Skip to main content

Wrong tactics or wrong players?

Wrong tactics or wrong players?

Joined
Mar 2, 2006
Messages
11,374
Location
B6243
Don't get me wrong I'm delighted with tonight's result.

However, we were so, so lucky. Daylight robbery I think they call it. Chesterfield wasted several gilt edged chances as they battered us for the best part of an hour after we scored and then sat back to defend our penalty area.

I can understand SG wanting to play to those negative tactics but what I cannot understand is how he can possibly think that's a winning strategy with a centre midfield including Gally and Johnson. They're both fantastic players when we're in possession but pretty hopeless at defending. We were so weak defending in midfield and very, very lucky not to be punished.

Surely if he chooses that strategy he should also have players in midfield who can tackle.

Crikey, that was torture there tonight.

Think about it Simon. You got lucky tonight.
 
Which gilt edged chances were those?

The ones they blazed wildly over the bar, wide of the post and straight at our keeper. Several in the first half and even more as they pinned us in our own penalty area for most of the second.

Chesterield will feel very unlucky with that result.
 
Midfield was bypassed 99% of the game. Defence kept punting the ball up front to garner or beckford who had no chance of winning it, and it came straight back. The wingback formation didn't work very well as all of their play was on the wings. If we had gone to a 4-4-2 formation it would have nulled their attacking option and gave us more control in the midfield enabling players like Johnson to come into fruition.
 
The ones they blazed wildly over the bar, wide of the post and straight at our keeper. Several in the first half and even more as they pinned us in our own penalty area for most of the second.

Chesterield will feel very unlucky with that result.

Um Ok.
 

We allowed them 65% possession, mostly in our half, and 20 shots at our goal.

Luckily for us their shooting tonight was shit so we still hold our slender lead.

If its SG's intention to defend the whole of the remainder of the tie from the moment we took the lead 6 minutes into the 180 then please god get some players in midfield who actually know how to defend. It's laughable watching Gally and DJ fanny about trying and failing to do it. Not good management IMHO. (we looked far better eventually when he put NK on)
 
No he isn't.

They did not have single gilt edged chance throughout the game.

You keep kidding yourself.

They had 20 shots at our goal, simple chances wasted, countless last ditch blocks and clearances inside our penalty area, ball pinging across our six yard box, several free kicks just outside our box and corners and crosses flying in.

I was there mate. Believe me we were extremely lucky to hold on to our one goal lead. It seemed just a matter of time before all of their pressure told with an equaliser but luckily for us they wasted all of their chances with wild finishing. The most frequently sung song from the PNE fans tonight "What the fuckin hell was that?" at each and every poor shot.
 
You keep kidding yourself.

They had 20 shots at our goal, simple chances wasted, countless last ditch blocks and clearances inside our penalty area, ball pinging across our six yard box, several free kicks just outside our box and corners and crosses flying in.

I was there mate. Believe me we were extremely lucky to hold on to our one goal lead. It seemed just a matter of time before all of their pressure told with an equaliser but luckily for us they wasted all of their chances with wild finishing. The most frequently sung song from the PNE fans tonight "What the fuckin hell was that?" at each and every poor shot.

Do you know what a gilt edged chance is?

On your definition, we had about 25 last Sunday.
 
20 shots and 0 goals

There's a reason football matches don't end up with cricket scores. Defenders are there to defend, put players off, make them hit balls wide and over the bar.

They didn't waste "gilt egded" chances, we stopped them taking them.
 
Back
Top