Skip to main content

5 points

5 points

Joined
Jan 6, 2011
Messages
2,032
We've now lost 5 points due to referees poor penalty decisions alone.
3 points against Newcastle and 2 today. Those five points would see us level with Sheff Weds and in a play off position-ish.
Promotion from this division is worth multi-millions of pounds. Why oh why is the refereeing so inept?

Nice One.
 
I'm just on about decisions alone mate. Not how we've played (I agree with you on that). In an industry with so much money sloshing about. Things like today's penalty decision shouldn't come into it.

Nice One.
 
We've now lost 5 points due to referees poor penalty decisions alone.
3 points against Newcastle and 2 today. Those five points would see us level with Sheff Weds and in a play off position-ish.
Promotion from this division is worth multi-millions of pounds. Why oh why is the refereeing so inept?

Nice One.

All swings and roundabouts.... doesn't make the shit refereeing right but all teams will attribute points lost and gained from the ref.

Nice One
 
Fulham as well when Beckford scored should never have been disallowed for offside. But like today it would have been daylight robbery if we got anything from that game. Newcastle on the other hand we deserved the 3 points never mind 1.
 
Bloody ell that's going back a long time to find a decision that went for us! League One we were the big boys and got more decisions, now we're a small fish in a big pond.

Just pointing out one that springs mind but I sure our players have pulled a few shirts etc and not conceded Penalties. yes, poor refereeing but I do believe over time it balances out
 
I honestly believe the "balances itself out" thing to be a massive cliche. I'd like to see a study done by Harvard or Cambridge.

Nice One.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
What made his decision to give the penalty even worse was that he discussed it with the linesman who I'm sure told him it was a clean tackle.
He then played the big man and totally disregarded that advice, purely IMO because he didn't want lose face and admit he got it wrong.
Why even have assistants if the ref is going to ignore them?
Even the Villa players hardly made any appeal.
 
Not even close to a foul. As textbook a tackle as you'll see.

Nice One.


0e6819066c0bc377bc0ca1bc31b96c42.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
The linesman clearly agreed it was a good tackle. I was stood behind him in line with the incident. From what I could see he told three north end players that he agreed the ball was won. The ref talked to him and reconfirmed the penalty which was mystifying. As pne4ever says none of the villa players appealed.
 
We didn't deserve to win today. Never a penalty but should've been at least 2-0 down at half time anyway.
Oh well then if you think we should have been 2-0 down anyway no point bothering about refs decisions then we move on.
 
Oh well then if you think we should have been 2-0 down anyway no point bothering about refs decisions then we move on.

What I'm saying is, the decision didn't really cost us any points today.

Refs have certainly cost us in other games though. Newcastle and Fulham spring to mind.
 
What I'm saying is, the decision didn't really cost us any points today.

Refs have certainly cost us in other games though. Newcastle and Fulham spring to mind.

Most people would say it definitely did cost us two points. Basic mathematics.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Yes, we've had some shit decisions but we're still up there with a chance of the playoffs.

It's great to be looking up and I'm feeling more positive about North End right now than I have since the day the poisoned dwarf fucked up our play off final against the spam. Even after that fantastic Wembley day in May 2014, I didn't believe life in the championship would be anything other than a struggle.

Imagine how you'd feel if you were a Brizzle fan complaining about a refs decision costing you your 8th defeat on the bounce!
 
Usually evens itself out over the course of a full season.

What a ridiculous saying that is, there's not the remotest chance that will happen. As Joey says above you have to think hard to find a dubious decision which went in our favour this season whereas we can easily think of many which gave gone against us
 
Usually evens itself out over the course of a full season.
What a ridiculous saying that is, there's not the remotest chance that will happen. As Joey says above you have to think hard to find a dubious decision which went in our favour this season whereas we can easily think of many which gave gone against us
I also don't buy the "it evens itself out over the season" argument.

These dubious decisions almost always favour the bigger team. So how will these things even themselves out for the likes of Newcastle - or even Aston Villa?

The fact is, over a full season, they will benefit from these decisions far more than they will suffer from them - whereas for a smaller team like us, it's exactly the opposite case.
 
Back
Top