Skip to main content

Best 3 Managers

Best 3 Managers

Peters........ Good eye for a player and he dragged us back up towards where we belong

Moyes......... Took over from Peters and improved us with many of Peters players


John Mcgrath.... Did it with feck all !

Fully agree on all 3 counts...
 
With all the talk of Simon Grayson being axed (or not) I thought about all the managers that have come and gone. I would say my top three managers over the years are as follows:-

1. David Moyes. The only Manager who has won anything for the club in recent years, League 1 title.

2. Simon Grayson. The Manager that gave us the best day at Wembley since 1938. My gratitude for that day will be with me forever.

3. Craig Brown. The Manager who brought the best footballers I have seen at Deepdale and that gave Billy Davies the team that provided the most exciting time of our Championship era. Love or hate Billy Davies whilst he was here we were buzzing.

Who are your best three and why?
1. David Moyes - same reason.
2. Simon Grayson - same reason.
3. Gary Peters - the only other manager who has won anything for the club in recent years, the "League 2" title.
 
You are obviously too young to remember Tommy Docherty in 1978 ish

The worst manager North End have ever had...........

To be fair he wasn't here long enough to build any kind of win percentage! Remember him saying he'd get us playing in Europe within 5 years!!

Moyes
McGrath
Poisoned Dwarf
 
Best
1. Big John Magrath
2. David Moyes
3= Gary Peters & Simon grayson

Worst
1. Alan Irvine (TH backed the wrong horse I think...)
2. Les Chapman - so apathetic after Magraths reign
3. Brian Kidd
 
Jimmy Milne in the sixties created the best north end team I have seen. Signing Alex Dawson and Nobby Lawton from united. Kelly, Ross, Smith, Lawton,Singleton, Kendall, Wilson, Ashworth, Dawson, Spavin, Holden. FA Cup Final 1964 3rd in the old first division. In my time he stands alone as the best.
 
Jimmy Milne in the sixties created the best north end team I have seen. Signing Alex Dawson and Nobby Lawton from united. Kelly, Ross, Smith, Lawton,Singleton, Kendall, Wilson, Ashworth, Dawson, Spavin, Holden. FA Cup Final 1964 3rd in the old first division. In my time he stands alone as the best.

He also presided over the memorable cup run in 1966 when we beat Tottenham and were unlucky not to beat Manchester United in the 6th round. On the debit side though we were unable to maintain the momentum we had in the League in 1964 and never really got close to promotion in the years after that.
 
McGrath - didn't just turn a re-election side into promotion winners in one season whilst not having a pot to piss in, the then build a second quality side with 18 months with the likes of Mooney, Ellis, Patterson, Joyce and Bogie, all costing next to nowt. It took a decade and a board that backed their manager to the tune of several record signings before got a side better than that one

Moyes - was the one that finally lead us from the darkness to the brink of the top flight.

Poison Dwarf - would have been too had he not got it wrong when it mattered the most. Twice.

Best scout - Pa Broon

Best commercial manager - Beck

Best bloke - Peters
 
McGrath - didn't just turn a re-election side into promotion winners in one season whilst not having a pot to piss in, the then build a second quality side with 18 months with the likes of Mooney, Ellis, Patterson, Joyce and Bogie, all costing next to nowt. It took a decade and a board that backed their manager to the tune of several record signings before got a side better than that one

Moyes - was the one that finally lead us from the darkness to the brink of the top flight.

Poison Dwarf - would have been too had he not got it wrong when it mattered the most. Twice.

Best scout - Pa Broon

Best commercial manager - Beck

Best bloke - Peters

Is it because the likes of Andy Smith and Marlon Broomes were so catastrophically shit, that the decent signings Broon made seem to cloud the judgment so?

He got some right and most wrong like pretty much every manager we've ever had.

I'd suggest that the late, great John McGrath had the best eye for a player. He assembled a squad out of nothing for nothing that won promotion, picked up Swanny for 10 grand and brought in the likes of Mooney and Ellis from obscurity.

All Brown's decent signings were either very well known or, indeed, internationals!
 
Is it because the likes of Andy Smith and Marlon Broomes were so catastrophically shit, that the decent signings Broon made seem to cloud the judgment so?

He got some right and most wrong like pretty much every manager we've ever had.

I'd suggest that the late, great John McGrath had the best eye for a player. He assembled a squad out of nothing for nothing that won promotion, picked up Swanny for 10 grand and brought in the likes of Mooney and Ellis from obscurity.

All Brown's decent signings were either very well known or, indeed, internationals!

Derek Shaw's decision to replace McGrath with Beck was not only a football crime, but a crime against humanity itself.


And I should know.
 
Derek Shaw's decision to replace McGrath with Beck was not only a football crime, but a crime against humanity itself.


And I should know.

He didn't replace McGrath with Beck, so he's not guilty of that particular crime.
 
Jimmy Milne in the sixties created the best north end team I have seen. Signing Alex Dawson and Nobby Lawton from united. Kelly, Ross, Smith, Lawton,Singleton, Kendall, Wilson, Ashworth, Dawson, Spavin, Holden. FA Cup Final 1964 3rd in the old first division. In my time he stands alone as the best.

Hard to disagree with that. If we hadn't been pre-occupied with the Cup I'm sure we'd have gone up that season. A pity there were no Play-Offs in those days.
 
He didn't replace McGrath with Beck, so he's not guilty of that particular crime.

For signing Frank Worthington, Brian Mooney and Tony Ellis - McGrath deserved the freedom of Preston, instead he was sacked. It was criminal activity and should be investigated forthwith.
 
Back
Top