Skip to main content

Will he keep Rudd?

Will he keep Rudd?

Joined
Jun 29, 2017
Messages
6
Surely Alex Neil's first test. A player he clearly doesn't rate but the owners/chairman do? Does he give him a clean slate and pacify the owner 0r go with his instincts and move him on? Similarly does Rudd knuckle down or look to move on asap? Interesting dinamics straight away. I'd feel pretty fucking unlucky if i were declan
 
Think he'll keep him as the number 2. Like you say you'd be pretty peed if you're Declan Rudd signing a 3 year contract at a new club with a fresh start and your nemesis joins you a week later. Sure all parties would wish the deal to be cancelled if possible. Do they not have the 14 day cooling off period for football transfers lol. For what it's worth I was hoping that Rudd would be number 1 this year.
 
Will he keep Rudd?

This will surely have been ironed out before Alex was offered the position. In other words, he's to keep him and treat him fairly.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
It's a stupid idea that people think Alex would be so petty, he will have known who we had and if he really did come in a get rid or force him to be number 2 and not base it on his performances I would rather the Manager go. However I don't think there is an issue between the 2, they hd a few good keepers and Rudd missed out, now he's at PNE, he should based on his past for us be fighting for 1st place.
 
To be fair he gave Rudd a run in the premier league days so clearly sees something in him. He also wasn't the one to sell him, despite the fact we have clearly been interested for a while.

I would not at all be surprised if Rudd had an idea SG was off and AN in. I would be surprised if he isn't number one, or at the very least pushing for the jersey, against Sheff Weds
 
I think he and Maxwell will compete for the jersey, and I don't know who will win. I see them both staying for at least a year though.
 
I really hope there's no issues. I think Rudd's class and probably (if he's showing form in pre-season) number 1 for me. I feel sorry for Maxwell but from what I remember of Rudd he's a cracking keeper...
 
We've only just signed Rudd, as far as I know Neil has never had a personal problem with Rudd and if PR suspected there might be any issue I'm sure that would be a major question during the job interview. I would guess the reason he never got a game under him at Norwich was that at the time they also had John Ruddy who for a couple of years was a regular in the England squad.
 
I'm not convinced Neil doesn't rate him. Rudd had a very good keeper ahead of him in Ruddy yet still managed to oust him briefly in the prem. The decision to loan him out may just be that Norwich as well Rudd needed him to have more game time.
 
The only reason there will be an issue is if Rudd was promised a start no matter what over Maxwell under Grayson.

Giving Rudd the number 1 shirt was rather crappy and cemented the notion that he had been pursued by Grayson and the rest since his departure 3 years ago.

Rudd will be here for at least the 17-18 season regardless of his role simply due to the investment in him during recruitment.

Maxwell's ability to support the team in a high line was the single most effective change in our fortunes last year. I think Grayson was forced into the change and I am certain he would never have been comfortable with the less defensive minded approach. I would also hazard a guess that Grayson was relieved when he was able to line Maxwell us as a scapegoat following the end of season implode. (Still had a better save rate in those games than Ward at Huddersfield)

This high line released some players from defensive duties and look what happened. Said it before the replacement of Lindegarrd saved us from relegation.

Incidentally I was rather surprised by the style of play supported by Maxwell after seeing the exact opposite from him at Fleetwood where he was the playmaker in possession from the back.

I think what Maxwell is missing is dishonesty - he might be better thought of if he showboated more with standard easy saves. You know the ones where the keeper throws himself in the air after making a save with his feet on the ground. Or the best one where they catch/parry the ball at shoulder height then dive up into the top corner.
 
Giving Rudd the number 1 shirt was rather crappy and cemented the notion that he had been pursued by Grayson and the rest since his departure 3 years ago.

I don't agree at all?

Shirt numbers mean nothing in my opinion. A lot of players now use their number as a brand so not necessarily 1-11 anymore.

Some players like to keep the same number because of luck? Callum Robinson for one. Paul Hunts secondly.

Just because Rudd was allocated 1, does not mean he will be 'number one' for us.

For all you know, Maxwell may have asked for 22 again because her performed so well last season?
 
I don't agree at all?

Shirt numbers mean nothing in my opinion. A lot of players now use their number as a brand so not necessarily 1-11 anymore.

Some players like to keep the same number because of luck? Callum Robinson for one. Paul Hunts secondly.

Just because Rudd was allocated 1, does not mean he will be 'number one' for us.

For all you know, Maxwell may have asked for 22 again because her performed so well last season?


Do you think maxwell would not have been proud to wear number 1 I do! Slap in the face for me!
 
Back
Top