Skip to main content

Wing backs.

Wing backs.

I thought we went more 4-3-3 at times when Holmes came on, with Hume, Davies and Beavon as a front three, still made little difference and even after we made changes still did not look like getting back in the game.

You may be right, it was hard to tell, especially as Holmes wanders all over the place. I know we have had some success with 3 at the back and certainly looked more solid defensively but personally I would revert to what most players at this level know, ie 4-4-2, even if that does mean not being able to accommodate all 3 of Hume, Davies and Beavon.
 
You may be right, it was hard to tell, especially as Holmes wanders all over the place. I know we have had some success with 3 at the back and certainly looked more solid defensively but personally I would revert to what most players at this level know, ie 4-4-2, even if that does mean not being able to accommodate all 3 of Hume, Davies and Beavon.

I would agree Schemer and SG would need to decide on his front two, Davies with either Hume or Beavon, which ever didn't start could be brought on from the bench.
I would personally go Rudd,Clarke,Huntingdon,Wright,Laird,Humphrey,Welsh,Wroe,Holmes,Davies & Hume.
 
I would agree Schemer and SG would need to decide on his front two, Davies with either Hume or Beavon, which ever didn't start could be brought on from the bench.
I would personally go Rudd,Clarke,Huntingdon,Wright,Laird,Humphrey,Welsh,Wroe,Holmes,Davies & Hume.

Wouldn't argue much with that really, although I'm not convinced by Humphrey, so maybe Holmes on the right and Hayhurst on the left. Keane has done well but would probably benefit from a break.
 
The reason probably being that when Holmes came on, Hume went wide left, Laird to LB and Clarke to RB, ie we switched to 4-4-2.
At times it was so obvious that he was deliberately not passing to Humphreys that it was either tactical (in which case why not sub him earlier) or signs of a rift.
 
At times it was so obvious that he was deliberately not passing to Humphreys that it was either tactical (in which case why not sub him earlier) or signs of a rift.

I don't think it was signs of a rift. More that Humphrey was playing shit and Clarke realised this.
 
Who is a wing back these days? There are great attacking full backs (like Baines, and Laird) but as an actual wing back you will struggle to find any. Humphrey works to a point because he's quick. Just a shame he's not very skillfull and rarely puts in a decent cross.

Grayson almost stumbled across this formation, and it worked so he stuck with it. It reminds me a bit of Brown having to go with 3 up front when Treacy was sold. Time is now to revert back to a formation that suits the squad of players that we have long term, which is 442.
 
The whole midfield of Laird Keane Byrom and Humphrey was totally ineffective, certainly gave the forwards very little to work on and so they had to come out of position to get the ball.

Waited too long to bring Holmes on, he should have done that at half time.

Set off like a house on fire but ran out of steam and ideas after 10 mins and Grayshon didnt change it round early enough.

Whats the point in having 3 decent forwards but giving them no service?
 
Wouldn't argue much with that really, although I'm not convinced by Humphrey, so maybe Holmes on the right and Hayhurst on the left. QUOTE]

Neither would I - much. But with Holmes on the right and free to move to more central positions, which is possibly the best way to use him, then what we really need is a pacy right-back to get up on the overlap and exploit the space he leaves behind. Surely that should be what we have signed Nicholson to do.
 
Wouldn't argue much with that really, although I'm not convinced by Humphrey, so maybe Holmes on the right and Hayhurst on the left. Keane has done well but would probably benefit from a break.

I am not convinced by Humphrey either, but should be given a go in a 4-4-2, with the back up of Clarke behind him, just to see if he is the fast attacking wide player we believed we had signed.
If not then SG has to come up with another plan, it does not look like Monakana will be returning, so SG will need another option in this position.
 
The whole midfield of Laird Keane Byrom and Humphrey was totally ineffective, certainly gave the forwards very little to work on and so they had to come out of position to get the ball.

Waited too long to bring Holmes on, he should have done that at half time.

Set off like a house on fire but ran out of steam and ideas after 10 mins and Grayshon didnt change it round early enough.

Whats the point in having 3 decent forwards but giving them no service?

Agree with all of this.
 
Back
Top