Skip to main content

Will Keane release

Will Keane release

Fair points.

I had no idea which regulars or to be regulars were missing.

I guess he won't be making the cut then. I still think there is a decent footballer inside him.

Maybe but that footballer isn't as good as what Will think he is.
 
Keane made the wrong choice as he was just starting to nail down a place in the side and play well.

Permanently I think I'd take him back. A Keane-Beckford partnership could be a fruitful one imho.
 
Fair points.

I had no idea which regulars or to be regulars were missing.

I guess he won't be making the cut then. I still think there is a decent footballer inside him.

The 25 man PL squad can be gotten around if you use young/homegrown players, which players like Keane and Wilson are. Players like Rashford, Fosu-Mensah and Borthwick-Jackson won't have been named in the squad but are still usable.

I would take Keane back, people think he didn't have the work rate but I remember that being one of his best qualities.
 
I prefer to judge a player on their attributes on the pitch instead of if they have long hair or wear gloves, which is completely irrelevant. Talking about his gloves does nothing more than portray petty bitterness because he wanted to go back. I've never seen so much bitterness towards someone who is just an ex-loanee before.

I do accept he needs to improve the strength and aggression side of his game. Not playing enough men's football won't have helped that, it will come in time. He absolutely does not lack effort and as sf pointed out, it's probably one of his better attributes. I can't remember when he did a trick on the edge of our own box so that must be completely made up.

On the Doyle comparison……they were both on 1 goal when Keane left so they were equal in the time they were both here. Also one of the main excuses for Doyle from his fans is that he often played out wide. Keane played on the right a lot and it never gets mentioned. As sf said, probably selective memory from some.

As minty says, he was just beginning to find his stride. Particularly in the home games be Reading and Hull he was excellent, so it was a shame he wanted to go back. It's a pointless debate really as I doubt there is a chance of a return, but overall my opinion won't change; he has all the attributes to be a top player in the Championship and if he wanted to come back on a permanent deal I would definitely have him.

I would not be shocked if he joined a Championship club this summer and did very well and kicked on.

Agreed. In any event in comparison to Doyle he's a number 10, not 9. Yes he did rate himself but he did have some quality.
 
I must admit I am very surprised by the comments about Keane on here. He is a talented lad without doubt and could have a big future in the game.

he needs the right manager to get the best out of him and SG would have been that man I think.

he did let his ambition run away with his ability at times but he will always have a place in my heart for that goal against the 6 fingered betheren which for a week or two shut them up and the bragging rights till April were immense. They moaned and moaned and moaned but at the end of the day we won 2-0.

The best other day at turf for me was in 1986 October I think it was when John Thomas and Gary Brazil got 2 each and we won 4-1.
 
I prefer to judge a player on their attributes on the pitch instead of if they have long hair or wear gloves, which is completely irrelevant. Talking about his gloves does nothing more than portray petty bitterness because he wanted to go back. I've never seen so much bitterness towards someone who is just an ex-loanee before.

I do accept he needs to improve the strength and aggression side of his game. Not playing enough men's football won't have helped that, it will come in time. He absolutely does not lack effort and as sf pointed out, it's probably one of his better attributes. I can't remember when he did a trick on the edge of our own box so that must be completely made up.

On the Doyle comparison……they were both on 1 goal when Keane left so they were equal in the time they were both here. Also one of the main excuses for Doyle from his fans is that he often played out wide. Keane played on the right a lot and it never gets mentioned. As sf said, probably selective memory from some.

As minty says, he was just beginning to find his stride. Particularly in the home games be Reading and Hull he was excellent, so it was a shame he wanted to go back. It's a pointless debate really as I doubt there is a chance of a return, but overall my opinion won't change; he has all the attributes to be a top player in the Championship and if he wanted to come back on a permanent deal I would definitely have him.

I would not be shocked if he joined a Championship club this summer and did very well and kicked on.

Watch the burnley v preston highlights again and when pickford made that world class save it was because Keane tried a fancy trick just outside the area.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P1zhkS6f_88

Just for your info. It's about 28 seconds in. What attributes does he actually have? He wasn't strong/didn't put challenges in. Ok - he's a striker and he scored one goal. What was his purpose? And even that goal was fortunate. I'm not bitter he wanted to go back - good riddance as we improved once he left as proven by our results. The reason I mentioned he wore gloves was as mentioned previously he was soft. He had two good games for us in 20. That is not good enough!

He has scored 4 goals in his career and is 23. We have better strikers in the club at the moment who will score more goals.

Also, for you info, I am not a fan of doyle but I rate him a hell of a lot more then Keane because one he puts in a graft. Something that Keane did about twice. He also started a lot less matches up until Keane left meaning he didn't really get the chance to get the goals.
 
Last edited:
It's odd how Grayson has in the past received stick for signing players he knows from previous clubs or for going back to sign players we previously had yet every time someone like this becomes available there's a clamour from some to sign them.

It's the same with Vermijl, it's as though he's the only RB out there.
 
Is Eoin Doyle a particularly hard worker like a lot of people are saying?

It's not something i'd really associate with him tbh.
 
Is Eoin Doyle a particularly hard worker like a lot of people are saying?

It's not something i'd really associate with him tbh.

They were saying on commentary last night that it was suprising how many times he was actually involved in PNEFC goals last season when they were doing a montage. Even though he didn't get the assist or score the goal, it was his neat turns and clever touches that helped scored the goal.

BC away last season is a perfect example.
 
Is Eoin Doyle a particularly hard worker like a lot of people are saying?

It's not something i'd really associate with him tbh.

He's not on the Cresswell level...

You know how it is though, close a few full backs down and people seem to remember that more!!

Like when Cresswell used to close the keeper down even though he never blocked a single clearance he was loved for it.

Doyle works hard enough though, he certainly isn't lazy, but for me working hard is the least I expect from a player. I think this current crop of players rate highly on that score.
 
Back
Top