Skip to main content

Yes another Eoin Doyle thread.....

Yes another Eoin Doyle thread.....

I don't think a players age should matter in our search for a striker - we need goals and need 'em fast. As they say, 'a good old 'un who CAN is better than a good young 'un who MIGHT' any day of the week. And surely there are plenty of older strikers around who know where the net is?
 
We can - and must do - better than Doyle.

2 goals in 17 games.

Over a season (well, 42/43 games), that is a fantastic return of 5 goals. Well worth laying out £900k on!!
Joe Garner

28 games

3 goals

9 yellow cards

1 red card

Over a 46 game season that means he will have scored

errrr

3!
 
Assuming how many goals a striker will finish the season with based on his contribution so far is pointless. What would we have predicted Beckford would have finished last season with based on his first few weeks, when he couldn't hit a cow's arse? Not 18, that's for sure.
There are such things as scoring spree's or lucky streaks - look at Garner a couple of seasons ago -nowt by November, 20 plus at the end of the season.
 
I don't think a players age should matter in our search for a striker - we need goals and need 'em fast. As they say, 'a good old 'un who CAN is better than a good young 'un who MIGHT' any day of the week. And surely there are plenty of older strikers around who know where the net is?
You make it sound easy.
Like who?
 
I don't think a players age should matter in our search for a striker - we need goals and need 'em fast. As they say, 'a good old 'un who CAN is better than a good young 'un who MIGHT' any day of the week. And surely there are plenty of older strikers around who know where the net is?

I agree , in principle ! , but I don't think it's Trevor Hemmings and ultimately Simon Grayson's model - the older Championship forwards may be used to high wages and they may be thought of as disruptive , upsetting SG's group ethos .

I remember that comment by ironically , Joey Garner ; in that official Springfields video clip - a van draws up and he says that'll be Kev's wage , OK - it was just banter , not malicious , but there's many a true thing said in jest .

Simon Grayson dropped a few hints in the Radio Lancashire interview by saying look at all these " bigger clubs " on bigger budgets that are below us
 
Last edited:
Not going to get too excited about anyone or anything this season, all about staying up this year.

As I think moyes once said lets get 50 points first then see were we are from there.
 
Joe Garner

28 games

3 goals

9 yellow cards

1 red card

Over a 46 game season that means he will have scored

errrr

3!

Yes, I was expecting this obvious reply.

1 - Garner is our player.
2 - Garner has 2 very prolific seasons in the bank, not a half a season flash in the pan like Doyle.
3 - Garner puts a 100% shift in every game whereas Doyle, he tends to hide (imo).
4 - Garner is our talisman.
5 - Garner is more of a goal threat than Doyle. Been unlucky hitting the woodwork how many times this season?
6 - Garner is physically stronger as seen in his play. Doyle appears to be weak.
7 - Garner can play in a pair or up top by himself. Point 6 reflects this.
8 - Garner has decent movement and shows for the ball all across the front line.
9 - Garner has very good link up play (see Garner / Beckford)
10- Garner requires a decent strike partner and the answer is not Eoin Doyle.


There is only room for one ginna up top at PNE! 😀
 
You make it sound easy.
Like who?

Wilbraham? Scored against us twice recently.
Madden?
Holt? Similar career scoring record to Beckford.
Just two or three that spring to mind, and before you say it, yes, I know these are'nt the greatest players around, but they could have done us a short term job for the season and surely would have done better than Keane, Hugill or Doyle?
 
Yes, I was expecting this obvious reply.

1 - Garner is our player.
2 - Garner has 2 very prolific seasons in the bank, not a half a season flash in the pan like Doyle.
3 - Garner puts a 100% shift in every game whereas Doyle, he tends to hide (imo).
4 - Garner is our talisman.
5 - Garner is more of a goal threat than Doyle. Been unlucky hitting the woodwork how many times this season?
6 - Garner is physically stronger as seen in his play. Doyle appears to be weak.
7 - Garner can play in a pair or up top by himself. Point 6 reflects this.
8 - Garner has decent movement and shows for the ball all across the front line.
9 - Garner has very good link up play (see Garner / Beckford)
10- Garner requires a decent strike partner and the answer is not Eoin Doyle.


There is only room for one ginna up top at PNE! 😀

That's a bit ginger-ist. You'll be demanding a maximum quota of gingers next !!!
 
Wilbraham? Scored against us twice recently.
Madden?
Holt? Similar career scoring record to Beckford.
Just two or three that spring to mind, and before you say it, yes, I know these are'nt the greatest players around, but they could have done us a short term job for the season and surely would have done better than Keane, Hugill or Doyle?
So Bristol City will hand us there top scorer will they??
 
So Bristol City will hand us there top scorer will they??


Someone said to me on social media - think he's a Derby fan , " Is he still playing ? " - my reply was yeah but he's usually in the Bristol 1st XI and more often than not he scores

Bristol must have some sort of arrangement re training at his age - I believe Liverpool in their relative ! prime used to play a televised game on a sunday , then they'd say to Kenny Dalglish - see you on thursday , as he could be trusted to look after himself and their system relied on a " link player " between the midfield and the other forward

Obviously the Championship with the Tuesday , Saturday fixtures is a bit more demanding
 
Last edited:
Yes, I was expecting this obvious reply.

1 - Garner is our player.
2 - Garner has 2 very prolific seasons in the bank, not a half a season flash in the pan like Doyle.
3 - Garner puts a 100% shift in every game whereas Doyle, he tends to hide (imo).
4 - Garner is our talisman.
5 - Garner is more of a goal threat than Doyle. Been unlucky hitting the woodwork how many times this season?
6 - Garner is physically stronger as seen in his play. Doyle appears to be weak.
7 - Garner can play in a pair or up top by himself. Point 6 reflects this.
8 - Garner has decent movement and shows for the ball all across the front line.
9 - Garner has very good link up play (see Garner / Beckford)
10- Garner requires a decent strike partner and the answer is not Eoin Doyle.


There is only room for one ginna up top at PNE! 😀

Could not agree more buddy. To get the best out of Garner, we need to find him a decent strike partner. Beckford's injury has robbed us of him for this season and I think this has obviously effected Joe. He's been doing the work of two strikers this season due to the shabby work rates of Doyle and Keane. Hugill plain and simply is not good enough for this level. We need Simon to come in and get Joe some help up there. I quite liked Clarke Harris from Rotherham, quick and mobile and hes scored a couple this year. Someone in that mould would suit us I think.
 
Could not agree more buddy. To get the best out of Garner, we need to find him a decent strike partner. Beckford's injury has robbed us of him for this season and I think this has obviously effected Joe. He's been doing the work of two strikers this season due to the shabby work rates of Doyle and Keane. Hugill plain and simply is not good enough for this level. We need Simon to come in and get Joe some help up there. I quite liked Clarke Harris from Rotherham, quick and mobile and hes scored a couple this year. Someone in that mould would suit us I think.

Just said something very similar on the other thread. Spot on.

Losing Beckford was a massive blow to how we planned to set up.
 
Could not agree more buddy. To get the best out of Garner, we need to find him a decent strike partner. Beckford's injury has robbed us of him for this season and I think this has obviously effected Joe. He's been doing the work of two strikers this season due to the shabby work rates of Doyle and Keane. Hugill plain and simply is not good enough for this level. We need Simon to come in and get Joe some help up there. I quite liked Clarke Harris from Rotherham, quick and mobile and hes scored a couple this year. Someone in that mould would suit us I think.
they highlighted clarke-harris on soccer am the other day. unfortuntely, it was for being laughably shit rather than any good.
 
Doyle should have finished his chance yesterday but he's low on confidence. Played in the middle with Garner, he'll start scoring.
 
Garner is not suited to the lone striker role because he lacks the ability to hold the ball up while support arrives though he is very good at providing first-time touches - he absolutely has to be played with a partner close by him. What sort of partner is a another matter - he can be played as a finisher alongside a targetman or as the targetman alongside a finisher. He played the first of those roles alongside Kevin Davies and the second alongside Beckford.

Doyle is a penalty box player who needs someone to provide the flick-ons and lay-offs to create chances for him. Garner has been doing that but frankly Doyle has been missing the chances. But it is an exercise in utter futility to play Doyle in any sort of wide position. A 4.3.3 with Garner all by himself in the centre and, say, Doyle and Reach 20-30 yards away on either side is a nonsense and if that is what we played yesterday then it is little wonder we lost.

I still think our best bet in the short term for getting more goals from the strikeforce would be to free up Garner by bringing in a big rough centre forward on loan to partner him till the end of the season - another Brett Angell. Otherwise we persist with Doyle or give Robinson or Hugill a go. But whatever it has to be Garner and someone else upfront as a strikeforce not Garner running himself silly with no support. That approach is bankrupt.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top