Skip to main content

Bizarre ....

Bizarre ....

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why a miscalculated starting line up? Why were we lethargic? Why were we lacking energy?

I do wish our manager would take some responsibility for our results. It is his responsibility (and the rest of the coaching staff) to select the right starting line up, tactics and formation. It's also the responsibility of the same individuals to make sure the players are fit and ready and that they play with the required desire, tempo and effort.

If the above was not true, then we wouldn't need managers or coaching staff and we could just send 11 players onto the pitch to just get on with it. But good and great managers are worth their weight in gold. Witness Simeone at Athletico Madrid, Conte at Chelsea, Klopp at Liverpool and others at different levels. You can not over emphasise the importance of having a good manager.

Now I'm not saying we should have any of these 'super' managers in charge at PNE, just using them as examples to illustrate the effect a different manager can have, even with the same group of players.

Yes the players also have a responsibility to do their best, but they need managing, motivating, inspiring, encouraging, filling with self belief so they play with little or no fear. That's the real difference.

I've witnessed Graysons football, tactics and philosophy since he arrived at the club. I can remember games even in league 1 that we should have won easily (Chesterfield and Rotherham at home) and debacles away (e.g. Rochdale). Weaknesses, patterns of play and frailties that were there then are still there, with a set of completely different players.

Hence the question that keeps resurfacing at that back of my mind, asking if we do indeed have the right manager in place to progress and take us further. I have always had my doubts and will continue to have them, whilst hoping to be proven wrong.

All managers have their flaws though, even those you have mentioned. Yes, over Grayson's tenure some of the football has been boring and dull to watch, but other times it has been a joy to watch. That is a pattern that most football clubs will follow.

Yes, Grayson is not tactically perfect and does make the odd strange/ wrong substitution, sometimes he takes too long to make a decision on the sidelines. Again, I'm sure all managers make the same kind of mistakes.

Grayson's record speaks for itself - we have improved every season that he has been here, on a small budget - going through very poor patches of form and very strong patches of form. He has built a young hungry side over that time, which has the odd bit of quality as well.

We have lost 3 of the last 16 league games (I think), we are the 8th top scorers in the division (despite not having the unrealistic mutli million pound scorer that we apparently need), and we are playing better football and creating quite a few chances. The process has been and will continue to be a fairly slow process with no success guaranteed overnight, but our manager is doing a damn good job, given all the circumstances.

I wouldn't be surprised if he was poached by a bigger club before he got sacked.
 
Why a miscalculated starting line up? Why were we lethargic? Why were we lacking energy?

I do wish our manager would take some responsibility for our results. It is his responsibility (and the rest of the coaching staff) to select the right starting line up, tactics and formation. It's also the responsibility of the same individuals to make sure the players are fit and ready and that they play with the required desire, tempo and effort.

If the above was not true, then we wouldn't need managers or coaching staff and we could just send 11 players onto the pitch to just get on with it. But good and great managers are worth their weight in gold. Witness Simeone at Athletico Madrid, Conte at Chelsea, Klopp at Liverpool and others at different levels. You can not over emphasise the importance of having a good manager.

Now I'm not saying we should have any of these 'super' managers in charge at PNE, just using them as examples to illustrate the effect a different manager can have, even with the same group of players.

Yes the players also have a responsibility to do their best, but they need managing, motivating, inspiring, encouraging, filling with self belief so they play with little or no fear. That's the real difference.

I've witnessed Graysons football, tactics and philosophy since he arrived at the club. I can remember games even in league 1 that we should have won easily (Chesterfield and Rotherham at home) and debacles away (e.g. Rochdale). Weaknesses, patterns of play and frailties that were there then are still there, with a set of completely different players.

Hence the question that keeps resurfacing at that back of my mind, asking if we do indeed have the right manager in place to progress and take us further. I have always had my doubts and will continue to have them, whilst hoping to be proven wrong.

As usual I think that there is a lot of over analysis going on. Every team has an off-day or runs up against an opponent playing with a lot of confidence and belief. The manager has to carry the can of course but we seem to be getting a huge over-reaction from some people when we lose a game (which to be fair hasn't happened that much recently). Obviously those with their own agenda against the manager will jump on these perceived tactical errors (easy with hindsight) but, given our financial constraints, which does make his (and his backroom team's) job a lot harder, his record over the past four years has been nothing short of excellent. For the first time since BD we have some stability and a strategy for development of the team, and it would be ridiculous in my view to put this at risk unless we have a disastrous second half of the season and end up being relegated.
 
Now I'm not saying we should have any of these 'super' managers in charge at PNE, just using them as examples to illustrate the effect a different manager can have, even with the same group of players.
How about you include some reference to the effect Di Matteo had at Villa, Pearson at Derby, Trollope at Cardiff, Stubbs at Rotherham, Wenga at Wolves, Caldwell at Wigan, Haissalbank at QPR. Or maybe examine why managers who have got clubs promoted from the Championship before (Owen Coyle, Ian Holloway and Nigel Adkins etc) have failed miserably at other clubs recently. Perhaps its because there is no magic formula to success. Or how Gary Rowett was unfairly booted out of Birmingham only for them to suffer back to back defeats under the 'super manager wanabee' Zola.

A manager is just one part of the overall jigsaw. And lets face it few managers are able to work with a bottom three budget and offer consistent long term success. But one thing we can learn from a lot of Championship clubs is that chopping and changing your manager if he doesnt offer a top 6 berth - is not the answer. Leeds have gone through 10 managers since Grayson left. All failed to beat Grayson's record there. At many clubs firing a manager is done to placate dumbass fans and keep the boos and spit from heading the boardrooms way. Thats the basic truth of the matter.

When Grayson leaves this football club he will walk into another job in the Championship. He has proven over and over again that he knows how to compete in this division.
 
How about you include some reference to the effect Di Matteo had at Villa, Pearson at Derby, Trollope at Cardiff, Stubbs at Rotherham, Wenga at Wolves, Caldwell at Wigan, Haissalbank at QPR. Or maybe examine why managers who have got clubs promoted from the Championship before (Owen Coyle, Ian Holloway and Nigel Adkins etc) have failed miserably at other clubs recently. Perhaps its because there is no magic formula to success. Or how Gary Rowett was unfairly booted out of Birmingham only for them to suffer back to back defeats under the 'super manager wanabee' Zola.

A manager is just one part of the overall jigsaw. And lets face it few managers are able to work with a bottom three budget and offer consistent long term success. But one thing we can learn from a lot of Championship clubs is that chopping and changing your manager if he doesnt offer a top 6 berth - is not the answer. Leeds have gone through 10 managers since Grayson left. All failed to beat Grayson's record there. At many clubs firing a manager is done to placate dumbass fans and keep the boos and spit from heading the boardrooms way. Thats the basic truth of the matter.

When Grayson leaves this football club he will walk into another job in the Championship. He has proven over and over again that he knows how to compete in this division.

I don't think I recall anyone saying any differently.... Including Marsbars.... 🙂
 
There's absolutely no point contemplating a change of manager without spelling out exactly who the new manager should be, so we can discuss their relative merits.

This isn't Brexit, where we just make a change for the sake of change without a clue what we do next. That's the policy adopted by many cash-rich clubs in this league, and it's great because it causes them to piss money away needlessly on futile staff turnover every 6 or 12 months - helping us to compete with them, because every pound they waste is a pound they can't spend improving their squad.

But for us to adopt that short-term approach would be reckless at best - and thankfully, the guy who'd have to pay for it all seems to understand this very well.
 
I don't think I recall anyone saying any differently.... Including Marsbars.... 🙂
Its a shame we still have to endure these kind of threads then - especially when his 'talisman' suggestion Coyle has lost five straight games and is looking like he's League One bound - never mind top six material.
 
How about you include some reference to the effect Di Matteo had at Villa, Pearson at Derby, Trollope at Cardiff, Stubbs at Rotherham, Wenga at Wolves, Caldwell at Wigan, Haissalbank at QPR. Or maybe examine why managers who have got clubs promoted from the Championship before (Owen Coyle, Ian Holloway and Nigel Adkins etc) have failed miserably at other clubs recently. Perhaps its because there is no magic formula to success. Or how Gary Rowett was unfairly booted out of Birmingham only for them to suffer back to back defeats under the 'super manager wanabee' Zola.

A manager is just one part of the overall jigsaw. And lets face it few managers are able to work with a bottom three budget and offer consistent long term success. But one thing we can learn from a lot of Championship clubs is that chopping and changing your manager if he doesnt offer a top 6 berth - is not the answer. Leeds have gone through 10 managers since Grayson left. All failed to beat Grayson's record there. At many clubs firing a manager is done to placate dumbass fans and keep the boos and spit from heading the boardrooms way. Thats the basic truth of the matter.

When Grayson leaves this football club he will walk into another job in the Championship. He has proven over and over again that he knows how to compete in this division.

People are very quick not to compare our manager to others in the division because it completely disproves their argument.

I'd like people to compare Grayson to the likes of Simpson, Westley, Ferguson and Brown before they start to criticise Grayson.

Not that he isn't above criticism as nobody is, but to instantly jump on his back after a poor showing is bad form in my book.
 
There's absolutely no point contemplating a change of manager without spelling out exactly who the new manager should be, so we can discuss their relative merits.

This isn't Brexit, where we just make a change for the sake of change without a clue what we do next. That's the policy adopted by many cash-rich clubs in this league, and it's great because it causes them to piss money away needlessly on futile staff turnover every 6 or 12 months - helping us to compete with them, because every pound they waste is a pound they can't spend improving their squad.

But for us to adopt that short-term approach would be reckless at best - and thankfully, the guy who'd have to pay for it all seems to understand this very well.


You're quite correct..........Bobbing along at the end of a lead and being too frightened of voicing an opinion ( rightly or wrongly) because you might lose what you already have ........Is the way to go..........It's the stuff of Champions!
 
Its a shame we still have to endure these kind of threads then - especially when his 'talisman' suggestion Coyle has lost five straight games and is looking like he's League One bound - never mind top six material.

It's an opinion......... That's all.
 
I don't think I recall anyone saying any differently.... Including Marsbars.... 🙂

Correct. Grayson will do just enough but sadly that is all. It's an easy choice to make ... if you're grateful to be here and think we can't compete and want Preston to be mid table in this league forever whilst making excuses then Graysons your man. If you want Preston to get promoted then he's not.

Twist or stick innit BUT the clubs that get promoted always twist.
 
I don't think I recall anyone saying any differently.... Including Marsbars.... 🙂
Correct. Grayson will do just enough but sadly that is all. It's an easy choice to make ... if you're grateful to be here and think we can't compete and want Preston to be mid table in this league forever whilst making excuses then Graysons your man. If you want Preston to get promoted then he's not. Twist or stick innit BUT the clubs that get promoted always twist.
I said Grayson CAN compete in this division. So it looks like Liberation was wrong about you after all. How queer.
 
I suspect he meant for promotion.....You little tinker, twisting words...
So did I in my original post. Not a twist of words at all. A win on NYE and we could be 5pts off 6th spot. I would say thats competing. Especially when we have three new players in training and a massive cup tie to look forward. Whats to be miserable about? Its not like we have Owen Coyle as manager.

PS Grayson finished 7th in his first season with Leeds. When he was sacked they were 10th. Is that not competing?
 
Last edited:
You're quite correct..........Bobbing along at the end of a lead and being too frightened of voicing an opinion ( rightly or wrongly) because you might lose what you already have ........Is the way to go..........It's the stuff of Champions!
Not sure what your metaphor is meant to be about - but as I said, there's no point advocating managerial change without specifying who you think the new manager should be.
 
I suspect he meant for promotion.....You little tinker, twisting words...

Of course. It's like dealing with psychopaths in here sometimes! If that miserable sour faced get Dreyfus has his way we'll be competing for 10th forever. No balls, no passion. Boring. It's not a surprise he's on the same page as the Thracian really is it?
 
Last edited:
Of course. It's like dealing with psychopaths in here sometimes!
Of course, even your "majestic talisman" managers didn't get promoted with their first job.

Ian Holloway started at QPR, where he took them down to L1 - oops. Got them up again at the 3rd attempt, then finished 11th (sound familiar?). Left the next season with them 14th.

He then went to Plymouth and promised them Prem football - he delivered them 11th (sound familiar?) then jumped ship to Leicester the next season.

Took Leicester down to L1 (sound familiar?), then resigned.

Got the Lashers job after a spell out of football. Now what exactly about his track record at that point suggested he was destined for promotion?

It's a genuine question, because you keep telling us a track record of "failure" means a manager can never win promotion to the Prem.

Yet Holloway did just that!
 
Last edited:
Of course. It's like dealing with psychopaths in here sometimes! If that miserable sour faced get Dreyfus has his way we'll be competing for 10th forever. No balls, no passion. Boring. It's not a surprise he's on the same page as the Thracian really is it?
Miserable sour faced? You are projecting again. Looking forward to going to see us versus Sheff Wed, Burton, Arsenal, Brighton, Villa... I'll see you at some of those games I am sure??? Maybe not.
 
Of course, even your "majestic talisman" managers didn't get promoted with their first job.

Ian Holloway started at QPR, where he took them down to L2 - oops. Got them up again at the 3rd attempt, then finished 11th (sound familiar?). Left the next season with them 14th.

He then went to Plymouth and promised them Prem football - he delivered them 11th (sound familiar?) then jumped ship to Leicester the next season.

Took Leicester down to L2 (sound familiar?), then resigned.

Got the Lashers job after a spell out of football. Now what exactly about his track record at that point suggested he was destined for promotion?

It's a genuine question, because you keep telling us a track record of "failure" means a manager can never win promotion to the Prem.

Yet Holloway did just that!


Well obviously we want the successful part you utter fucking idiot! The point is that they have had success in getting a team to the prem unlike the man we are employing. Jesus!
 
Miserable sour faced? You are projecting again. Looking forward to going to see us versus Sheff Wed, Burton, Arsenal, Brighton, Villa... I'll see you at some of those games I am sure??? Maybe not.

I'll be on 3 of those games and no doubt we'll see it differently. You'll be defending the mediocre and I'll be asking questions as to why Grayson has been allowed to bottle it yet again.
 
Of course. It's like dealing with psychopaths in here sometimes! If that miserable sour faced get Dreyfus has his way we'll be competing for 10th forever. No balls, no passion. Boring. It's not a surprise he's on the same page as the Thracian really is it?


Nah.... Only ones that take themselves far too seriously and have an inability to laugh at their own failings ( they don't have any don't you know )

If only they were as " driven " to win football matches as they are about to trying to appear logical eh?

🙂
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top