Skip to main content

Will Keane release

Will Keane release

I actually thought he was showing signs of developing into a decent creative forward for us, after an uninspiring start, when he decided to bugger off back. It'll be interesting to see how he copes without his safety net/comfort zone of U21 football.
 
Watch the burnley v preston highlights again and when pickford made that world class save it was because Keane tried a fancy trick just outside the area.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P1zhkS6f_88

Just for your info. It's about 28 seconds in. What attributes does he actually have? He wasn't strong/didn't put challenges in. Ok - he's a striker and he scored one goal. What was his purpose? And even that goal was fortunate. I'm not bitter he wanted to go back - good riddance as we improved once he left as proven by our results. The reason I mentioned he wore gloves was as mentioned previously he was soft. He had two good games for us in 20. That is not good enough!

He has scored 4 goals in his career and is 23. We have better strikers in the club at the moment who will score more goals.

Also, for you info, I am not a fan of doyle but I rate him a hell of a lot more then Keane because one he puts in a graft. Something that Keane did about twice. He also started a lot less matches up until Keane left meaning he didn't really get the chance to get the goals.

That was probably the only time all season he gave it away on the edge of his own box. "Just for your info", later in the video he runs from the halfway line and gives us the lead in the derby. And Keane's departure wasn't the catalyst for our good run of form; we had already starting improving as a side whilst he was a starting player.

I will reiterate again - wearing gloves has no bearing on whether a player is soft or not. Didier Drogba, who was one of the most physical strikers in the Prem for about a decade, wore gloves from time to time.

Keane's best attributes IMO are his work rate, his touch, awareness, and link up play with other forwards. He also has a decent burst of pace as shown on the video you have linked. He is also versatile and was just getting into the groove on the right of that 443 formation we played prior to his departure. I completely agree he is lacking physically and aggression wise as it stands. He also needs to show a more ruthless streak in the final third to find more chances.

We will never agree about this so it is probably best if we agree to disagree. I'm certainly not saying he's the next big thing or that he'll be very prolific in future, but I find some of the criticism, particularly of his character and attitude, very unfair and grossly exaggerated, and I would have him back if the price was right because IMHO there's a very good player in there that can be unlocked.
 
Last edited:
I liked him and although understandable, was disappointed with his decision to return to utd. He definately wasnt work shy and had some very tidy footwork. Not sure where hed fit in now though with our plethora of strikers.
 
Last edited:
That was probably the only time all season he gave it away on the edge of his own box. "Just for your info", later in the video he runs from the halfway line and gives us the lead in the derby. And Keane's departure wasn't the catalyst for our good run of form; we had already starting improving as a side whilst he was a starting player.

I will reiterate again - wearing gloves has no bearing on whether a player is soft or not. Didier Drogba, who was one of the most physical strikers in the Prem for about a decade, wore gloves from time to time.

Keane's best attributes IMO are his work rate, his touch, awareness, and link up play with other forwards. He also has a decent burst of pace as shown on the video you have linked. He is also versatile and was just getting into the groove on the right of that 443 formation we played prior to his departure. I completely agree he is lacking physically and aggression wise as it stands. He also needs to show a more ruthless streak in the final third to find more chances.

We will never agree about this so it is probably best if we agree to disagree. I'm certainly not saying he's the next big thing or that he'll be very prolific in future, but I find some of the criticism, particularly of his character and attitude, very unfair and grossly exaggerated, and I would have him back if the price was right because IMHO there's a very good player in there that can be unlocked.

No wonder he was getting into the groove of things if we were playing with 12 men.

Good post, by the way.
 
I'm actually shocked by how many would consider taking him back. For 90% of his time here he was hammered by most, me included probably.

I agree he was just starting to perform better (but let's face it he wasn't exactly outstanding) but that took until about December and he was gone in January. Are we going to wait another 4/5 months for him to come good again at the expense of our permanent strikers?

Leave well alone for me.
 
That was probably the only time all season he gave it away on the edge of his own box. "Just for your info", later in the video he runs from the halfway line and gives us the lead in the derby. And Keane's departure wasn't the catalyst for our good run of form; we had already starting improving as a side whilst he was a starting player.

I will reiterate again - wearing gloves has no bearing on whether a player is soft or not. Didier Drogba, who was one of the most physical strikers in the Prem for about a decade, wore gloves from time to time.

Keane's best attributes IMO are his work rate, his touch, awareness, and link up play with other forwards. He also has a decent burst of pace as shown on the video you have linked. He is also versatile and was just getting into the groove on the right of that 443 formation we played prior to his departure. I completely agree he is lacking physically and aggression wise as it stands. He also needs to show a more ruthless streak in the final third to find more chances.

We will never agree about this so it is probably best if we agree to disagree. I'm certainly not saying he's the next big thing or that he'll be very prolific in future, but I find some of the criticism, particularly of his character and attitude, very unfair and grossly exaggerated, and I would have him back if the price was right because IMHO there's a very good player in there that can be unlocked.

One of the few bits of sense on here.
 
Will Keane had actually started to show a few signs of being a decent Championship Player when he decided to go back to United. However for him to think he was anywhere near good enough to break into what is one of the Worlds biggest Clubs, shows that he is a tad deluded.
 
I think we have enough striking options this season.

At present, we have Doyle, Garner, Beckford, Hughill, Makienok and May when he is fit. 6 strikers in total.

I hope we have enough firepower there to get by reasonably ok.

I think we have more urgent defensive issues to address in light of Calum Woods' injury at this moment in time. Signing a right back is priority more than an extra forward I think at this time.

Sent from my SM-G900F using Tapatalk
 
Been given a squad number at Man U . Number 48 the highest number in the squad . Says it all.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Been given a squad number at Man U . Number 48 the highest number in the squad . Says it all.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

But James Wilson and Tyler Blackett haven't. He was always number 48 at United, so if anything that means he's staying there.
 
According to the teletext will Keane is a 6.5 million target for David moyes at Sunderland. We've seen him play, and he ain't worth 6.5 million so it just goes to show what 'stupid money' is all about in football. In this thread we were seriously thinking we might be able to sign him !!!!!
 
According to the teletext will Keane is a 6.5 million target for David moyes at Sunderland. We've seen him play, and he ain't worth 6.5 million so it just goes to show what 'stupid money' is all about in football. In this thread we were seriously thinking we might be able to sign him !!!!!

Illustrates everything that is wrong with English football. This is a player who has achieved nothing at all in the game and yet he is 'valued' at 6.5 million. Imagine for a minute what 6.5 million actually buys you in the real world or what that amount of money could mean if invested into grass roots football. Its just like monopoly money now in the Premiership and it stinks.
 
Has he ever even played in the premier league? What would that make joe garner worth? If anyone wants to pay that much for a man Utd reserve who cannot even score regularly in the championship then the game really is going crazy.

6.5 million for a lad that scores 1 goal in 20 odd games in the championship. I honestly thought Moyes was smarter than this.
 
Back
Top