Skip to main content

Will Welsh start?

Will Welsh start?

Joined
May 30, 2014
Messages
4,821
I noticed that club captain John Welsh was the chosen one of the players to represent the club for media purposes.
Now I like him as a person but I sincerely hope he doesn't start on Saturday. Youth and Kilkenny for me please Simon.
 
I noticed that club captain John Welsh was the chosen one of the players to represent the club for media purposes.
Now I like him as a person but I sincerely hope he doesn't start on Saturday. Youth and Kilkenny for me please Simon.

Agreed. Browne and brownhill need to start for me.
 
I'd rather he didn't start. The alternatives will be far more suited to breaking down Notts County who I wouldn't be surprised to see use quite negative tactics tomorrow.
 
I don't think Welsh will start. He will have a bigger role later in the season when the pitches deteriorate and matches get scrappy.

Choice tomorrow I think is Kilkenny, Browne and Brownhill OR King, Kilkenny and Brownhill.

Given that LEP are saying the former in their likely team then I imagine it will be that. Ben Davies at left back as well.
 
I don't know is a simple answer the same as 99.9% of the people on here. Should he start now that is a different question.My answer is no.
 
The team tomorrow will tell us much about the intentions of SG regarding the approach this season.
If Welsh starts I would not be shocked but I would be disappointed.
 
King played well with the two I mentioned in the first half at Halifax. Even accepting the opposition that was the best I have seen PNE play for a very long time.

I agree those 3players played very well against Halifax & when King came on at HT v Burnley we started to play better aswell.
 
Yeah, great shout let's just throw the kids in with the lightweight Kilkenny!

Notts County, I would expect them to pack their midfield with battlers and experienced pros, who won't be shirking challenges. Browne, Brownhill and Kilkenny could get bullied and over-run.

King in front of the back 4 makes perfect sense to me, a bit of steel and protection.

I don't think we're up to Barca standards yet where we can just football teams off the park! Striking the right balance without being too negative or "gung-ho" is crucial.
 
I like King, and am happy to see him either start or be brought on when needs be.

Welsh strikes me as a nice guy that is good at what he does - King strikes me as an intimidating fucker that I wouldn't want to go anywhere near, whilst also being good at what he does.

That's the main difference for me.
 
Last edited:
Welsh ahead of King please

Why? Welsh is no better than King and has less presence in the midfield. I'd even play Keane before Welsh because though he's not the most amazing player, he puts tackles in and contributes more going forward than I think most people notice.

At home, for me, it's Kilkenny, Browne and Brownhill or just Kilkenny and Brownhill if we have a good enough striker to partner Garner.
 
I can't see Welsh starting tomorrow, think it'll be the 4-1-4-1 scenario with Kilkenny as the holding defensive midfielder and Garner up top supported by Gallagher, Browne, Brownhill & Little. That said the 4-1-4-1 formation is something I've heard SG talk about using during pre-season! I've seen every game and I couldn't tell you when he used that formation with the exception of possibly Morecambe!! But possibly I'm guessing.

Roll on tomorrow!!
 
Why? Welsh is no better than King and has less presence in the midfield. I'd even play Keane before Welsh because though he's not the most amazing player, he puts tackles in and contributes more going forward than I think most people notice.

At home, for me, it's Kilkenny, Browne and Brownhill or just Kilkenny and Brownhill if we have a good enough striker to partner Garner.

Keane is a yellow card waiting to happen.

King in the DM hole makes perfect sense to me, he has physical presence, decent enough passer and also pops up with a goal or two. I'd like to see him given the start ahead of Welsh.
 
Keane is a yellow card waiting to happen.

King in the DM hole makes perfect sense to me, he has physical presence, decent enough passer and also pops up with a goal or two. I'd like to see him given the start ahead of Welsh.

Sounds like we're singing from the same hymn sheet.

Notts County aren't going to lie down and die for us. Just because they narrowly avoided relegation last season, means jack-shit, and in any case they have a totally different team anyway.

Like I said previously, although it would be nice to throw in all our most naturally gifted footballers all at the same time, this could be asking for trouble, as chances are, we would get bullied out of it.

PS Beavon was one of our most gifted footballers, but was seen as not right for PNE by Grayson. Make of that what you will.
 
Back
Top