Skip to main content

Will keane

Will keane

another inept performance time he was sent back to man Utd.

And play who? Doyle looks a significantly inferior player to me and Hugill doesn't score, gets sent off, lets his team down, has too hot a head and can get wound up. (Delete as appropriate).

Keane has had far better games this season and scored more than the supporting cast. Keep him in the team until Beckford returns or we sign better in January which I think we should do.
 
U

I agree that it's weird he wears gloves, it doesn't say anything about commitment though.

As for the commitment shown by Hugill, he has been given opportunities this season and made dumb decisions: got himself sent off for no reason and then, rather than squaring the ball to DJ to finish off Bolton he hit the worst shot I've seen in many a game. I don't think Grayson feels he can trust him as he keeps letting himself down.

Keane is definitely the best of a poor bunch of supporting strikers.

Good post. I wouldn't even consider playing Hugill either. Not good enough. We're a solid championship outfit and some players just aren't good enough ability wise.

I'm not a fan of playing 1 up front (Garner) but I honestly can't see where the strikers we currently have can make a good enough contribution. At home, we're best pushing up Gallagher behind Garner and bringing in a solid extra midfielder like Welsh.

When Beckford is back, we can all prosume that it will be himself and Garner up front. Would not be surprised to see and upturn in results when he's back. I don't think a mid-table finish is unrealistic.
 
Keane has skill but fails to apply himself with sufficient determination on any consistent basis - whether he should be returned to Man Utd if we have the option to do so is a close call. Doyle has failed to make an impact despite being given plenty of opportunity and should be returned to Cardiff if possible - though he is probably not that bad a player. Hugill has promise and could make it at this level given a chance. If we were to sign another striker in the New Year then the best option might be an experienced centre forward with some presence on a short-term deal - frankly another Brett Angell or Kevin Davies. Alongside such a player Garner would start getting the chances that are currently in short supply for him.
 
Keane has skill but fails to apply himself with sufficient determination on any consistent basis - whether he should be returned to Man Utd if we have the option to do so is a close call. Doyle has failed to make an impact despite being given plenty of opportunity and should be returned to Cardiff if possible - though he is probably not that bad a player. Hugill has promise and could make it at this level given a chance. If we were to sign another striker in the New Year then the best option might be an experienced centre forward with some presence on a short-term deal - frankly another Brett Angell or Kevin Davies. Alongside such a player Garner would start getting the chances that are currently in short supply for him.

I dont get this buzz about hugill, hes been a big donkey whenever ive seen him play.
 
Garner and Beckford would be first choice strikers if fit, Keane a supporting act. When he was signed I don't think it was to be an out and out striker though so think some fans are looking at him to fill a void left by Beckford who is a different class in comparison.

I didn't understand the sudden optimism on deadline day when we signed Doyle and May, both lads who struggled in the championship the previous season.

For every good thing Hughil does there is something immature and unreliable afterwards.

Garner needs a hand, I don't think it is a coincidence that a player of genuine class (DJ) is the main and only other consistent source of goals.
 
I dont get this buzz about hugill, hes been a big donkey whenever ive seen him play.

I haven't seen much of him but when I have he seems quite mobile for a big lad. Doyle got a run of games to try to prove himself - Hugill at least deserves as muich.
 
I haven't seen much of him but when I have he seems quite mobile for a big lad. Doyle got a run of games to try to prove himself - Hugill at least deserves as muich.

Doyle is shite. One lucky half a season in L1.

Beavon #2.

Get rid in January. Waste of a loan.
 
Doyle.

Get rid in January. Waste of a loan.

Doyle looked very good in League 1 and was worth a punt. Frankly he is exactly the type of player we ought to be prepared to take a chance on because you can bet he would really want to prove himself at a higher level. But maybe he does not have the ability to make that step up whatever his attitude - and when I have seen him he has seemed at to want to succeed. Yes the hard-headed decision on January will be to send him back to Cardiff if we can - if a League 1 club then picked him up for the rest of the season he would probably get a bagful for them.
 
Doyle is shite. One lucky half a season in L1.

Beavon #2.

Get rid in January. Waste of a loan.

Harsh on Beavon is that comparison. While Beavon didn't score goals, he was actually quite a technically gifted footballer, unlike Doyle. If anything Keane is Beavon #2 because he's a reasonably decent footballer, but is highly unlikely to be a prolific scorer, and hence is for the same reason ineffective as a striker.
 
Also fed up with Keane, but can't see a better option at the moment. Maybe pushing DJ on to add a bit of pace would give defences something to think about?
 
My wife told me I had a small organ - I replied it had never played in a cathedral before.

The last time I was in hospital I asked a nurse about the possibility of donating an organ. She slapped me across the face and threatened to call the police. God knows why. Maybe it came out all wrong.
 
I'd try Reach along side Joe at Huddersfield and have Terriers' ex fullback Woods as right wingback with Cunningham on the left with Wright, Hunts and Clarke in the middle. Reach had his best match when he had freedom to roam against Reading, and could compliment Garner. One thing is for sure; that none of Doyle, May, Keane or Hugill is as good as Beckford.
 
I'd try Reach along side Joe at Huddersfield and have Terriers' ex fullback Woods as right wingback with Cunningham on the left with Wright, Hunts and Clarke in the middle. Reach had his best match when he had freedom to roam against Reading, and could compliment Garner. One thing is for sure; that none of Doyle, May, Keane or Hugill is as good as Beckford.
I doubt whether on current form all four of those PUT TOGETHER are as good as a fit Beckford.
 
I'd try Reach along side Joe at Huddersfield and have Terriers' ex fullback Woods as right wingback with Cunningham on the left with Wright, Hunts and Clarke in the middle. Reach had his best match when he had freedom to roam against Reading, and could compliment Garner. One thing is for sure; that none of Doyle, May, Keane or Hugill is as good as Beckford.

Garner needs to operate with a partner. For the next two games that means one out of Keane, Doyle or Hugill. Whether we will bring in someone else in addition to waiting for Beckford to return remains to be seen - that will presumably depend on whether we have the option of returning Keane and/or Doyle and whether SG thinks a loan might be a good option to aid Hugill's further development.
Reach needs the freedom to roam to be effective as an attacker - he is not a striker and it would just be a misuse of him to try to use him in that way. Woods is a decent enough right-back and has looked surprisingly good recently when used in a back three but there is no case to preferring him to Vermilj as right wing-back.
If there is a selection poser for the next game it is whether to start Kilkenny who seems to have played well when he came on at Leeds. But a midfield of, say, Gallagher, Johnson and Kilkenny really would be very lightweight - we need one or other of Browne and Welsh to give us a bit of 'bite' there.
 
Harsh on Beavon is that comparison. While Beavon didn't score goals, he was actually quite a technically gifted footballer, unlike Doyle. If anything Keane is Beavon #2 because he's a reasonably decent footballer, but is highly unlikely to be a prolific scorer, and hence is for the same reason ineffective as a striker.

Agree on Beavon, in the right set up I still think he would have been a key player for us in League One despite not being a consistent goalscorer.

From what I've seen, Doyle is nothing more than a 'tap-in' specialist and i'm on the fence about Will Keane, zero strength or presence.
 
Agree on Beavon, in the right set up I still think he would have been a key player for us in League One despite not being a consistent goalscorer.

From what I've seen, Doyle is nothing more than a 'tap-in' specialist and i'm on the fence about Will Keane, zero strength or presence.

I'm glad we ended up with Doyle on loan rather than paying good money for him, wasn't it reported that we bid 950k ?

Since he joined Cardiff in January, he's scored a grand total of 6 goals at this level, 2 of which were penalties against Blackpool last season. I'm starting to come around to the thinking that Doyle was a half season wonder in league 1 and nothing more. He doesn't seem up to much in the Championship. And considering he turns 28 soon, unless he goes on a wonderful goal-scoring run between now and the end of the season I wouldn't consider spending decent cash on him in the summer.
 
Keane has blown hot and cold. I agree on some fronts he looks weak and needs to man up and stop getting knocked off the ball to easily. That said against reading he was quality and showed some real quality footwork and touches that made me think yeah thats why Ferguson rated him so highly.
Lets not forget he is still young, lets show some faith in the lad and hope he bangs in more goals like he did on the turf moor as shite!!!
 
Awful. All the players were awful today but every time I looked at Keane, he was stroking his hair. Think he got the message about the gloves though. Shite. As somebody else mentioned, to many fancy boys in this 'team'
 
Back
Top