Skip to main content

Will Keane release

Will Keane release

Joined
Oct 17, 2004
Messages
84
According to Daily Telegraph Will Keane to be released by Man Utd. Where now for him? Would he ever consider Deepdale, would North End want him?
 
According to Daily Telegraph Will Keane to be released by Man Utd. Where now for him? Would he ever consider Deepdale, would North End want him?

He's in the united squad for their tour to China, so I doubt it. And we don't want him ever again for multiple reasons.

https://twitter.com/ManUtd/status/755333873731526656
Cnt8JzJWcAAMObD.jpg
 
Last edited:
According to the report, they will listen to offers for him after the China tour.

Not a popular opinion, but I would rather have re-signed Keane than Eoin Doyle. Keane is a very talented young player. With a bit more application, I feel Grayson could've moulded him into a top player at this level.
 
According to the report, they will listen to offers for him after the China tour.

Not a popular opinion, but I would rather have re-signed Keane than Eoin Doyle. Keane is a very talented young player. With a bit more application, I feel Grayson could've moulded him into a top player at this level.

He's a flat track bully. looks an absolute beast playing against kids, terrible against men. unfortunately for him, there comes a time where you have to step up, he won't. he's happier playing against u21 teams scoring a few and making an absolute packet for it.
 
I think he will always be wanting to get back to the premiership at whatever cost. Usually i would say that is what we should look for. But he was happy to leave us quickly last time and im sure he would again and probably at the cost of wrecking team spirit. Its a no for me unless he gives garantees he will stay for at least 2 seasons

Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk
 
According to the report, they will listen to offers for him after the China tour.

Not a popular opinion, but I would rather have re-signed Keane than Eoin Doyle. Keane is a very talented young player. With a bit more application, I feel Grayson could've moulded him into a top player at this level.

Might not be popular but definitely a sensible opinion sir! I don't know as much as others seem to about our Will but could he be a solid championship striker? I would have thought so.
 
If he's going to make it at Championship level he needs to knuckle down and stop mincing about.

This lad turned up at Turf Moor in gloves, that alone speaks volumes. (although he did score)

Nice One.
 
I prefer Will Keane to Eoin Doyle but there's no room for both in the squad, even though I don't consider Keane an out & out striker.

Keane was starting to establish himself in the team before he decided he could start ahead of Wayne Rooney. He's also a bit of a fanny.
 
It's a shame because he was really getting into his stride before he decided to think he's Messi and left us. Won't forget his goal at Burnley though!
 
According to the report, they will listen to offers for him after the China tour.

Not a popular opinion, but I would rather have re-signed Keane than Eoin Doyle. Keane is a very talented young player. With a bit more application, I feel Grayson could've moulded him into a top player at this level.

Talented? Application? This is the guy who wore gloves most times I saw him, hardly ever put in a challenge for a header and tried fancy tricks on the outside of our box which sometimes nearly led to a goal. Doyle may have only got 4 goals but I still like him because at least he put in effort - something that Will Keane lacks.
 
Talented? Application? This is the guy who wore gloves most times I saw him, hardly ever put in a challenge for a header and tried fancy tricks on the outside of our box which sometimes nearly led to a goal. Doyle may have only got 4 goals but I still like him because at least he put in effort - something that Will Keane lacks.

Selective memory? Keane might have worn gloves (pretty irrelevant observation) but his work rate was fine and he did plenty of closing down.

Poor in the air maybe and lacked strength/ aggression but he put in the effort in terms of his running and pressurising. One of his main qualities imo.
 
The lad has talent and ability, of that there is no doubt.

It's what's going on inside his head that is the biggest hurdle to overcome.

I wouldn't be upset if we re-signed Will at some stage.

Interesting that the squad in a post above is a 25 nan squad, the exact number that the PL require.

Assuming that Pogba signs, who is the one to make way? Not for one minute is Keane the obvious one out, he is one of 3 or 4 who won't make the cut to accommodate Pogba.
 
The lad has talent and ability, of that there is no doubt.

It's what's going on inside his head that is the biggest hurdle to overcome.

I wouldn't be upset if we re-signed Will at some stage.

Interesting that the squad in a post above is a 25 nan squad, the exact number that the PL require.

Assuming that Pogba signs, who is the one to make way? Not for one minute is Keane the obvious one out, he is one of 3 or 4 who won't make the cut to accommodate Pogba.

No Martial in that squad either, must still be on his hols after the Euros.
 
Selective memory? Keane might have worn gloves (pretty irrelevant observation) but his work rate was fine and he did plenty of closing down.

Poor in the air maybe and lacked strength/ aggression but he put in the effort in terms of his running and pressurising. One of his main qualities imo.

Selective memory? He was soft, shirked out of many challenges. Fair enough he closed players down so he looked like he was putting in effort but there is no point in doing that if you aren't prepared to put in a challenge which he wasn't.

I also find it laughable that people are actually trying to justify signing will keane instead of eoin doyle. Yes Doyle only scored four goals (I can understand why people aren't happy) but how many did will keane score? Oh yes one and he was soft as shit as well. I wasn't sorry when he left - in fact we looked a much better team without him in the squad.

Also if someones main qualities is to run after the ball then what do they get paid for? He is 23 and yet to settle down at a club and has only scored 4 league goals. Think that says something!
 
Last edited:
The lad has talent and ability, of that there is no doubt.

It's what's going on inside his head that is the biggest hurdle to overcome.

I wouldn't be upset if we re-signed Will at some stage.

Interesting that the squad in a post above is a 25 nan squad, the exact number that the PL require.

Assuming that Pogba signs, who is the one to make way? Not for one minute is Keane the obvious one out, he is one of 3 or 4 who won't make the cut to accommodate Pogba.

No Martial, Zlatan, Schweinsteiger, Fellaini etc in the squad. Will Keane was also named in Man United's 25 man Premier League squad last summer even though he was on loan to us.
 
Talented? Application? This is the guy who wore gloves most times I saw him, hardly ever put in a challenge for a header and tried fancy tricks on the outside of our box which sometimes nearly led to a goal. Doyle may have only got 4 goals but I still like him because at least he put in effort - something that Will Keane lacks.

I prefer to judge a player on their attributes on the pitch instead of if they have long hair or wear gloves, which is completely irrelevant. Talking about his gloves does nothing more than portray petty bitterness because he wanted to go back. I've never seen so much bitterness towards someone who is just an ex-loanee before.

I do accept he needs to improve the strength and aggression side of his game. Not playing enough men's football won't have helped that, it will come in time. He absolutely does not lack effort and as sf pointed out, it's probably one of his better attributes. I can't remember when he did a trick on the edge of our own box so that must be completely made up.

On the Doyle comparison……they were both on 1 goal when Keane left so they were equal in the time they were both here. Also one of the main excuses for Doyle from his fans is that he often played out wide. Keane played on the right a lot and it never gets mentioned. As sf said, probably selective memory from some.

As minty says, he was just beginning to find his stride. Particularly in the home games be Reading and Hull he was excellent, so it was a shame he wanted to go back. It's a pointless debate really as I doubt there is a chance of a return, but overall my opinion won't change; he has all the attributes to be a top player in the Championship and if he wanted to come back on a permanent deal I would definitely have him.

I would not be shocked if he joined a Championship club this summer and did very well and kicked on.
 
Last edited:
Selective memory? He was soft, shirked out of many challenges. Fair enough he closed players down so he looked like he was putting in effort but there is no point in doing that if you aren't prepared to put in a challenge which he wasn't.

I also find it laughable that people are actually trying to justify signing will keane instead of eoin doyle. Yes Doyle only scored four goals (I can understand why people aren't happy) but how many did will keane score? Oh yes one and he was soft as shit as well. I wasn't sorry when he left - in fact we looked a much better team without him in the squad.

Also if someones main qualities is to run after the ball then what do they get paid for? He is 23 and yet to settle down at a club and has only scored 4 league goals. Think that says something!

Broken legs don't help matters when it comes breaking into first teams though, he's had a few injuries, not denying he's soft but he's got much more ability than Doyle and his link-up play is good. Pretty sure Doyle was bumming around in Ireland at Keane's age.

Yes, his goal record is poor but he's not a striker in my book, looks much better playing off the striker or behind a front two.

That's not to say I want to sign him, i'd just prefer him if it was a toss up between him and Doyle.
 
No Martial, Zlatan, Schweinsteiger, Fellaini etc in the squad. Will Keane was also named in Man United's 25 man Premier League squad last summer even though he was on loan to us.

Fair points.

I had no idea which regulars or to be regulars were missing.

I guess he won't be making the cut then. I still think there is a decent footballer inside him.
 
Back
Top