Skip to main content

Yes another Eoin Doyle thread.....

Yes another Eoin Doyle thread.....

Joined
Aug 22, 2004
Messages
3,052
Probably setting myself up for some stick but here goes....

Think we are pretty all agreed that we need another striker. SG has stated that he'd like another.
But who is a realistic target?

1. We obviously can't afford the ready made goalscoring Championship striker

2. Appears current leading League 1 strikers are out of our price range too given Conor Washington's £2.5m transfer fee. Can't see Walsall selling Bradshaw for £500k(our rumoured offer). Would make sense for them to hang on til another QPR type club come along.


So what do we do?

1.Do we look at players that have done ok previously at this level that have maybe lost their way . Players like Matty Derbyshire or Gary Madine for example.

2. Forwards that scored goals at the level bellow (we currently have 2 of those)

3. Do we look at League 2 or the Conference in hope we find another David Nugent or Andre Gray?

4. Look abroad or Scottish League?

At the moment we have two 27year olds (still relatively young) who scored Played 76 games and scored an impressive 52 goals between them at League 1 level last season.(haven't included Doyle's Cardiff apps or goals)

Both are still at a good age and at the moment Doyle is probably within our price range (maybe not £750k fee Cardiff paid though)
Just think a club of our size in this league need to find players who we can work with,develop and improve ( I include all our current forwards in that). Maybe thats a player that isn't in a side or scoring goals right now. Remember this was what David Moyes did at this level with Richard Cresswell.

I'm a fan of Doyle and feel he can offer us something and young enough to improve. Agreed his confidence looks shot in front of goal right now as does Joe Garner's. The fact both missing chances is a good sign. Better that than never being in the right place.

Doyles Last 4 League games -

Scored equaliser v Rotherham
Good link up play with Gallagher for 1st goal v Bristol City
Control and cross for goal v Ipswich
Good link up play with Pearson for marginally offside goal v Ipswich
Assist v Brentford

Yes he missed a chance he should have buried but the abuse and blame aimed his way on here yesterday pretty sad. Vermijl got similar stick last year yet 4 weeks later theres demands we should sign.

Pays to be patient in my opinion.
 
Probably setting myself up for some stick but here goes....

Think we are pretty all agreed that we need another striker. SG has stated that he'd like another.
But who is a realistic target?

1. We obviously can't afford the ready made goalscoring Championship striker

2. Appears current leading League 1 strikers are out of our price range too given Conor Washington's £2.5m transfer fee. Can't see Walsall selling Bradshaw for £500k(our rumoured offer). Would make sense for them to hang on til another QPR type club come along.


So what do we do?

1.Do we look at players that have done ok previously at this level that have maybe lost their way . Players like Matty Derbyshire or Gary Madine for example.

2. Forwards that scored goals at the level bellow (we currently have 2 of those)

3. Do we look at League 2 or the Conference in hope we find another David Nugent or Andre Gray?

4. Look abroad or Scottish League?

At the moment we have two 27year olds (still relatively young) who scored Played 76 games and scored an impressive 52 goals between them at League 1 level last season.(haven't included Doyle's Cardiff apps or goals)

Both are still at a good age and at the moment Doyle is probably within our price range (maybe not £750k fee Cardiff paid though)
Just think a club of our size in this league need to find players who we can work with,develop and improve ( I include all our current forwards in that). Maybe thats a player that isn't in a side or scoring goals right now. Remember this was what David Moyes did at this level with Richard Cresswell.

I'm a fan of Doyle and feel he can offer us something and young enough to improve. Agreed his confidence looks shot in front of goal right now as does Joe Garner's. The fact both missing chances is a good sign. Better that than never being in the right place.

Doyles Last 4 League games -

Scored equaliser v Rotherham
Good link up play with Gallagher for 1st goal v Bristol City
Control and cross for goal v Ipswich
Good link up play with Pearson for marginally offside goal v Ipswich
Assist v Brentford

Yes he missed a chance he should have buried but the abuse and blame aimed his way on here yesterday pretty sad. Vermijl got similar stick last year yet 4 weeks later theres demands we should sign.

Pays to be patient in my opinion.
He was also instrumental in the goal we scored yesterday aswell.
 
Probably setting myself up for some stick but here goes....

Think we are pretty all agreed that we need another striker. SG has stated that he'd like another.
But who is a realistic target?

1. We obviously can't afford the ready made goalscoring Championship striker

2. Appears current leading League 1 strikers are out of our price range too given Conor Washington's £2.5m transfer fee. Can't see Walsall selling Bradshaw for £500k(our rumoured offer). Would make sense for them to hang on til another QPR type club come along.


So what do we do?

1.Do we look at players that have done ok previously at this level that have maybe lost their way . Players like Matty Derbyshire or Gary Madine for example.

2. Forwards that scored goals at the level bellow (we currently have 2 of those)

3. Do we look at League 2 or the Conference in hope we find another David Nugent or Andre Gray?

4. Look abroad or Scottish League?

At the moment we have two 27year olds (still relatively young) who scored Played 76 games and scored an impressive 52 goals between them at League 1 level last season.(haven't included Doyle's Cardiff apps or goals)

Both are still at a good age and at the moment Doyle is probably within our price range (maybe not £750k fee Cardiff paid though)
Just think a club of our size in this league need to find players who we can work with,develop and improve ( I include all our current forwards in that). Maybe thats a player that isn't in a side or scoring goals right now. Remember this was what David Moyes did at this level with Richard Cresswell.

I'm a fan of Doyle and feel he can offer us something and young enough to improve. Agreed his confidence looks shot in front of goal right now as does Joe Garner's. The fact both missing chances is a good sign. Better that than never being in the right place.

Doyles Last 4 League games -

Scored equaliser v Rotherham
Good link up play with Gallagher for 1st goal v Bristol City
Control and cross for goal v Ipswich
Good link up play with Pearson for marginally offside goal v Ipswich
Assist v Brentford

Yes he missed a chance he should have buried but the abuse and blame aimed his way on here yesterday pretty sad. Vermijl got similar stick last year yet 4 weeks later theres demands we should sign.

Pays to be patient in my opinion.

If you want a striker who's going to improve and you're going to give them that opportunity, 27 is not really young enough. I'd much rather buy someone who's closer to around 21 and give them that time. Strikers generally peak at 28 to 30 so Doyle isn't going to improve all that much in my opinion.

Frankly, I'd give Hugill that chance over Doyle and we already have him. Were not going up, not going down, why not play Hugill properly and see how he does when he's had 5 or 10 games straight?
 
Probably setting myself up for some stick but here goes....

Think we are pretty all agreed that we need another striker. SG has stated that he'd like another.
But who is a realistic target?

1. We obviously can't afford the ready made goalscoring Championship striker

2. Appears current leading League 1 strikers are out of our price range too given Conor Washington's £2.5m transfer fee. Can't see Walsall selling Bradshaw for £500k(our rumoured offer). Would make sense for them to hang on til another QPR type club come along.


So what do we do?

1.Do we look at players that have done ok previously at this level that have maybe lost their way . Players like Matty Derbyshire or Gary Madine for example.

2. Forwards that scored goals at the level bellow (we currently have 2 of those)

3. Do we look at League 2 or the Conference in hope we find another David Nugent or Andre Gray?

4. Look abroad or Scottish League?

At the moment we have two 27year olds (still relatively young) who scored Played 76 games and scored an impressive 52 goals between them at League 1 level last season.(haven't included Doyle's Cardiff apps or goals)

Both are still at a good age and at the moment Doyle is probably within our price range (maybe not £750k fee Cardiff paid though)
Just think a club of our size in this league need to find players who we can work with,develop and improve ( I include all our current forwards in that). Maybe thats a player that isn't in a side or scoring goals right now. Remember this was what David Moyes did at this level with Richard Cresswell.

I'm a fan of Doyle and feel he can offer us something and young enough to improve. Agreed his confidence looks shot in front of goal right now as does Joe Garner's. The fact both missing chances is a good sign. Better that than never being in the right place.

Doyles Last 4 League games -

Scored equaliser v Rotherham
Good link up play with Gallagher for 1st goal v Bristol City
Control and cross for goal v Ipswich
Good link up play with Pearson for marginally offside goal v Ipswich
Assist v Brentford

Yes he missed a chance he should have buried but the abuse and blame aimed his way on here yesterday pretty sad. Vermijl got similar stick last year yet 4 weeks later theres demands we should sign.

Pays to be patient in my opinion.
not good enough lets be honest if he any good Cardiff would not let him leave on loan he is a very good league one striker ,but he is here till end of the season and I hope we don't sign him in summer
 
Probably setting myself up for some stick but here goes....

Think we are pretty all agreed that we need another striker. SG has stated that he'd like another.
But who is a realistic target?

1. We obviously can't afford the ready made goalscoring Championship striker

2. Appears current leading League 1 strikers are out of our price range too given Conor Washington's £2.5m transfer fee. Can't see Walsall selling Bradshaw for £500k(our rumoured offer). Would make sense for them to hang on til another QPR type club come along.


So what do we do?

1.Do we look at players that have done ok previously at this level that have maybe lost their way . Players like Matty Derbyshire or Gary Madine for example.

2. Forwards that scored goals at the level bellow (we currently have 2 of those)

3. Do we look at League 2 or the Conference in hope we find another David Nugent or Andre Gray?

4. Look abroad or Scottish League?

At the moment we have two 27year olds (still relatively young) who scored Played 76 games and scored an impressive 52 goals between them at League 1 level last season.(haven't included Doyle's Cardiff apps or goals)

Both are still at a good age and at the moment Doyle is probably within our price range (maybe not £750k fee Cardiff paid though)
Just think a club of our size in this league need to find players who we can work with,develop and improve ( I include all our current forwards in that). Maybe thats a player that isn't in a side or scoring goals right now. Remember this was what David Moyes did at this level with Richard Cresswell.

I'm a fan of Doyle and feel he can offer us something and young enough to improve. Agreed his confidence looks shot in front of goal right now as does Joe Garner's. The fact both missing chances is a good sign. Better that than never being in the right place.

Doyles Last 4 League games -

Scored equaliser v Rotherham
Good link up play with Gallagher for 1st goal v Bristol City
Control and cross for goal v Ipswich
Good link up play with Pearson for marginally offside goal v Ipswich
Assist v Brentford

Yes he missed a chance he should have buried but the abuse and blame aimed his way on here yesterday pretty sad. Vermijl got similar stick last year yet 4 weeks later theres demands we should sign.

Pays to be patient in my opinion.

I agree. Some People on here are too quick to judge and, as in the case of Vermijl,left with egg on their face when they see what we actually have. Doyle is slowly but surely getting to grips with our style, formation,ideas and players. I'm not going to mention the other players that have been slaughtered then come good, there is no point, some people form an opinion and that's it.

As for signing another striker,i'd be looking at splashing the cash Now. So we, are and the New player is, ready for an all out assault on promotion next season

ps When I say Splashing the cash I don't mean blow 6,7,8 million on a player, I just mean don't lose out on a target because we are not prepared to spend a little more as in the case of Darikwa in the Summer..
 
not good enough lets be honest if he any good Cardiff would not let him leave on loan he is a very good league one striker ,but he is here till end of the season and I hope we don't sign him in summer
If Cardiif wanted rid in August surely they'd have accepted our bid
 
Probably setting myself up for some stick but here goes.... <snip>
On the contrary, you make some very good points, and you show very clearly that there are no easy answers.

Doyle is incredibly frustrating, and fluffing his lines as often as he has recently is criminal for a striker, but "sending him back" isn't the answer, and would just be "cutting off our nose to spite our face".

He's still a better option than Hugill in my opinion, and so until we get someone better in, he has to start (or we have to bench him and commit to one-up-front for a while).
 
On the contrary, you make some very good points, and you show very clearly that there are no easy answers.

Doyle is incredibly frustrating, and fluffing his lines as often as he has recently is criminal for a striker, but "sending him back" isn't the answer, and would just be "cutting off our nose to spite our face".

He's still a better option than Hugill in my opinion, and so until we get someone better in, he has to start (or we have to bench him and commit to one-up-front for a while).

Or maybe give Hugill,I know you think Doyle is a better option, an extended run in the team. This seems to be what SG is doing with ED.If is dry spell continues then maybe Hugill should be afforded the same opportunity.
 
On the contrary, you make some very good points, and you show very clearly that there are no easy answers.

Doyle is incredibly frustrating, and fluffing his lines as often as he has recently is criminal for a striker, but "sending him back" isn't the answer, and would just be "cutting off our nose to spite our face".

He's still a better option than Hugill in my opinion, and so until we get someone better in, he has to start (or we have to bench him and commit to one-up-front for a while).


The speech marks were not required.
 
Weirdly in 11 starts for Cardiff he scored 5 goals, yet they didnt play him more?
Yes, but two of them were pens, and he also came on as a sub 5 times.

He scored twice from open play in his 11 starts.
 
Doyle has been disappointing and my initial feeling would be to send him back if it is possible, but then I looked for a reason that he has been poor.

I may be wrong here, but when he had his success in L1 at Chesterfield wasn't he their main/only striker in the team, whereas here, he's perhaps seen as the support striker to Garner. It also takes some strikers a lot of games and sometimes a full season or even more to hit a rich vein of scoring. Joey certainly fits that category.

I suppose there's a fine line between giving the lad time, and making a decision that he is not suited to our style of play. Maybe, if Garner gets suspended and Doyle becomes our No 1 striker for a few games we may see a different player. I'm not holding my breath though, as I'm just trying to find a way of giving the lad more time.
 
We can - and must do - better than Doyle.

2 goals in 17 games.

Over a season (well, 42/43 games), that is a fantastic return of 5 goals. Well worth laying out £900k on!!
 
If you want a striker who's going to improve and you're going to give them that opportunity, 27 is not really young enough. I'd much rather buy someone who's closer to around 21 and give them that time. Strikers generally peak at 28 to 30 so Doyle isn't going to improve all that much in my opinion.

Frankly, I'd give Hugill that chance over Doyle and we already have him. Were not going up, not going down, why not play Hugill properly and see how he does when he's had 5 or 10 games straight?

It's simple - Hugill can't manage 5-10 games straight, he either gets red carded, injured, or is not good enough and falls back down the pecking order. We've had him nearly two seasons now. What more proof do we need that he can't cut the mustard?
 
Maybe ? - the question begged is how did Chesterfield use him ? - I know you have to consider the difference between League 2 , I think they won it ? , League 1 & the championship - then they made the play offs in League 1 as we know

I remember a night game in League 1 , I think it was a draw and people complaining ; and I think ? he was a problem for PNE
 
Back
Top