Skip to main content

Yes another Eoin Doyle thread.....

Yes another Eoin Doyle thread.....

If you want a striker who's going to improve and you're going to give them that opportunity, 27 is not really young enough. I'd much rather buy someone who's closer to around 21 and give them that time. Strikers generally peak at 28 to 30 so Doyle isn't going to improve all that much in my opinion.

Frankly, I'd give Hugill that chance over Doyle and we already have him. Were not going up, not going down, why not play Hugill properly and see how he does when he's had 5 or 10 games straight?

On the button this ^^^^^
 
If you want a striker who's going to improve and you're going to give them that opportunity, 27 is not really young enough. I'd much rather buy someone who's closer to around 21 and give them that time. Strikers generally peak at 28 to 30 so Doyle isn't going to improve all that much in my opinion.

Frankly, I'd give Hugill that chance over Doyle and we already have him. Were not going up, not going down, why not play Hugill properly and see how he does when he's had 5 or 10 games straight?
Think its about having the right balance of youth and experience. We already have May and Hugill at 21/22 yo .
 
He's garbage but steady garbage. We need to keep him on loan until the end of the season while bring Beckford and May ( a better player in my opinion but I know that's not popular) are nursed back to fitness.

i would sell Hugill to whoever wants him for as much as they will pay and then sign a Nugentesque off the radar talented player from the back of beyond.

We'd still have Doyle missing chances and Garner falling over and hugill not playing (as we've moved him on). We'd just have another option who might be better.
 
He's garbage but steady garbage. We need to keep him on loan until the end of the season while bring Beckford and May ( a better player in my opinion but I know that's not popular) are nursed back to fitness.

i would sell Hugill to whoever wants him for as much as they will pay and then sign a Nugentesque off the radar talented player from the back of beyond.

We'd still have Doyle missing chances and Garner falling over and hugill not playing (as we've moved him on). We'd just have another option who might be better.

With May, I am with you.

Got slated on here by many for defending May. He has played 4 times for us off memory. Barely had a chance. I think had he played the 17 games that Doyle has played, his return would have been better.
 
Ive always been a Doyle fan but watching him on Saturday he just looked like he wasnt with it, not putting in enough effort to win the ball especially for headers. He chased players down, which I admire, but the tackles he made to get the ball back were poor. He just sort of stuck a leg out and hoped it would work. Not good enough Im afraid, lets try someone else.
 
Ive always been a Doyle fan but watching him on Saturday he just looked like he wasnt with it, not putting in enough effort to win the ball especially for headers. He chased players down, which I admire, but the tackles he made to get the ball back were poor. He just sort of stuck a leg out and hoped it would work. Not good enough Im afraid, lets try someone else.

There is a strong case for starting Robinson alongside Garner in the next match.
 
Think he is the best option afforded to us at this moment in time which is hard to take, but we are not as cash rich and top prospect as we were in League 1. We need to establish ourselves a bit more before we can start getting recognised Championship Strikers/Goalscorers.

January is a weird transfer window as people are reluctant to sell because they either want to go up or stay up, add to that I bet 70% off the Championship are looking for a regular goalscorer and ones that are available at a reasonable price are as rare as unicorn droppings.

Patience is the name of the game on this one.
 
With May, I am with you.

Got slated on here by many for defending May. He has played 4 times for us off memory. Barely had a chance. I think had he played the 17 games that Doyle has played, his return would have been better.

Agreed, I think May will come good - if his rehab goes to plan. In his last couple of brief performances, he was starting to look sharper. Considering he had an interrupted pre-season at Sheff Weds & not many minutes for us, those that have written him off already are foolish & typical of a number of posters on here, getting on players backs immediately - the Pearson questioning is fucking outrageous so early on - and he's given 2 decent performances out of the 3 appearances.
 
Reading the end of today's LEP suggest to me that SG no longer wants Doyle on a Perm. Might make some on here happy.

Doyle, on loan from Cardiff City for the season, was linked recently with a permanent move to Deepdale during the window.

But North End are content with the current loan arrangement.
 
Reading the end of today's LEP suggest to me that SG no longer wants Doyle on a Perm. Might make some on here happy.

Doyle, on loan from Cardiff City for the season, was linked recently with a permanent move to Deepdale during the window.

But North End are content with the current loan arrangement.

I'm happy. Had the time, not produced. Bad loan signing.
 
Reading the end of today's LEP suggest to me that SG no longer wants Doyle on a Perm. Might make some on here happy.

Doyle, on loan from Cardiff City for the season, was linked recently with a permanent move to Deepdale during the window.

But North End are content with the current loan arrangement.
Did SG ever officially say he wanted Doyle on a permanent this window?

As opposed to "reports" from "sources" who "understood" he wanted him?

Just wondering as I don't remember seeing an official comment myself.
 
Did SG ever officially say he wanted Doyle on a permanent this window?

As opposed to "reports" from "sources" who "understood" he wanted him?

Just wondering as I don't remember seeing an official comment myself.

Agreed.

Maybe Cardiff asked the question and we declined.
 
Did SG ever officially say he wanted Doyle on a permanent this window?

As opposed to "reports" from "sources" who "understood" he wanted him?

Just wondering as I don't remember seeing an official comment myself.

Does not matter whether it's this Window or last, we had a Perm bid rejected in the Summer, that we all know. This may make some assume we want Doyle on a Perm still if he becomes available. Hopefully it's not the case.
 
Yes another Eoin Doyle thread.....

Reading the end of today's LEP suggest to me that SG no longer wants Doyle on a Perm. Might make some on here happy.

Doyle, on loan from Cardiff City for the season, was linked recently with a permanent move to Deepdale during the window.

But North End are content with the current loan arrangement.

Very happy. Felt we rushed through both him and May and never got the excitement when they joined.
 
Did SG ever officially say he wanted Doyle on a permanent this window?

As opposed to "reports" from "sources" who "understood" he wanted him?

Just wondering as I don't remember seeing an official comment myself.

Agreed.

Maybe Cardiff asked the question and we declined.

Might be wrong but didn't Doyle say at a fans forum that SG wanted to buy him permanently but Cardiff wouldn't allow it ?

Think there was a thread about that particular forum on here which mentioned it.
 
Back
Top