Alexander
Edwards
Kidd
Jackson
Parkinson
Anderson
Appleton
Cartwright
Eyres
Gregan
McKenna
Rankine
Basham
Macken
Mathie
Angel
They didn't all play in the same team at the same time obviously but they ( imho) are all better than what we have now. And they were good enough to go up and be one game away from the Prem !!
PS... I've left out the players that I think were inferior to what we have now.
ALL those players are better than ALL of our players now? Absolute horse-shit. And Edwards only signed in the championship, didn't he?
You're telling me Basham, Mathie & Angell are better than Davies, Hume & Beavon?
Can't believe I forgot Kidd, Parky, Cartwright, Anderson & Appleton, and yes they'd all get in today's side, but you make it sound like they're all a bunch of carthorses. Unfortunately I was going off top my head, I didn't have the posters in front of me.
If we had a "Macken" or a "Gregan" in our ranks now, we'd be flying. It's always difficult comparing different eras and some like to look at the past in their rose-tinted specs.
Rankine was a good partner for Gregan, but he was lucky to play alongside him. Welsh & Keane could do his steady Eddie job unspectacular job just as well IMHO.
At least we agreed on the 'keepers, I think!?