times in spite of recent success.

Imho the club has come a long way since PR came in but there's still a lot of work to be done.
 
Welcome to the forum Peter. 😉

People have a right to moan as it is your right to support everything the club do.

Fair 🙂 I obviously wish things were different sometimes. I'd love a better atmosphere. And tickets to be cheaper. And us to have better players. And to win the league.

It's sad we don't have those things, but sometimes the gripes get a bit repetitive, that's all! I think the club do a pretty good job given the circumstances we're in and I'm not sure that any of us would do anything massively different if we actually had the keys to the door and a mere only £900m to our name 😉
 
I think it's Human nature to under appreciate what you've got and to take things for granted.

Threads like this are as important to balance as the criticism the club receives.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
We seem to be losing fans by the season.

Our current average at this level (after only 2 home games) is simply following a well worn pattern of a PNE team promoted from the third tier and in it's second season at the higher level. ie good gates during the first season after promotion, then it starts to drop.

1971/72 first season after said promotion.........15,136.
1972/73 second season after promotion............10,199.

1978/79 first season after promotion................12,117.
1979/80 second season after promotion............9,751.
1980/81 third season after promotion...............7,631. (relegation season also to offer balance).

And the last time we were promoted it took longer for the gates to drop, but drop they did.

200/01 first season after promotion...........14,530. Then a gradually fluctuation until:
2010/11 (granted a relegation season)........11,768.

When we have eventually played teams at home such as Newcastle, Villa, Leeds, Sheffield Wednesday and a few other of the teams that are either more attractive opposition, or will bring more fans that Fulham (as an example) I am sure our home average will climb considerably.

They may or may not reach last seasons 13,035, but somewhere in that vicinity I would think.
 
I think it's Human nature to under appreciate what you've got and to take things for granted.

Threads like this are as important to balance as the criticism the club receives.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Well said bogie ... we may find that this thread may well disappear down the page quickly without much comment ... Bumped!!!!
 
I pretty much agree with everything there, I don't think that mega cheap season tickets are the way forward.

I do think the club could look at price it a bit lower, with a statement about how they've tried to make it more affordable whilst staying competitive but I also understand the risk involved in this as they'd just lose money if hardly any extra buyers where enticed into parting with their cash. When it comes to season tickets the only real criticism is the lack of pushing them. People have posted on here recently stating they didn't renew and the club haven't approached them to ask why, that is very poor in my opinion.

Nothing makes me more angry than seeing ill educated morons having a go at Hemmings for not spending silly money, he already puts enough in and whilst this might not actually be the case, if I was him I'd be pretty disappointed that there aren't more North End supporters willing to put their own bit of money in by coming to home games. Unfortunately I think we do have quite a few casual fans that can't see past the fact that other clubs charge less. I have seen some despicable things said about Hemmings, more so on Facebook than here. We should be nothing but thankful to him as we'd be knackered without him at present and in the past 10+ years.

Lets get things in perspective, the club isn't perfect by any means but it could be a LOT worse. Look at the Lashers and the Plastics. Both have become a shambles at best and both are now well behind us off the field and both will more than likely be at least one level below us on the pitch next season.
 
Welcome to the forum Peter. 😉

People have a right to moan as it is your right to support everything the club do.

The reason people moan is because they love the club. The club which we put hundreds if not thousands of pounds a year into. A club which whilst is heavily reliant on the owner would not survive without the supporters either. If the football club remain unchallenged then they can do what ever they please.

Point one - Season tickets.

Personally I understand why we do not sell season tickets for £149, however the football clubs reliance on the core support renewing is a poor strategy. We do absolutely nothing to entice new fans on Deepdale, the failed ambassador scheme being the number one supporter of this. Our stadium is more than half empty most weeks. The weekly attendance is dropping not improving the longer we are in this league. This HAS to be addressed or the club we die on its arse. We simply can not afford to just assume that the 5/6000 will renew every year which seems to be what they are doing at the moment.

Football is too expensive full stop.

Point Two - The Owner

I believe that TJH is still reeling from the money that Alan Irvine wasted, a time when the former chairman operated a unsustainable financial model in which he assumed we could spend what ever and just get Trevor to loan us more money. This has done to death though, we are where we are. Without the owner we would have no club. I'm grateful for his backing, it is his money and he can do what he wants with it. However I wish he would do more, he could bank roll us, he chooses not to. Like I say that is his choice. However i find it totally understandable that folk get frustrated when we piss clubs about with derisory offers for players that we clearly could actually afford to buy and then lose out at the last minute. Selling Joe Garner makes sense but only if that money is reinvested in the team.

I'll end this point with the note that PNE have sold season tickets with Premier League logo's all over the adverts, offering FREE Premier League football if we get there. We all know its hard for us to compete but whilst the club do offers like this it only puts more pressure on them to show some ambition.

Point 3 - Electronic Ticketing.

This should have been introduced many years ago. Everyone can see that our ticketing service is out dated. We couldn't cope when 500 folk turned up at 7:15 for a match when 4,000 attended. Our online ticket site is shite and hardly ever works. We have massive paper season ticket books whilst the half time draw is computerised. Relating back to point one, we could offer far better incentives for fans if everyone who wanted one could get a ticket card. Match by Match uploading online, avoiding queuing, tracking which games folk attend. Sell tickets in blocks, half/full season tickets. It would take huge pressure off the ticket office, reduce staff levels, save money. The putting money into the team argument is flawed. This should be something that is done to compliment the fact we should be a forward looking football club. You talk like it would cost millions, it wouldn't. It is 2016 not 1968.

Yes there are many things Peter has got right since coming to PNE, ultimately the club is in a far better place, obviously the league shows that. However this shouldn't stop us from commenting on areas where things can be improved.


Well said that man
 
1971/72 first season after said promotion.........15,136.
1972/73 second season after promotion............10,199.

1978/79 first season after promotion................12,117.
1979/80 second season after promotion............9,751.
1980/81 third season after promotion...............7,631. (relegation season also to offer balance).

And the last time we were promoted it took longer for the gates to drop, but drop they did.

200/01 first season after promotion...........14,530. Then a gradually fluctuation until:
2010/11 (granted a relegation season)........11,768.

When we have eventually played teams at home such as Newcastle, Villa, Leeds, Sheffield Wednesday and a few other of the teams that are either more attractive opposition, or will bring more fans that Fulham (as an example) I am sure our home average will climb considerably.

Jeez we are a small club on a par with Barnsley and marginally bigger than Rotherham. Nearly every club in the division is bigger than us and yet a lot of fans expect us to be challenging for the Premiership.
Even the squad we have now would nowhere near be possible based on income from supporters and TV money.
I can understand fans dreaming of us making it to the Premiership but in the grand scheme of things we're an Iceland amongst the teams of Europe.
 
Welcome to the forum Peter. 😉

People have a right to moan as it is your right to support everything the club do.

The reason people moan is because they love the club. The club which we put hundreds if not thousands of pounds a year into. A club which whilst is heavily reliant on the owner would not survive without the supporters either. If the football club remain unchallenged then they can do what ever they please.

Point one - Season tickets.

Personally I understand why we do not sell season tickets for £149, however the football clubs reliance on the core support renewing is a poor strategy. We do absolutely nothing to entice new fans on Deepdale, the failed ambassador scheme being the number one supporter of this. Our stadium is more than half empty most weeks. The weekly attendance is dropping not improving the longer we are in this league. This HAS to be addressed or the club we die on its arse. We simply can not afford to just assume that the 5/6000 will renew every year which seems to be what they are doing at the moment.

Football is too expensive full stop.

Point Two - The Owner

I believe that TJH is still reeling from the money that Alan Irvine wasted, a time when the former chairman operated a unsustainable financial model in which he assumed we could spend what ever and just get Trevor to loan us more money. This has done to death though, we are where we are. Without the owner we would have no club. I'm grateful for his backing, it is his money and he can do what he wants with it. However I wish he would do more, he could bank roll us, he chooses not to. Like I say that is his choice. However i find it totally understandable that folk get frustrated when we piss clubs about with derisory offers for players that we clearly could actually afford to buy and then lose out at the last minute. Selling Joe Garner makes sense but only if that money is reinvested in the team.

I'll end this point with the note that PNE have sold season tickets with Premier League logo's all over the adverts, offering FREE Premier League football if we get there. We all know its hard for us to compete but whilst the club do offers like this it only puts more pressure on them to show some ambition.

Point 3 - Electronic Ticketing.

This should have been introduced many years ago. Everyone can see that our ticketing service is out dated. We couldn't cope when 500 folk turned up at 7:15 for a match when 4,000 attended. Our online ticket site is shite and hardly ever works. We have massive paper season ticket books whilst the half time draw is computerised. Relating back to point one, we could offer far better incentives for fans if everyone who wanted one could get a ticket card. Match by Match uploading online, avoiding queuing, tracking which games folk attend. Sell tickets in blocks, half/full season tickets. It would take huge pressure off the ticket office, reduce staff levels, save money. The putting money into the team argument is flawed. This should be something that is done to compliment the fact we should be a forward looking football club. You talk like it would cost millions, it wouldn't. It is 2016 not 1968.

Yes there are many things Peter has got right since coming to PNE, ultimately the club is in a far better place, obviously the league shows that. However this shouldn't stop us from commenting on areas where things can be improved.

Well said.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top