Skip to main content

Will keane

Will keane

Joined
Jul 6, 2011
Messages
639
Location
Bamber Bridge
Don't often critic own players BUT..

Never want to see him play again. He's like a girl. No strength about him. He has nothing. He scored a fluke at Burnley which made him keep his place.

He's a ponce who thinks he's Ronaldo. Half hearted effort. Not interested, has stupid hair and wears gloves in one of the mildest Decembers on record. GIRL.

Why didn't he cut out the cross for their goal today? Not good enough and never will be. Doyle and May not good enough either but Keane is the worst out of the lot. Time to do some work in January Grayson.
 
Don't often critic own players BUT..

Never want to see him play again. He's like a girl. No strength about him. He has nothing. He scored a fluke at Burnley which made him keep his place.

He's a ponce who thinks he's Ronaldo. Half hearted effort. Not interested, has stupid hair and wears gloves in one of the mildest Decembers on record. GIRL.

Why didn't he cut out the cross for their goal today? Not good enough and never will be. Doyle and May not good enough either but Keane is the worst out of the lot. Time to do some work in January Grayson.
Pleased for May recovering enough from his injury to play today. Remarkable. Got to admit that doyle definitely didnt show enough in the 3 minutes he got on, waster 😉
 
I have to say, although I didn't go today, once Pickford got his red, I thought the most obvious candidate to be dragged off, would be fancy dan Keane.

Not the ball-winning Welsh, who when you have 10 men would seem a good choice to stay on the pitch! Keane does not strike me as the type you need when it's "backs-to-the-wall-stuff"!

The next substitution also seemed baffling to both me and the Radio Lancs commentary team, taking off the energetic Browne who can run all day, for the rather pedestrian Kilkenny(although his ability to keep possession is obviously a plus point).

Hoyland kept saying it was crying out for Hugill to come on and hold the ball up and give us a presence up top, and that seems logical.

Why the apparently anonymous Keane stayed on til the 87th minute, to be replaced by the out of form Eoin Doyle, whilst the battering ram stays on the bench kicking his heels, seems a tad bizarre to me.

Sounded like Leeds were hanging on a bit despite their man advantage, and had we given them more to think about, could've got at least a point.

Don't usually like commenting on games I've not actually witnessed, but that's how it came across on commentary. For those who parted with 37 sovs feel free to shoot me down in flames!

PS How many did we take today? Heard a few audible "yellows" shouts throughout.
 
Don't often critic own players BUT..

Never want to see him play again. He's like a girl. No strength about him. He has nothing. He scored a fluke at Burnley which made him keep his place.

He's a ponce who thinks he's Ronaldo. Half hearted effort. Not interested, has stupid hair and wears gloves in one of the mildest Decembers on record. GIRL.

Why didn't he cut out the cross for their goal today? Not good enough and never will be. Doyle and May not good enough either but Keane is the worst out of the lot. Time to do some work in January Grayson.

Keane is the second best striker at the club with JB injured. Until we replace him with better there seems little point raging about him if he has a poor game as there has been plenty of good stuff from the lad this month.

He tries to take people on a lot and loses the ball occasionally but I think his movement is terrific and it's no coincidence our upturn in results has come when he's been in the side. At other clubs he'd be more popular, here we like our players to be a bit more John Welshesque. Not a criticism of Welsh who I like, just noticed North End fans struggle with wayward, attacking, non defensive flair players. Especially ones who wear gloves.
 
Last edited:
Don't often critic own players BUT..

Never want to see him play again. He's like a girl. No strength about him. He has nothing. He scored a fluke at Burnley which made him keep his place.

He's a ponce who thinks he's Ronaldo. Half hearted effort. Not interested, has stupid hair and wears gloves in one of the mildest Decembers on record. GIRL.

Why didn't he cut out the cross for their goal today? Not good enough and never will be. Doyle and May not good enough either but Keane is the worst out of the lot. Time to do some work in January Grayson.

That's a bit contradictory considering you have just had a go at three of our players in one post!
 
I have to say, although I didn't go today, once Pickford got his red, I thought the most obvious candidate to be dragged off, would be fancy dan Keane.

Not the ball-winning Welsh, who when you have 10 men would seem a good choice to stay on the pitch! Keane does not strike me as the type you need when it's "backs-to-the-wall-stuff"!

The next substitution also seemed baffling to both me and the Radio Lancs commentary team, taking off the energetic Browne who can run all day, for the rather pedestrian Kilkenny(although his ability to keep possession is obviously a plus point).

Hoyland kept saying it was crying out for Hugill to come on and hold the ball up and give us a presence up top, and that seems logical.

Why the apparently anonymous Keane stayed on til the 87th minute, to be replaced by the out of form Eoin Doyle, whilst the battering ram stays on the bench kicking his heels, seems a tad bizarre to me.

Sounded like Leeds were hanging on a bit despite their man advantage, and had we given them more to think about, could've got at least a point.

Don't usually like commenting on games I've not actually witnessed, but that's how it came across on commentary. For those who parted with 37 sovs feel free to shoot me down in flames!

PS How many did we take today? Heard a few audible "yellows" shouts throughout.

I didn't see the subs but yes the last man I would have taken off when went down to ten men would be Welsh
 
On Tuesday night against Birmingham, it was 13 degrees, apart from the keepers, Keane was the only other person out of 10,500 wearing gloves - no bottle, not interested and seems to think Utd will want him back. Would be extremely disappointed if we even signed him on a free, this guy is robbing a wage and needs sending back as soon as possible!!
 
Hence not the man for a battle, when you're a man down. Not doubting he has ability, but he needs to know when a "fancy flick" is appropiate, and "soft" is his middle name. Makes Graham Shaw look like Terry Hurlock!

I'd tend to agree with all this. We need to play to the lads' obvious strengths rather than asking him to do jobs he can't do.

Going back to the OP's original criticism that he 'thinks he's Ronaldo', again I'd agree, although I don't think it's a bad thing, especially in a rather turgid, regimented North end side. He has a spark about him and tries the unexpected. We're a better team with him in the side.
 
On Tuesday night against Birmingham, it was 13 degrees, apart from the keepers, Keane was the only other person out of 10,500 wearing gloves - no bottle, not interested and seems to think Utd will want him back. Would be extremely disappointed if we even signed him on a free, this guy is robbing a wage and needs sending back as soon as possible!!

Jesus Christ...
 
The next substitution also seemed baffling to both me and the Radio Lancs commentary team, taking off the energetic Browne who can run all day, for the rather pedestrian Kilkenny(although his ability to keep possession is obviously a plus point.

I think brownes confidence was shot at that point. He had just headed in the og and then committed a badly timed foul on the edge of the box. He was visibly upset leaving the pitch at the end of the match. He had had a good first half but I think it was the right call.

Kilkenny was excellent having two great chances. The Leeds keeper saving his header well. He was also constantly organising everyone and pointing and talking to them. Just what was needed.

Welsh was also great while he was on.

Agree on the hugill/Doyle point though.
 
I think brownes confidence was shot at that point. He had just headed in the og and then committed a badly timed foul on the edge of the box. He was visibly upset leaving the pitch at the end of the match. He had had a good first half but I think it was the right call.

Kilkenny was excellent having two great chances. The Leeds keeper saving his header well. He was also constantly organising everyone and pointing and talking to them. Just what was needed.

Welsh was also great while he was on.

Agree on the hugill/Doyle point though.

Fair play mate, it did sound as if Kilkenny had an impact, he does have his qualities, and against his old club he wouldn't want to let anybody down.
 
Back
Top