Skip to main content

Automatic Promotion

Automatic Promotion

Alexander
Edwards
Kidd
Jackson
Parkinson
Anderson
Appleton
Cartwright
Eyres
Gregan
McKenna
Rankine
Basham
Macken
Mathie
Angel


They didn't all play in the same team at the same time obviously but they ( imho) are all better than what we have now. And they were good enough to go up and be one game away from the Prem !!

PS... I've left out the players that I think were inferior to what we have now.

ALL those players are better than ALL of our players now? Absolute horse-shit. And Edwards only signed in the championship, didn't he?

You're telling me Basham, Mathie & Angell are better than Davies, Hume & Beavon?

Can't believe I forgot Kidd, Parky, Cartwright, Anderson & Appleton, and yes they'd all get in today's side, but you make it sound like they're all a bunch of carthorses. Unfortunately I was going off top my head, I didn't have the posters in front of me.

If we had a "Macken" or a "Gregan" in our ranks now, we'd be flying. It's always difficult comparing different eras and some like to look at the past in their rose-tinted specs.

Rankine was a good partner for Gregan, but he was lucky to play alongside him. Welsh & Keane could do his steady Eddie job unspectacular job just as well IMHO.

At least we agreed on the 'keepers, I think!?
 
Of course what happens now is the only thing that's important but I do think that a comparison between this squad and the last one that won it is interesting.... If not particularly relevant.

Well in with the stats everyone. The next 10 games harvested 26 points. Come on Simon!
 
Small steps. You don't go from being rubbish to brilliant overnight. We have to be patient and I think play offs this season would be brilliant (good chance of being successful as well given our manager's history and the experience we have in the squad).

Let's not forget, when Moyes took over, his first full season at this level was play offs only. We have no right to expect us to walk automatic. Logic dictates that Wolves (with a proper champ line up) and Posh (who were unlucky to go down with the points total they got in the champ) should claim the top 2 without much problem.
 
Would any of our team now get in the first XI then

Both our current keepers would get the nod, as would both our left backs. Grezza would be at right-back, of course. Jackson is the only Centre back I would consider over our current bunch. Gregan pips Keane but I don't think there's really much in it.

I loved Rankine and Cartwright but if we're basing this soley on talent then neither would get in the side.

Harris, Byfield, Basham, Angell and Mathie would all probably play second fiddle to Beavon, Hume and Davies. Only Macken and Nogan would have a chance and you have to remember Macken had not become the player we remember him as at this point and Nogan was on his way out.
 
ALL those players are better than ALL of our players now? Absolute horse-shit. And Edwards only signed in the championship, didn't he?

You're telling me Basham, Mathie & Angell are better than Davies, Hume & Beavon?

Can't believe I forgot Kidd, Parky, Cartwright, Anderson & Appleton, and yes they'd all get in today's side, but you make it sound like they're all a bunch of carthorses. Unfortunately I was going off top my head, I didn't have the posters in front of me.

If we had a "Macken" or a "Gregan" in our ranks now, we'd be flying. It's always difficult comparing different eras and some like to look at the past in their rose-tinted specs.

Rankine was a good partner for Gregan, but he was lucky to play alongside him. Welsh & Keane could do his steady Eddie job unspectacular job just as well IMHO.

At least we agreed on the 'keepers, I think!?



Horse shit or not.......... If you are correct then we will get within a whisker of the Prem with our current squad... If not...I'll remind you later !! 🙂


And you're wrong about Edwards..... 1999/2000
 
Well if I picked the best of both it would be:

GK. Rudd
RB. Alexander
CB. Jackson
CB. Wright (or Kidd)
LB. Laird (or Kidd)
RW. Anderson
CM. Gregan
CM. McKenna
LW. Eyres
ST. Davies
ST. Macken

I know a couple of them ie. McKenna and Macken may be based on a few years later but Rankine would get the nod over Keane or Welsh anyway. I'd like Kidd in there but Wright and Laird are good players.

Manager - Moyes
 
Both our current keepers would get the nod, as would both our left backs. Grezza would be at right-back, of course. Jackson is the only Centre back I would consider over our current bunch. Gregan pips Keane but I don't think there's really much in it.

I loved Rankine and Cartwright but if we're basing this soley on talent then neither would get in the side.

Harris, Byfield, Basham, Angell and Mathie would all probably play second fiddle to Beavon, Hume and Davies. Only Macken and Nogan would have a chance and you have to remember Macken had not become the player we remember him as at this point and Nogan was on his way out.

Keeper and left back opinion I'll give you but..........."Gregan pips Keane but I don't think there's really much in it."........As much as I rate Keane.. You must be tripping ! 🙂.Rankine was a 100% box to boxer which is something that we have nothing like right now...Angel never missed anything inside the 18 yard box ( which forced us over that finishing line ) so with the utmost respect....Put that thinking cap on PW .. And please remember that the majority of those that I listed nearly got us to the prem. 🙂
 
Well if I picked the best of both it would be:

GK. Rudd
RB. Alexander
CB. Jackson
CB. Wright (or Kidd)
LB. Laird (or Kidd)
RW. Anderson
CM. Gregan
CM. McKenna
LW. Eyres
ST. Davies
ST. Macken

I know a couple of them ie. McKenna and Macken may be based on a few years later but Rankine would get the nod over Keane or Welsh anyway. I'd like Kidd in there but Wright and Laird are good players.

Manager - Moyes

Good side but you can't leave out Rankine who kept McKenna out of the middle for a long time....... and who's that " ( or Kidd ) " bloke ? One of my all time heroes..How dare you leave him out ? 🙂... You know your footy.. I wonder why you get so much stick on here ?..... No offense meant ! 🙂
 
Horse shit or not.......... If you are correct then we will get within a whisker of the Prem with our current squad... If not...I'll remind you later !! 🙂


And you're wrong about Edwards..... 1999/2000

Well let's hope it's me reminding you then eh? Then we'll all be happy!

I'm not saying this squad doesn't have it's limitations, and we're still a couple players short IMO, if we want promotion. I was just sticking up for our current team, as they're the ones who matter right now, and I thought you were a bit harsh saying how the 99/00 team were streets ahead.

They might edge it pound for pound, but I don't think there's an awful lot in it. Some of the fringe players back then were pretty poor, your Harrises, Bjarkis of this world for example. Think our strength in depth is better now, but there's not as many stand out players, most of the guys are at a similar level.

Like I said earlier, stick an in his prime Gregan & Macken in there and we'd be a right force in this league, but this ain't fantasy football & comparing eras is an impossible task, as no-one can say who's right and who's wrong.

So we make do with what we have and see where that takes us, unless Trevor starts feeling generous and brings in another couple of quality signings to get us out of this bloody league!?
 
Good side but you can't leave out Rankine who kept McKenna out of the middle for a long time....... and who's that " ( or Kidd ) " bloke ? One of my all time heroes..How dare you leave him out ? 🙂... You know your footy.. I wonder why you get so much stick on here ?..... No offense meant ! 🙂

I know I know I think Kidd would be ahead of Wright or Laird and also one of my favourites. I'd probably put him ahead of Laird. And yes Shabba but then again McKenna is one of my favourites but he came through one in the Championship.

It's not really my footy I get stick for mate but thanks.
 
Automatic Promotion

Well let's hope it's me reminding you then eh? Then we'll all be happy!

I'm not saying this squad doesn't have it's limitations, and we're still a couple players short IMO, if we want promotion. I was just sticking up for our current team, as they're the ones who matter right now, and I thought you were a bit harsh saying how the 99/00 team were streets ahead.

They might edge it pound for pound, but I don't think there's an awful lot in it. Some of the fringe players back then were pretty poor, your Harrises, Bjarkis of this world for example. Think our strength in depth is better now, but there's not as many stand out players, most of the guys are at a similar level.

Like I said earlier, stick an in his prime Gregan & Macken in there and we'd be a right force in this league, but this ain't fantasy football & comparing eras is an impossible task, as no-one can say who's right and who's wrong.

So we make do with what we have and see where that takes us, unless Trevor starts feeling generous and brings in another couple of quality signings to get us out of this bloody league!?

Top 2 side mate if added McKenna, Gregan and Ranks to our midfield instead of Moose, Keane and Byrom
 
Well let's hope it's me reminding you then eh? Then we'll all be happy!

I'm not saying this squad doesn't have it's limitations, and we're still a couple players short IMO, if we want promotion. I was just sticking up for our current team, as they're the ones who matter right now, and I thought you were a bit harsh saying how the 99/00 team were streets ahead.

They might edge it pound for pound, but I don't think there's an awful lot in it. Some of the fringe players back then were pretty poor, your Harrises, Bjarkis of this world for example. Think our strength in depth is better now, but there's not as many stand out players, most of the guys are at a similar level.

Like I said earlier, stick an in his prime Gregan & Macken in there and we'd be a right force in this league, but this ain't fantasy football & comparing eras is an impossible task, as no-one can say who's right and who's wrong.

So we make do with what we have and see where that takes us, unless Trevor starts feeling generous and brings in another couple of quality signings to get us out of this bloody league!?

Theres nothing wrong with our current squad and having " a pop " at them wasn't my intention... Just an interesting caparison with no agenda...........And yes.... You can remind me all day long if you are proven to be correct ! I'll be as happy as a pig in sh%%%%. 🙂
 
I know I know I think Kidd would be ahead of Wright or Laird and also one of my favourites. I'd probably put him ahead of Laird. And yes Shabba but then again McKenna is one of my favourites but he came through one in the Championship.

It's not really my footy I get stick for mate but thanks.

Welcome.... And for the record I'd slot Kidd in ANYWHERE in our current back 4 and not worry about it being weakened !
 
Welcome.... And for the record I'd slot Kidd in ANYWHERE in our current back 4 and not worry about it being weakened !

I can't remember against who and what season but that season he typified his grit when he got sent off and then came running back down the tunnel to get involved with a pitch brawl..... Top lad
 
What game was it that Beck (I think ) played Kidd on the left wing but Subbed him quite quickly due to not having a good game ? ( I can't remember the game)
 
What game was it that Beck (I think ) played Kidd on the left wing but Subbed him quite quickly due to not having a good game ? ( I can't remember the game)

Wasn't that at Burnley? And the game when he came running back on was Carlisle at home - 1996?
 
Back
Top