Skip to main content

Best 3 Managers

Best 3 Managers

Joined
Oct 8, 2004
Messages
27,265
Location
Deepdale
With all the talk of Simon Grayson being axed (or not) I thought about all the managers that have come and gone. I would say my top three managers over the years are as follows:-

1. David Moyes. The only Manager who has won anything for the club in recent years, League 1 title.

2. Simon Grayson. The Manager that gave us the best day at Wembley since 1938. My gratitude for that day will be with me forever.

3. Craig Brown. The Manager who brought the best footballers I have seen at Deepdale and that gave Billy Davies the team that provided the most exciting time of our Championship era. Love or hate Billy Davies whilst he was here we were buzzing.

Who are your best three and why?
 
Moyes - fairly obvious choice

Billy Davies - although we failed in the play-offs under him, we were a great team at the time in the Championship. How many games did we go unbeaten ? We had some great moments like 2-0 away at Burnley with the Nugent volley, 0-0 away at Pride Park in the play-off second leg. Memorable moments. Also he was the man who signed Nugent.

Grayson - although I'm having doubts about him now at this level, as you say, I will always be grateful for that day at Wembley regardless of what the future holds for him at this club.
 
Moyes
Billy
Grayson



Brown would have made a better football director as could pick a player but seemed to have no motivational skills.

Irvine would have made a better coach. Good coach but wasn't great tactically or in he transfer market....
 
I know only two responses but 3 of us have named Simon Grayson in top 3, and people are talking of wanting him sacked, really?
 
Sadly, it's a lot easier to name the best 3 managers than the worst 3. I'd go with Moyes, Grayson and Brown like Joan. My utter loathing of BD prevents me from listing him, despite his success.
 
1) Moyes - for obvious reason.

2)Billy Davies - assembled and presided over the most successful Preston team in the past 40 years. We were an absolute force in the Championship back then, It's baffling we failed to make the Premiership between 2004-07. It makes our spectacular fall from grace since then even more disappointing.

3) Gary Peters - got the 'BAXI revolution' ball rolling. Won the league in '96. Played some good football as well for what was the equivalent of League 2/1. Knew when to step aside and allow Moyes his chance as well.
 
Best 3 Managers

I know only two responses but 3 of us have named Simon Grayson in top 3, and people are talking of wanting him sacked, really?

I've named him and wouldn't mind if he was sacked. I am not going to go in to the whole sacking debate as there are threads on that but I am worried we will get relegated if he doesn't turn things round straight away....

Yet for his promotion last season he is in my top 3 but miles away from Moyes and Davies
 
Moyes
Billy
Grayson



Brown would have made a better football director as could pick a player but seemed to have no motivational skills.

Irvine would have made a better coach. Good coach but wasn't great tactically or in he transfer market....

Argh - don't get me started on Broon.

How hard could it have been to spot Fuller at Hearts? He must have stuck out like a sore thumb amongst all that shite.

He had a win percentage that was worse than Les Chapman. I could go on, but I shouldn't have to.
 
Argh - don't get me started on Broon.

How hard could it have been to spot Fuller at Hearts? He must have stuck out like a sore thumb amongst all that shite.

He had a win percentage that was worse than Les Chapman. I could go on, but I shouldn't have to.

It wasn't just Fuller mate it was some of the best players I've seen in my time at North End. He wasn't in my top 3 and nowhere near. As I said he was a good ambassador and his scouting network was obviously very strong but wasn't good enough as a manager
 
1) Moyes - for obvious reason.

2)Billy Davies - assembled and presided over the most successful Preston team in the past 40 years. We were an absolute force in the Championship back then, It's baffling we failed to make the Premiership between 2004-07. It makes our spectacular fall from grace since then even more disappointing.

3) Gary Peters - got the 'BAXI revolution' ball rolling. Won the league in '96. Played some good football as well for what was the equivalent of League 2/1. Knew when to step aside and allow Moyes his chance as well.

This'un, for me.
 
I saw 10 defeats on the spin under Broon - the memory of that capitulation at Derby still haunts me to this day.

Our 4 outfield subs were David Elebert, Kyle Armstrong, Mark Jackson and Simon Lynch - I'm really not sure the old charlatan couls spot a player you know!
 
Peters........ Good eye for a player and he dragged us back up towards where we belong

Moyes......... Took over from Peters and improved us with many of Peters players


John Mcgrath.... Did it with feck all !
 
I saw 10 defeats on the spin under Broon - the memory of that capitulation at Derby still haunts me to this day.

Our 4 outfield subs were David Elebert, Kyle Armstrong, Mark Jackson and Simon Lynch - I'm really not sure the old charlatan couls spot a player you know!

I only actually remember Lynch....

Did he sign Etuhu, Mawene, Davies, Mears, O'Neill along with Fuller?
 
1.David Moyes

2.Wee William Davies

3.Nobby Stiles.

With honourable mentions to John McGrath and Gary Peters.
 
Peters........ Good eye for a player and he dragged us back up towards where we belong

Moyes......... Took over from Peters and improved us with many of Peters players


John Mcgrath.... Did it with feck all !

The achievements of McGrath far outweigh those of most others for me. From our position the season before to do what he did from the proceeds of selling Nigel Greenwood for (I think) £15,000 beggars belief. The feel good factor that season was bigger than at any time since for me.

David Moyes, more so for the play off final season than the promotion season. The reason I say that is for way he managed and improved essentially the same players moving up a division, with a tweak here and there. We really punched above our weight that season.

Third, Gary Peters just ahead of Stiles. Probably to do with the way he moved us on from the depths of Beck, his passion and the way he knew when he wasn't going to take us further and stepped aside. Also continued working at the club afterwards, absolutely no ego with the man.
 
Back
Top