Rejected a new deal at Walsall. Good player when I have seen him and has skippered them for the last few years. Could be a useful option at CB as the leader and experienced CB we need according to a few on here. Thoughts?🙂
Andy Butler
OP
The Target Man
Thread starter
One of the best in this division, won't get many better frees than Butler.
I agree, seems a good no nonsense defender and worth a punt for free on what may presumably be cheap wages coming from Walsall.
Rejected a new deal at Walsall. Good player when I have seen him and has skippered them for the last few years. Could be a useful option at CB as the leader and experienced CB we need according to a few on here. Thoughts?🙂
Big and strong lad and very good at this level. Only question is,...is he better than what we have already?
Maybe we should go for Edgy's Butler?
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/21938914
Could be something on the cards - is that "Ashton" inked on his right arm?!
Could be something on the cards - is that "Ashton" inked on his right arm?!
- Joined
- Aug 5, 2009
- Messages
- 1,150
Big and strong lad and very good at this level. Only question is,...is he better than what we have already?
King and Wright? Without doubt he is.
- Joined
- Jun 28, 2004
- Messages
- 6,057
I'd be delighted with him. He'd instantly be the best CB at the club. No frills but a good defender.
undoubtedly a good player at this level and i'm sure he's smart enough to know that by rejecting Wallsall's contract offer he'll be in demand from teams more likely than Wallsall to be challenging for promotion. that being the case i think if we're to sign him its best to test the water by putting an offer on the table asap and see if he accepts or if he's holding out for a club like Sheff Utd, Peterborough, Bristol City, etc who'd be able to offer bigger wages.
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2004
- Messages
- 19,671
Big and strong lad and very good at this level. Only question is,...is he better than what we have already?
I'm better than King at CB so I imagine this guy is as well!!
When we played Walsall when Westley had just taken over (predictably it was 0-0) Butler stood out that day and I said he'd be just the sort of player Westley would go for.
Personally though if we signed another centre half (probably the one area we don't need to strengthen) then I'd rather we went for a promising youngster from League One or Two who's already played +100 games and could have some sell-on value in 2-3 years.
Personally though if we signed another centre half (probably the one area we don't need to strengthen) then I'd rather we went for a promising youngster from League One or Two who's already played +100 games and could have some sell-on value in 2-3 years.
coming up 31 and only 43 games at Championship level.....most of them at Scunthorpe...not for me thanks
Maybe we should go for Edgy's Butler?
You may be able to afford him but the club wouldn't !
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2004
- Messages
- 13,345
Never heard of him.
Next.
You don't seem to have heard of many of the players mentioned as possible targets. I don't know why you think we might be interested in your ignorance.
I agree with the others that he might be worth considering despite the fact that he is 30.
You may be able to afford him but the club wouldn't !
I trust he still irons 'The Times' in the morning
OP
The Target Man
Thread starter
coming up 31 and only 43 games at Championship level.....most of them at Scunthorpe...not for me thanks
We are a league one club in case you haven't noticed. Nugent hadn't played a single game above League Two level until we signed him and look at what happened then. He may be 30 but that means he would still have at least four or five years at this level in him for sure. I'm sure we wouldn't offer him that long anyway.
OP
The Target Man
Thread starter
Never heard of him.
Next.
For a massive Preston fan like you it doesn't appear you know much about the level we play at. You must think we play at Old Trafford or something.