Skip to main content

Wing backs.

Wing backs.

Joined
Jan 4, 2006
Messages
606
Sorry to be critical of a current Pne favourite but IMO Laird is not performing this season. Hes just been ok, not quite back to his best. As for Humphrey , where do i start?! Is it me or is he very frustrating? He ticks the basic boxes of being reasonabley fit and hard working but how many times has he beat a man or got a cross in? Also, his touch is woeful.
So, in a nutshell two of the key components which need to be functioning fully for this system to work are not.
I also think centre midfield is way short of a promotion winning pairing. Compare it to Gregan & ranks.
 
Laird is much better when playing behind a winger that he can overlap. He doesn't have the pace to be a wing back or a winger.

The midfield I agree, is simply not good enough.
 
Sorry to be critical of a current Pne favourite but IMO Laird is not performing this season. Hes just been ok, not quite back to his best. As for Humphrey , where do i start?! Is it me or is he very frustrating? He ticks the basic boxes of being reasonabley fit and hard working but how many times has he beat a man or got a cross in? Also, his touch is woeful.
So, in a nutshell two of the key components which need to be functioning fully for this system to work are not.
I also think centre midfield is way short of a promotion winning pairing. Compare it to Gregan & ranks.

Laird is one of my favourite players but in the wing-backs system he seems to be caught in no-man's land too many times and stands off the attacking winger too much when defending. Personally I think he'd have benefitted from not playing in midweek but a lack of defensive options meant he had to play.
 
Lat week we saw the two sides of Humphrey, first half very poor but in the second half when Welsh and Wroe were introduced he was much more involved and put in some great early crosses, beat him man often and did a fine job.
 
Lat week we saw the two sides of Humphrey, first half very poor but in the second half when Welsh and Wroe were introduced he was much more involved and put in some great early crosses, beat him man often and did a fine job.
Did nt go last week ( only really go to grounds i have nt been to before if its long distance these days!) so did nt see Humphrey perform so well. Id ask my nephew who was there but he was shitfaced.
 
Sorry to be critical of a current Pne favourite but IMO Laird is not performing this season. Hes just been ok, not quite back to his best. As for Humphrey , where do i start?! Is it me or is he very frustrating? He ticks the basic boxes of being reasonabley fit and hard working but how many times has he beat a man or got a cross in? Also, his touch is woeful.
So, in a nutshell two of the key components which need to be functioning fully for this system to work are not.
I also think centre midfield is way short of a promotion winning pairing. Compare it to Gregan & ranks.

Simple answer we do not have any, any players good enough to operate as wing backs !
 
The problem with wing backs is that the opposition can double up and nullify the system, Clark does seem to get forward to try and support Humphrey but Laird is seemingly expected to cover the whole of one side of the pitch with little assistance.
 
Simple answer we do not have any, any players good enough to operate as wing backs !

No we don't have players good enough to be wing backs. We also lack quality wingers however. Playing wing backs I would assume, is Grayson's way of best utilising the players that he has available.
 
No we don't have players good enough to be wing backs. We also lack quality wingers however. Playing wing backs I would assume, is Grayson's way of best utilising the players that he has available.

I actually like the wing-backs system, especially the space it gives Larid and Humphrey to exploit and when it works it works well. But my only concern with it would be who to play along-side Keane and behind the front-two because as today proves we can be too predictable if plan A doesn't work.
 
No we don't have players good enough to be wing backs. We also lack quality wingers however. Playing wing backs I would assume, is Grayson's way of best utilising the players that he has available.
Was Humphrey's not signed for this purpose, also Holmes is best if not only position is as a wide left palyer. We have not seen Humphrey's in a wide right role, but he definatley is not a wing back.
Back to basics and 4-4-2 SG ?
 
Was Humphrey's not signed for this purpose, also Holmes is best if not only position is as a wide left palyer. We have not seen Humphrey's in a wide right role, but he definatley is not a wing back.
Back to basics and 4-4-2 SG ?

If he was signed to be a quality winger, he has so far not delivered. He was played in a 442 at the start of the season and was not great. I like Holmes. I would also like to see Monakana back in the team but Grayson doesn't seem to keen on him. Holmes and Monakana would be my chosen wingers in a 442.
 
Last edited:
If he was signed to be a quality winger, he has so far not delivered. I like Holmes. I would like to see Monakana back in the team but Grayson doesn't seem to keen on him.

We have not seen him as a winger, just a wing back which he is obviously not, let's see if he can be that quality winger we he is meant to be, give hem a chance in a 4-4-2.
 
We have not seen him as a winger, just a wing back which he is obviously not, let's see if he can be that quality winger we he is meant to be, give hem a chance in a 4-4-2.
did he not play as winger against Wolves? Im sure we started as a 4-4-2
 
did he not play as winger against Wolves? Im sure we started as a 4-4-2

If we did it is just one game, I think we need to go back to 4-4-2 and play a few games together, we did to allow the wide players to get round tge back and have a go at defenders. Let the opposition worry about our attacking players, rather then our atttacking wide men having to think about tracking back and defending rather than attacking, which they seem to be doing at present ?
 
The problem with wing backs is that the opposition can double up and nullify the system, Clark does seem to get forward to try and support Humphrey but Laird is seemingly expected to cover the whole of one side of the pitch with little assistance.

Good point, there was a couple of times yesterday when Crewe had four men on Humphrey, effectively playing him out of the game
 
It is a good point about doubling up on wing backs. With only 1 man on each flank, it is quite easy to mark them out of the game by bringing across the extra cover. This could exploit the middle of the park but we don't play at the sort of pace to make the most of this and we lack that 1 player in the middle who could get things moving and pick a pass.

In terms of Humphrey's overall play, he lacks attacking flair I feel. He runs and works hard all down the flank which is why Grayson prefers him to Monakana but he struggles to take on a man. Monakana has a few tricks up his sleeve and he can create things but is lazy and weak defensively. Grayson sets his stall out to be hard to beat and doesn't like to concede, based on this Humphrey will always be selected before him.
 
I don't know whether it is me or what?

In the second half, Clarke did not pass to Humphrey once.

Admittedly Humphrey was pretty static, but he could have tried at least one pass to him.

As soon as Holmes came on, Clarke passed to him. Admittedly, Holmes was much more mobile, but is there something wrong in the camp?
 
I don't know whether it is me or what?

In the second half, Clarke did not pass to Humphrey once.

Admittedly Humphrey was pretty static, but he could have tried at least one pass to him.

As soon as Holmes came on, Clarke passed to him. Admittedly, Holmes was much more mobile, but is there something wrong in the camp?

The reason probably being that when Holmes came on, Hume went wide left, Laird to LB and Clarke to RB, ie we switched to 4-4-2.
 
The reason probably being that when Holmes came on, Hume went wide left, Laird to LB and Clarke to RB, ie we switched to 4-4-2.

I thought we went more 4-3-3 at times when Holmes came on, with Hume, Davies and Beavon as a front three, still made little difference and even after we made changes still did not look like getting back in the game.
 
Back
Top