Skip to main content

Yesterday Possibly Explained

Yesterday Possibly Explained

Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
14,205
Location
San Diego (A Whales Vagina)
Now don't get me wrong I was as pissed off as anyone that yesterday Crewe were better than us in every department, we should have beaten them, but it isn't our god given right to win. After examining the result a bit more closely there can be many reasons that explain why we lost that game.

1. Some players were holding themselves back so that they didn't pick up a silly booking or get injured and were out of the play offs.

2. Crewe were fighting for there lives and simply put more into the game. Compared to some of our players who I think might have been holding themselves back.

3. Beavon and Garner didn't get a sniff all day because both there centre halves were huge and won everything in the air, adding to that our pedestrian midfield of Welsh and Kilkenny we had no chance against there CB. Grayson got that one wrong for me.

4. The midfield pairing of Welsh and Kilkenny doesnt work, especially away from home where teams will press us quickly. Too many times yesterday the ball was played sideways or backwards, the safe option. Browne in for me please as he can beat a man with the drop of his shoulder, he did it 4 or 5 times yesterday once he came on.

5. Tactics cost us the game.
 
Now don't get me wrong I was as pissed off as anyone that yesterday Crewe were better than us in every department, we should have beaten them, but it isn't our god given right to win. After examining the result a bit more closely there can be many reasons that explain why we lost that game.

1. Some players were holding themselves back so that they didn't pick up a silly booking or get injured and were out of the play offs.

2. Crewe were fighting for there lives and simply put more into the game. Compared to some of our players who I think might have been holding themselves back.

3. Beavon and Garner didn't get a sniff all day because both there centre halves were huge and won everything in the air, adding to that our pedestrian midfield of Welsh and Kilkenny we had no chance against there CB. Grayson got that one wrong for me.

4. The midfield pairing of Welsh and Kilkenny doesnt work, especially away from home where teams will press us quickly. Too many times yesterday the ball was played sideways or backwards, the safe option. Browne in for me please as he can beat a man with the drop of his shoulder, he did it 4 or 5 times yesterday once he came on.

5. Tactics cost us the game.

Stop making excuses..We were shit and there was no need for it.......
 
As the OP said, it isn't our god given right to win. You can dissect performances all you like but its football and shit happens. Who would have seen the Chelsea result vs Norwich coming today. We'll see a different team on saturday im sure.
 
My main concern is we are too nice. Away from home, Holmes and Gallagher are ineffective, great when we are tonking crap teams at Deepdale but not prepared to put it in away from home when it's tough. Holmes in particular is disappointing in attitude and I wouldn't keep him next season regardless of division we are in.

There is no big leader in the team to drag the lads through the game when we aren't playing well. No Gregan or Lucketti. Hopefully it won't stop us going up but again, whichever division we are in, it needs addressing next season and probably why Peter Clarke is Deepdale bound.
 
As the OP said, it isn't our god given right to win. You can dissect performances all you like but its football and shit happens. Who would have seen the Chelsea result vs Norwich coming today. We'll see a different team on saturday im sure.

Gods got bugger all to do with us being in the playoff places or Crewe being cannon fodder...... Ability and effort.. No excuse for yesterdays " whimper " of a finale..... I hope it's out of our system now.
 
My main concern is we are too nice. Away from home, Holmes and Gallagher are ineffective, great when we are tonking crap teams at Deepdale but not prepared to put it in away from home when it's tough. Holmes in particular is disappointing in attitude and I wouldn't keep him next season regardless of division we are in.

There is no big leader in the team to drag the lads through the game when we aren't playing well. No Gregan or Lucketti. Hopefully it won't stop us going up but again, whichever division we are in, it needs addressing next season and probably why Peter Clarke is Deepdale bound.

We need a " gripper" ? Agreed !
 
I don't know why people are getting their knickers in a twist for a nothing game, next Saturday is the one that matters .
 
Their proffesionals mate their paid to do a job and they didn't do their job very well did they. Stop putting a spin on it our Manager certainly didn't in his post match interview after the game. Hopefully they will man up this coming Saturday and all start winning their individual battles cause not one of them won them on Saturday
 
Stop fretting we will be at wembley on the 25th lifting that trophy.

Love the blind optimsm based on absolutely nothing. But I dearly hope you're right. Sadly in my 30+ years supporting the whites, I've come to expect nothing from them except eternal disappointment, so see no reason for things to different this time around. Compounded by our totally shite display yesterday. Rotherham look to have a bit more bollocks than we do, and more up for the fight.

Don't think our cautious approach will win us the prize, and the fact we've forgotten how to defend doesn't help. Very happy to be proved wrong though, obviously.
 
Gods got bugger all to do with us being in the playoff places or Crewe being cannon fodder...... Ability and effort.. No excuse for yesterdays " whimper " of a finale..... I hope it's out of our system now.

Agree with every word. What a daft comment "we haven't got a god given right to win". It's a sport not a life and death/religious/political debate.
 
My main concern is we are too nice. Away from home, Holmes and Gallagher are ineffective, great when we are tonking crap teams at Deepdale but not prepared to put it in away from home when it's tough. Holmes in particular is disappointing in attitude and I wouldn't keep him next season regardless of division we are in.

There is no big leader in the team to drag the lads through the game when we aren't playing well. No Gregan or Lucketti. Hopefully it won't stop us going up but again, whichever division we are in, it needs addressing next season and probably why Peter Clarke is Deepdale bound.

There is something in this, and, unfortunately Rotherham are a bunch of bad boys led by an mad tomato ( as Jamie Hoyland called him at the home game).
 
This is my team for Saturday.

RUDD

CLARKE
KING
WRIGHT
LAIRD OR BUCHANNAN

HUMPHREY
WELSH
BROWNE
GALLACHER

CRAIG DAVIES
GARNER

KEANE
HOLMES
K DAVIES
BEAVON
STUCK
KILKENNY
BROWNHILL.

I think Wiseman is unfit at the moment ( well he looked unfit on Sat )
 
I think Brownhill has to play and is being held back as a 'secret' weapon. He is on a different plane to the rest of the squad (except Gally in a home game) and could be the difference.
 
I think Brownhill has to play and is being held back as a 'secret' weapon. He is on a different plane to the rest of the squad (except Gally in a home game) and could be the difference.

IMO you play your strongest available side for who'll raise to the occasion and if it doesn't work then you switch it before it's too late. I'd like to see Brownhill get a start but realistically the only way he'll play on Saturday is if Grayson starts only 1 up front or plays 3 in midfield with the wing-backs system. Neither formations would go down well with the fans, many of whom will have been saving up a year's worth of whinging by staying away from Deepdale all season. It's a bit of a strange one that as the attendances have declined then so has the amount of negativity inside the ground on matchday when things don't go all our own way.
 
It is a difficult thing to work out. Can a team relax one game and turn it on the next? If it can then great, but my confidence in the team has gone down a notch or two.

The way I look at it is a professional outfit that wants promotion doesn't give a fig if it relegates another team in its bid to get a home leg in the play-offs. A team that deserves promotion finds a way to win even when the other side have more to lose.

PNE are generally good away from home and a home leg to start might not be such a bad thing. Our fans are used to play-off failure so home legs don't seem to have as much oomph as they could.
 
Back
Top