Skip to main content

An Honest question

An Honest question

Poll Poll An Honest question

  • FA Cup Final

    Votes: 100 51.8%
  • Promotion

    Votes: 93 48.2%

  • Total voters
    193
For promotion it's 4 mil in tv handouts and increased gate and advertising revinue... If we stayed in the Championship then that is on a yearly basis and regular............ How much for ( a one season only)... few low key European games?

PS.... A lot of local derbys and big gates in the Championship

TV money, gate reciepts and prize funds far outstrip the 4 million.

There would presumably be money associated with those low key Euro games.

Get to the Championship and stuggle, particularly in those derby games (we only got a big crowd against Blackpool because it was cheap) and suddenly we have alienated another group of potential supporters.

Get to the cup final and return to winning in league one the next season and it is completely possible one or two might carry on watching us.

And who is to say we would not get promotion the following season anyway 🙂
 
TV money, gate reciepts and prize funds far outstrip the 4 million.

There would presumably be money associated with those low key Euro games.

Get to the Championship and stuggle, particularly in those derby games (we only got a big crowd against Blackpool because it was cheap) and suddenly we have alienated another group of potential supporters.

Get to the cup final and return to winning in league one the next season and it is completely possible one or two might carry on watching us.

And who is to say we would not get promotion the following season anyway 🙂


Still can't understand how one good day out can possibly compete with a good " season " out... And don't forget we'd have a 50/50 chance of losing the final !! No thanks, I'll stck with promotion and then do the Cup "double" the year after..... And it won't do Europe any harm to wait another 12 months for PNE either.We're worth it. 🙂
 
Still can't understand how one good day out can possibly compete with a good " season " out... And don't forget we'd have a 50/50 chance of losing the final !! No thanks, I'll stck with promotion and then do the Cup "double" the year after..... And it won't do Europe any harm to wait another 12 months for PNE either.We're worth it. 🙂

One word, win or not in the FA Cup final Lib - GLORY!
 
I only see the FA Cup run as something that provides extra revenue to help PNE get promotion. We had a decent cup run 1999/2000 when we won promotion. Promotion, which takes 46 matches, takes pride of place for me. Can't see the point of winning the FA Cup but having to play Crawley away on a wet Tuesday in February next season. So in order of preference:
a) Win promotion and win the FA Cup;
b) Win promotion and have a decent FA Cup run;
c) Win promotion but Forest beat us at Deepdale next Wednesday;
d) Win the FA Cup but miss out on promotion;
e) Have a decent FA Cup run but miss out on promotion;
f) Have Forest beat us at Deepdale next Wednesday and miss out on promotion.
 
If losing is " glorious " then tell me how you felt after the three playoff losses... Don't understand how losing in an FA Cup final would be/feel any different.

There's much less as stake. Indeed, we could lose and still get into Europe.

Playing West Ham was a mega million winner takes all. I will never feel as gutted at a football match again.
 
Doubt it my friend....

I don't - the rewards from a cup final would be huge. 90,000 at an average of £50 would gross £4.5 million, I've no idea how that is split but I presume we'd get at least £1.5 million. The semi final receipts are substantial, each club get around 16% of the total receipts from the two games, so lets say another million. Prize money for losing the final (including winning other rounds yet to come) would be around £2.5 million, you've got all the TV money and loads of other incidentals - a conservative estimate would be £5 million just from the cup.

However, it's not going to happen!
 
Once in 13 years ? Twice if you include not turning up against W Ham. 🙂

Now you are being shall we say 'economic' with the truth. Without checking, didn't we make four play offs in about nine seasons...........never mind 'once in 13 years'. If you are in the play offs, surely that qualifies as an 'opportunity to get promoted'.

Come to think of it, if you count the previous season in the 3rd tier, that would make it 5 seasons out of 10 that qualify as 'an opportunity to get promoted'.

50% either getting promoted or having an opportunity to get promoted over a decade is a pretty good percentage as against one cup final in the last 50 years.
 
Last edited:
If losing is " glorious " then tell me how you felt after the three playoff losses... Don't understand how losing in an FA Cup final would be/feel any different.

Losing in a play off final isn't glorious. Just getting to the FA Cup final for a club like ours would give the club a huge spotlight and yes would be GLORY even if we lost. 😀
 
If losing is " glorious " then tell me how you felt after the three playoff losses... Don't understand how losing in an FA Cup final would be/feel any different.

Reaching the FA Cup Final would be a huge achievement in itself for a club like ours. Obviously we'd want to win it once we got there, but it's not the be all and end all. The world would watch the game, with the vast majority rooting for our club. If we lose, the history books would still show we were finalists. The Club's roll of honour will show "FA Cup Runners Up" The players would receive a medal that they'd cherish until the day they die. Supporters would tell their grandchildren about the day PNE played in the FA Cup Final at Wembley.

Lose a Play Off Final and you get fvck all. The only thing I can imagine that is comparable to losing a Play Off Final is losing an FA Cup Semi Final. But even then, I'm sure losing an FA Cup Semi Final would hurt more.
 
Now you are being shall we say 'economic' with the truth. Without checking, didn't we make four play offs in about nine seasons...........never mind 'once in 13 years'. If you are in the play offs, surely that qualifies as an 'opportunity to get promoted'.

Come to think of it, if you count the previous season in the 3rd tier, that would make it 5 seasons out of 10 that qualify as 'an opportunity to get promoted'.

50% either getting promoted or having an opportunity to get promoted over a decade is a pretty good percentage as against one cup final in the last 50 years.

.. Yes, we've had a number of opportunities , probably more than most but we are very, very good at squandering them aren't we ? And it remains the case that we've only capitalised the once in 13 years ( ish ) so with that conversion rate, future " opportunities " are hardly anything to get excited about imho.
 
Anyway...... If we take the FA Cup " appearance " over " promotion " as the poll suggests we democratically should do.... Who do we play in the Final ? 🙂
 
Back
Top