Skip to main content

Central midfield yet again

Central midfield yet again

Joined
May 5, 2009
Messages
12,037
Great performance by our ten men today.

I just don't get what Kilkenny does though.

A decent player in instead of him and we would have had a result today.



What does he do????
 
I can't help but think Johnson & Welsh have to start from now on. Johnson does Killa's job, but a lot better and we don't need two sideways passers in the starting 11.
 
I said last night that normally Kilkenny keeps the ball but last night he wasn't able to do that and spent the night chasing shadows. Thought Welsh was better in all departments last night. They both lack physical presence as shown when up against Felaini.
 
I called it months ago about Kilkenny and like most things people are finally realising I'm right.

Not good enough.
 
I called it months ago about Kilkenny and like most things people are finally realising I'm right.

Not good enough.[/QUOTE]

If its a first to call it competition, i would like to register that i called it, that you are a Dick last month,which if my maths is correct makes me 97th !!
 
Kilkenny can be very negative at times but I like the way he controls the midfield, Good player IMO

When was the last time he played a good forward ball.

Against weak opposition he is good at collecting it from a CB and passing it to another CB.

Backwards and sideways, never goes where it gets difficult, never takes it forwards in a meaningful way.

Busy going nowhere.

And last night he was just nowhere.


Not impressed, we can do much better than him.
 
I said last night that normally Kilkenny keeps the ball but last night he wasn't able to do that and spent the night chasing shadows. Thought Welsh was better in all departments last night. They both lack physical presence as shown when up against Felaini.

He was playing against Manchester United's midfield! I think we ought to be able to forgive him if he failed to dominate against midfielders worth millions of pounds who play in the top flight and the Champions League week-in week-out...
 
When was the last time he played a good forward ball.

Against weak opposition he is good at collecting it from a CB and passing it to another CB.

Backwards and sideways, never goes where it gets difficult, never takes it forwards in a meaningful way.

Busy going nowhere.

And last night he was just nowhere.


Not impressed, we can do much better than him.

1. He was playing against Manchester United
2. The majority of games I've seen he's played well and if he passes it sideways he's passing it into space a tactic that Simon Grayson likes to play
 
Yet he was given a 7 out of 10 rating in The Sun. Something only Tom Clarke also had for us. Football is all about opinions.

I have nothing negative to say about any of our players last night. We were superb, and matched a side who are one of the best sides in the country. Time to take this into what really matters, and that's getting promoted this season.
 
When was the last time he played a good forward ball.

Against weak opposition he is good at collecting it from a CB and passing it to another CB.

Backwards and sideways, never goes where it gets difficult, never takes it forwards in a meaningful way.

Busy going nowhere.

And last night he was just nowhere.


Not impressed, we can do much better than him.

The Daily Mail player ratings:

Preston (3-4-1-2): Stuckmann 6; Humphrey 6.5, Huntington 7, Clarke 7, Wright 6 (Wiseman 75, 6); Welsh 6.5; Kilkenny 7 (Reid 75, 6), Gallagher 7, Laird 7.5; Davies 6.5 (Robinson 75, 6), Garner 7.
 
He was playing against Manchester United's midfield! I think we ought to be able to forgive him if he failed to dominate against midfielders worth millions of pounds who play in the top flight and the Champions League week-in week-out...

1. He was playing against Manchester United
2. The majority of games I've seen he's played well and if he passes it sideways he's passing it into space a tactic that Simon Grayson likes to play

Exactly.

Some people need to give it a rest.
 
We are still an assertive, quality central midfielder short of where we need to be. Last night simply showed that with particular clarity. Laird is also now verging on being too slow to be really effective in that 'wing-back role - he simply can't get past a fullback way out wide - he is at his best popping up in more central positions as he did for that glorious moment last night.
 
Agreed I was a very proud Preston fan last night,
I just don't like it whenever we get beaten we get people like Europne having a go at individuals when the team played well against the 3rd best team in the country!
I don't normally get into these debates but it annoys me when we have been doing so well!

Don't be a negative nancy Europne!!! CHEER UP!!🙂
 
Welsh put it an excellent shift. He showed his ability even against top class opposition. He was the only player able to stop them dead in their tracks. Having watched the game back on Tv, I hadn't realised how much work Kilkenny got through on and off the ball - it's easy to miss how much he actually does.

We're used to him dictating play, that was never, ever going to happen against United. I thoroughly believe he has a part to play this season but Grayson still has to figure out his best eleven and best approach.
 
Back
Top