Skip to main content

Central midfield

Central midfield

I've never seen him play at all.

Based on your description it sounds like he has some ability so hopefully he'll get another chance. I don't think its fair to judge any young player too quickly.

Where have I judged him, I said he was terrible last night, I have not judged him and "branded" him a rubbish player.
 
We have been short of a creative midfielder ever since Coutts was sold.

However Westley didn't do creative so signed the "grafters" we have now along with some utter garbage like the moose who I still find astounding was actually made club captain.

I still think we need one, however we will need to get shut of some before we can sign anyone else I would imagine.

We could look at the loan market but signing young lads from the Premier League can be pot luck on if they are up to the right level.

All that said it is worth remembering prior to Saturday we had been unbeaten and going along quite nicely. So still no need to panic in my eyes.

I don't think it's panicking.....it was a good run but even when things are going well I am sure SG will still be looking to improve the team. There is definitely something missing in the middle and the players who have been knocking on the managers door recently certainly didn't grasp their opportunity last night.
 
The clubs best and most talented midfielder just happens to be a seventeen year old lad called Josh Brownhill.In my opinion nobody else comes close.If you want creativity look no further
 
The clubs best and most talented midfielder just happens to be a seventeen year old lad called Josh Brownhill.In my opinion nobody else comes close.If you want creativity look no further

I hope they award him a professional contract very soon.

Although Croasdale was ineffective last night I thought that he played promisingly in the pre-season games.
 
Brownhill looked to have real class when he came on. A lovely weight to his passing - very slick. He was composed under pressure and confident going forward.

Welsh is a class act, as is Wroe when on song. Wroe plays in that position which gets overlooked, quick turns and quick one-twos. He rarely runs with the ball - so people assume he hasn't done much. I thought they both played well last night but the system didn't suit anyone in the first half.

I would certainly play Welsh alongside Keane when we're up against tough tests like Wolves Away. I'd like to see Wroe get the nod above Byrom against Crewe. See what Wroe can do in our strongest line-up.
 
Brownhill looked to have real class when he came on. A lovely weight to his passing - very slick. He was composed under pressure and confident going forward.

Welsh is a class act, as is Wroe when on song. Wroe plays in that position which gets overlooked, quick turns and quick one-twos. He rarely runs with the ball - so people assume he hasn't done much. I thought they both played well last night but the system didn't suit anyone in the first half.

I would certainly play Welsh alongside Keane when we're up against tough tests like Wolves Away. I'd like to see Wroe get the nod above Byrom against Crewe. See what Wroe can do in our strongest line-up.

I watched Grayson's body language last night just before he substituted Wroe. The last straw seemed to be a spooned pass to the right from Wroe who was then replaced by the young lad. I think SG may have made his mind up about one or two...
 
IMO Schmeltz and Wesolowski for them were great last night, and that Schmeltz was even better in the first Oldham game (2-1), whether he's better than Humphrey or not I don't know, but still would be good enough for most teams in this league.

Korey Smith, centre mid, free from Norwich (was injured in the pre-match warm up), Wez highly paid Aussie, free from Peterbro, never scores (usually)
Schmeltz free from Belgium-- wasn't even in our squad at weekend, Dayton free (I think) from Scotland
Montano-our best winger, came on and played left back, ex west ham. Mills on loan from Burnley
ALL MOBILE AND QUICK
 
Korey Smith, centre mid, free from Norwich (was injured in the pre-match warm up), Wez highly paid Aussie, free from Peterbro, never scores (usually)
Schmeltz free from Belgium-- wasn't even in our squad at weekend, Dayton free (I think) from Scotland
Montano-our best winger, came on and played left back, ex west ham. Mills on loan from Burnley
ALL MOBILE AND QUICK

All 17th in the league.
 
Apart from Keane breaking up play I havnt seen anyone who is up to scratch.

Welsh
Wroe
Byrom
Mousinho

Just not good enough, just a bunch of very ordinary players, and Keane certainly isn't creative.

We need creativity, pace and someone who can carry the ball forwards!!We need this area strengthening and quickly to keep up our promotion challenge.

Why ? we don't use midfield. It's either out to the wings for ( hopefully) a cross or launch it right down the middle....... I'm not saying it will get us anywhere longterm but those are the tactics ! 🙂
 
Seems to be split opinion on Byrom.
He is supposed to be our creative midfielder?

Some think he is OK.

But to me he cant defend, cant get forward, supposedly has a good left foot but i am still waiting to see it.

And he is painfully slow.

What am I not seeing in him?
 
Seems to be split opinion on Byrom.
He is supposed to be our creative midfielder?

Some think he is OK.

But to me he cant defend, cant get forward, supposedly has a good left foot but i am still waiting to see it.

And he is painfully slow.

What am I not seeing in him?

Spot on assessment
 
Seems to be split opinion on Byrom.
He is supposed to be our creative midfielder?

No, at the risk of repeating myself from previous threads, we don't play with a creative midfielder. It's the 3rd, deeper forward and the two wingbacks who are suppose to provide the creativity in the formation, with the angled longball into Davies being the other option. Our midfield is there to protect the defence, break up play and recycle possession to other players - the latter aspect generally being where Byrom comes in.
 
No, at the risk of repeating myself from previous threads, we don't play with a creative midfielder. It's the 3rd, deeper forward and the two wingbacks who are suppose to provide the creativity in the formation, with the angled longball into Davies being the other option. Our midfield is there to protect the defence, break up play and recycle possession to other players - the latter aspect generally being where Byrom comes in.

When King is fit, I wold rather he played in that role alongside Keane rather than Byrom. I agree with what you say about the main purpose of the two deeper midfielders, however when you say they recycle possession, I feel that could be done to a higher standard than is currently being done by Byrom.
 
Do many teams have that kind of player? isnt it like the mythical "30 a season" striker that every team needs?

Oldham seemed to have. Our CM get the ball and instantly look to play it wide. Now that might be under instruction but its not a new thing it seems to have been happening for years.

Set pieces.

Is that it?

That's pretty big under Grayson. But personally I think he offers more than that.
 
Is that it?

He has his pros and cons. Generally I'm not an enormous fan but he is classy from the dead ball. Obviously this isn't enough but he does seem to have been part of a good run of form and has been contributing fairly well. The clear weakness in his game is when we don't have the ball.
 
He has his pros and cons. Generally I'm not an enormous fan but he is classy from the dead ball. Obviously this isn't enough but he does seem to have been part of a good run of form and has been contributing fairly well. The clear weakness in his game is when we don't have the ball.

So why don't we play Byrom in the hole, he can get forward and score without the defensive duties, and if we start getting over run in midfield he can help out. That's what the other two have not been doing!
 
Bryom is deffo a luxury player we didn't mention him once in the commentary in that first half at Peterbrough he went missing big time. Welsh actually came on and played in Bryoms advance roll
and and he was inspirational in driving us forward in the second half. I think Its pros and cons with all the midfield lads. I personally think have a look at the opposition their strengths and weakness and mix and match them accordingly.
 
Back
Top