Why a miscalculated starting line up? Why were we lethargic? Why were we lacking energy?
I do wish our manager would take some responsibility for our results. It is his responsibility (and the rest of the coaching staff) to select the right starting line up, tactics and formation. It's also the responsibility of the same individuals to make sure the players are fit and ready and that they play with the required desire, tempo and effort.
If the above was not true, then we wouldn't need managers or coaching staff and we could just send 11 players onto the pitch to just get on with it. But good and great managers are worth their weight in gold. Witness Simeone at Athletico Madrid, Conte at Chelsea, Klopp at Liverpool and others at different levels. You can not over emphasise the importance of having a good manager.
Now I'm not saying we should have any of these 'super' managers in charge at PNE, just using them as examples to illustrate the effect a different manager can have, even with the same group of players.
Yes the players also have a responsibility to do their best, but they need managing, motivating, inspiring, encouraging, filling with self belief so they play with little or no fear. That's the real difference.
I've witnessed Graysons football, tactics and philosophy since he arrived at the club. I can remember games even in league 1 that we should have won easily (Chesterfield and Rotherham at home) and debacles away (e.g. Rochdale). Weaknesses, patterns of play and frailties that were there then are still there, with a set of completely different players.
Hence the question that keeps resurfacing at that back of my mind, asking if we do indeed have the right manager in place to progress and take us further. I have always had my doubts and will continue to have them, whilst hoping to be proven wrong.
All managers have their flaws though, even those you have mentioned. Yes, over Grayson's tenure some of the football has been boring and dull to watch, but other times it has been a joy to watch. That is a pattern that most football clubs will follow.
Yes, Grayson is not tactically perfect and does make the odd strange/ wrong substitution, sometimes he takes too long to make a decision on the sidelines. Again, I'm sure all managers make the same kind of mistakes.
Grayson's record speaks for itself - we have improved every season that he has been here, on a small budget - going through very poor patches of form and very strong patches of form. He has built a young hungry side over that time, which has the odd bit of quality as well.
We have lost 3 of the last 16 league games (I think), we are the 8th top scorers in the division (despite not having the unrealistic mutli million pound scorer that we apparently need), and we are playing better football and creating quite a few chances. The process has been and will continue to be a fairly slow process with no success guaranteed overnight, but our manager is doing a damn good job, given all the circumstances.
I wouldn't be surprised if he was poached by a bigger club before he got sacked.