Skip to main content

Will Welsh start?

Will Welsh start?

Sounds like we're singing from the same hymn sheet.

Notts County aren't going to lie down and die for us. Just because they narrowly avoided relegation last season, means jack-shit, and in any case they have a totally different team anyway.

Like I said previously, although it would be nice to throw in all our most naturally gifted footballers all at the same time, this could be asking for trouble, as chances are, we would get bullied out of it.

PS Beavon was one of our most gifted footballers, but was seen as not right for PNE by Grayson. Make of that what you will.

This for me (personally) was our problem last year. Playing it safe at home!

Jack King isn't as effective as Kilkenny in building from the back. Yes I think I he can do that roll well, he can pick a pass and defend well but he doesn't dictate play like Kilkenny's capable of doing. We are at home against a team we're expected to beat so let's go for it!!
 
This for me (personally) was our problem last year. Playing it safe at home!

Jack King isn't as effective as Kilkenny in building from the back. Yes I think I he can do that roll well, he can pick a pass and defend well but he doesn't dictate play like Kilkenny's capable of doing. We are at home against a team we're expected to beat so let's go for it!!

I hear ya!

But...IMHO, we do need somebody in midfield who can put a tackle in. AB, NK & JB, are not tacklers and do not possess a lot of physical presence.

I would be delighted if we could "football Notts County to death", but I think we are far from the finished article, and clean sheets, both in pre-season and the latter part of last season, have become as rare as rocking horse shit.

King offers us some protection, and let's not forget, we have on many occasion failed to beat teams expected to struggle down at the fortress!

Would love nothing more than to see fast, flowing, expansive football from my football team, but, as it stands, I don't see this happening any time soon. We are what we are, a hardworking team that lacks quality. I would prefer SG picks a team to win the game without taking unnecessary risks.
 
Jack King ahead of the likes of Brownhill and Browne. Jesus Wept.

The point I was making was King vs Kilkenny as the starting defensive midfielder. Brownhill for now is a shoe in whilst Browne will fight for his place with Welsh, Keane & King.

To be fair King has been solid during pre season in that midfield role and has a goal threat so deserves his chance.
 
The great thing about that three-man midfield is that we have a lot of options. Kilkenny, King, Welsh even Keane could play the 'holding' role but Kilkenny could certainly also play further forward as could Keane and King. Brownhill and Browne, obviously, have to be further forward but depending on circumstances we could vary things between an ultra-attacking formation, Brownhill and Browne in front of Kilkenny, through a slightly more defensive one, say King for Kilkenny, to a really tough, aggressive one for the last 20 minutes of away matches on a Tuesday night, say Keane and Kilkenny in front of King. Another player who could slot in is Hayhurst - I think he would do well as the the left side of a three-man midfield.
 
I don't think Welsh will start. He will have a bigger role later in the season when the pitches deteriorate and matches get scrappy.

Choice tomorrow I think is Kilkenny, Browne and Brownhill OR King, Kilkenny and Brownhill.

Given that LEP are saying the former in their likely team then I imagine it will be that. Ben Davies at left back as well.

Unless we get Westley back our pitch won't deteriorate later on in the season and I can't remember many if any poor pitches at away games last season. I feel Welsh will play today but hope not as I think we should go with Browne, Brownhill and Kilkenny. I'd also start with the Ben Davies, purely because he's had good experience last season and looked good in the friendlies

I'm not bothered about what side Notts C put out, I'm confident in our ability to beat them, experience is valuable but not essential and I go with the saying that if you're good enough you're old enough.
 
Last edited:
Welsh gets a lot of unfair criticsm on here IMO.

Yes he's not the most technically gifted players and he want create chances...but that's not the sort of player he is.

Jon Parkin was a target man, you wouldn't then expect him to outpace the centre back running off the shoulder.

I agree Welsh probably shouldn't start against teams we will expect to have the majority of possession against, but when we play the likes of Shefield United, Bristol City etc especially away from home we will need someone who's hard in the tackle and wins us the ball back which is often what Welsh of does, and which IMO none of our other midfielders can do.

Andy Carroll is a target man who gets on the end of long balls and crosses. If you don't supply the long balls or crosses he's going to have a bad game.

Likewise , Welsh is a ball winner, if at home we have the ball for the majority of the time, Welsh is going to appear to have a bad game.

I assume the majority of 'Welsh fans' attend a fair few away games.
 
Last edited:
Expected line up:

Jj
Wiseman clarke wright laird
Welsh Kilkenny Brownhill
Gallagher
Little Garner

Something like that is highly likely though Woods for Wiseman, Ben Davies for Laird and King or Browne in midfield for Welsh are all possibilities. Upfront I would choose the same three but use them in a different way - Garner and Gallagher as a central striking partnership with Little running wider. Last season Gallagher was only really successful 'in the slot' behind a front two in that three-at-the-back formation with Humphrey and Laird as 'wing-backs'. But though that formation ground us out results away from home it was far too negative for home matches primarily because neither Humphrey nor Laird could provide any sort of attacking threat. That formation should really only be a tactical option this season for occasional use in tough away matches which means that Gallagher has got to be able to play as a conventional striker because he lacks the pace to play out wide.
 
Question answered. He should have. Hardly a tackle put in from the midfield area today.
 
Back
Top