Skip to main content

Will keane

Will keane

An interesting aside about Jordan Hugill came from reading Joe Garner's comments in Tuesday's match program. When questioned about the fastest player in the club, he said it was between Humphrey and Hugill which quite surprised me. Slowest he said, would be between Welsh and Gally, which isn't surprising. If Hugill has such a burst of speed and is good in the air,then he must be worth a shout. I thought that Keane was having an awful match at Burnley until he scored and it visibly lifted him and gave him the nod for the next few matches. He looks to over elaborate and does too many flicks and tricks for me.
 
I reckon we were 500 down. I would have expected 1400 there today

At a reasonable price between £25 - £28 (last 2 away days to Fulham 1993 / Burnley 2400), we would have shifted 2k+ easily. Leeds away is one of THE standout away days of the season with the added bonus that it is on a Sunday meaning those that work a 6 day week (Mon - Sat) could have attended.
 
At a reasonable price between £25 - £28 (last 2 away days to Fulham 1993 / Burnley 2400), we would have shifted 2k+ easily. Leeds away is one of THE standout away days of the season with the added bonus that it is on a Sunday meaning those that work a 6 day week (Mon - Sat) could have attended.

Isn't the weekend before Christmas notoriously lower for crowd attendances
 
Shaken off the ball far too easily at times. He has potential but definitely needs to toughen up a bit.

Spot on this. I've lost it with the guy. Spent the whole of the Burnley match slagging him off until he scored.

And oh yes, I know it's easy to talk about different things but this is a thread about Will Keane, please stay on topic.
 
Go on then, what do you feel he contributes to the team and do you feel he is committed to the club?

He reminds me of Gallagher during his first loan spell a few years ago. He clearly has ability but is not strong enough on the ball and for the most part, in my opinion, doesn't really look committed. I get the impression he thinks he's better than he is. I can't see him playing for United but if he can toughen up and show more commitment he can have a decent career at Championship or lower Premier League level. Attitude may not be more important than ability but it is as important.
 
Go on then, what do you feel he contributes to the team and do you feel he is committed to the club?

I think he contributes by being better than all of the other strikers aside from Garner and Beckford. He's one of the most unpredictable players we have in a rather predictable team and I would say this is an odd question based on the fact that our form with Keane in the team is statistically better than our form without him in the team.

Sorry to go a bit deeper than 'he wears gloves so he must be shit or lacking commitment' which seems to be the main framework of your post.

By far the finished article and I'm sure we'll see similar threads all season when he has a bad game but I see no better fit striker at the club so I find this bandwagon jumping weird.
 
There are glimpses of real class from Keane but he needs to get in the gym and strengthen up. His knee injury a couple of years ago will ha e really hindered his physical development and he's going to need a few loan spells to get to where he needs to be.
He's also going to need the odd rest in between games as he's never been used to playing this many physical games in such a short space of time
 
Durrutti, The reason for mentioning the fact he chose to wear gloves on a night when most people thought it too warm for a coat, was to suggest a problem with his attitude - something most posters on this thread have also mentioned. If Keane can get his head around the fact that he is not going to be a Premiership Prima Donna, but one of several hundred of players needing a contract next season, we might see a level of commitment similar to that shown by Hugill on the rare opportunities he has been given. Less of a bandwagon and more of an alternative view. Just off to put a bet on Keane turning out in tights and a balaclava should the temperature dip below 10 degrees!
 
I think he contributes by being better than all of the other strikers aside from Garner and Beckford. He's one of the most unpredictable players we have in a rather predictable team and I would say this is an odd question based on the fact that our form with Keane in the team is statistically better than our form without him in the team.

Sorry to go a bit deeper than 'he wears gloves so he must be shit or lacking commitment' which seems to be the main framework of your post.

By far the finished article and I'm sure we'll see similar threads all season when he has a bad game but I see no better fit striker at the club so I find this bandwagon jumping weird.

Agree with you.

I'd much rather have the sophisticated, if frustrating, Keane leading our attack in the absence of Beckford than the donkey Hugill or the anonymous Doyle
 
U
Durrutti, The reason for mentioning the fact he chose to wear gloves on a night when most people thought it too warm for a coat, was to suggest a problem with his attitude - something most posters on this thread have also mentioned. If Keane can get his head around the fact that he is not going to be a Premiership Prima Donna, but one of several hundred of players needing a contract next season, we might see a level of commitment similar to that shown by Hugill on the rare opportunities he has been given. Less of a bandwagon and more of an alternative view. Just off to put a bet on Keane turning out in tights and a balaclava should the temperature dip below 10 degrees!

I agree that it's weird he wears gloves, it doesn't say anything about commitment though.

As for the commitment shown by Hugill, he has been given opportunities this season and made dumb decisions: got himself sent off for no reason and then, rather than squaring the ball to DJ to finish off Bolton he hit the worst shot I've seen in many a game. I don't think Grayson feels he can trust him as he keeps letting himself down.

Keane is definitely the best of a poor bunch of supporting strikers.
 
Back
Top