Skip to main content

Crap Refs

Crap Refs

He was his own worst enemy yesterday. Whatever the rights and wrongs of the referee's decisions, you simply cannot react to decisions with a sustained amount of dissent - he was quite rightly booked for doing so. The Wolves defenders were actually very good at seeing what he was doing, waiting for the ball and trying to either lay it off or control it rather than moving towards it - and they stopped him from doing it effectively. If he's going to progress, he'll need to learn from yesterday and when it's clear he's not going to get the decisions change tack.



Out of interest, the referee yesterday is in the second tier of select referees and as such has the training mentioned in the original post.

Wolves players got away with showing dissent. The Icelandic centre forward showed clear dissent and the ref said nothing. The wolves player who threw himself on the floor twice showed dissent both times and again nothing from the ref. His inconsistency was incredible.
 
At one point he tried to book a wolves player and beckoNed to him to come over but the wolves player ignored him. He then trotted 20 yards to book him. At that point I thought here we go.

I also was a bit disappointed with hugill at times. Some of his fouls were obvious. At times I thought he played the man more than the ball in the air.

From my view I thought it a definite penalty on vermijl.

He does make us look more dangerous when he comes on.
 
At one point he tried to book a wolves player and beckoNed to him to come over but the wolves player ignored him. He then trotted 20 yards to book him. At that point I thought here we go.

I also was a bit disappointed with hugill at times. Some of his fouls were obvious. At times I thought he played the man more than the ball in the air.

From my view I thought it a definite penalty on vermijl.

He does make us look more dangerous when he comes on.

Vermijl is a fantastic player, I get the feeling neither he nor the management know where his best position is, if they can work that out and stick to it he'll be awesome.

The penalty debacle was awful, he was looking right at it and we should have had a penalty twice in one move and he bottled it just like the ref against Newcastle. Grayson is understandably diplomatic on the radio after the game as he doesn't want a fine or a ban but it can't just be me that wants him to go mental at some point. I feel like as a club we're just lying down and accepting it. With the correct decisions we could have gained 5 more points from the Newcastle and Wolves home games.
 
There are a few issues that yesterday's game brought into focus.

The days of the old homer ref are long passed.

The referees assistants appear to make no decisions other than the ball going out. Perhaps this is because they are miked up to the ref?

They are so inconsistent and cards are often issued later in the game for a first offence but similar offences commited twice in the first half go uncarded.

I would propose a number of possible solutions some mentioned here already.

More cards issued irrespective of when or who by and a sin bin for two. This would reduce inconstancy of punishment. Violent/Dangerous conduct would still be a red, but two yellows would be a period of say 10 minutes off. A further two would be a longer period.

Technology to include a video ref for a set number of appeals per game and also to be linked to the on pitch referee in case, or when, he has Missed something. The fourth official does little more than manage technical areas and overseas subs and time added.

Time keeping needs looking at and managing better. The time added on is impossible to guess other than subs being 30 seconds each the rest seems to be anything from 2-6 extra minutes.

Finally for now would be the refs mike being audible to the crowd so his decisions can be understood.
 
It's long overdue.

Give both teams a couple of "challenges" per half, and let the video ref rule on the big decisions that the guy on the field currently gets away with bottling.

That is more or less what happens in many of the other sports, Rugby Union, Cricket, Ice Hockey, NFL and so on.

Football is so far behind almost all of the other major world wide sports it is laughable. With technology available a challenge (or video review) would take no longer than one minute, two at the most, but here is a newsflash for those against the idea..............the correct result would be the consequence for the most part.

Isn't that what we all want, regardless of which team one supports?
 
I am not surprised that the quality of the referees has declined over the years. The FA is run by incompetence and the recent manager of England farce has only cemented my view. Those 2 people who appointed big Sam should have resigned or been sacked and they are running the body that controls referees the majority of which are either incompetent or bullied by bigger teams just look at Newcastle and see the decisions that they get and indeed got against us.
 
That is more or less what happens in many of the other sports, Rugby Union, Cricket, Ice Hockey, NFL and so on.

Football is so far behind almost all of the other major world wide sports it is laughable. With technology available a challenge (or video review) would take no longer than one minute, two at the most, but here is a newsflash for those against the idea..............the correct result would be the consequence for the most part.

Isn't that what we all want, regardless of which team one supports?

The main difference with those sports you mentioned is that they are reviewing facts i.e. was the pass 'complete' in NFL or was the batsman back to the crease in time for a run out.

Reviewing tackles in the box etc. would still be down to the opinion of one man sat in the stand. Now he will have the benefit of TV replays of course, but they aren't always conclusive (and would unlikely to filter down to Championship level) and even on MotD and when they're chatting about the games on Sky there are always disagreements about whether the decision given i.e. a penalty was correct.

If a ref in the stand would have said the challenge on Beckford wasn't a foul would we all then have accepted it? No. Some would still have disagreed. For me technology in football should be used where someones opinion is taken out of it which is the good thing about the goal line technology and I'd focus on filtering goal line technology down through the leagues first. A goal not given in league 2 might send a club out of league football.
 
Reviewing tackles in the box etc. would still be down to the opinion of one man sat in the stand. Now he will have the benefit of TV replays of course, but they aren't always conclusive (and would unlikely to filter down to Championship level) and even on MotD and when they're chatting about the games on Sky there are always disagreements about whether the decision given i.e. a penalty was correct.
Yes, it'll still be one guy's opinion, but at least it'll be one guy's opinion with the replays available to him, rather than some crap ref who "didn't see it" or somesuch lame excuse.

If the incident is still inconclusive in the opinion of the video ref, then the "ruling on the field stands", as they would say in NFL.

If it's restricted to "challenges" made by the respective managers (limited in number per half, perhaps with none allowed during added time), signalled in some way, and if the review time is limited too (no point having the video ref spending ages over it), it won't lead to endless stoppages, it'll just result in a few key, contentious decisions per game being more closely scrutinised while the match is in progress and the result still up for grabs, rather than them being reviewed later on telly when nothing can be done about the result... which can only be a good thing IMO.
 
Just found this article on the BBC website reporting that African referees are being suspended for poor performances.

http://www.bbc.com/sport/football/38052482

Interesting to see what people think. The most humiliation a referee can ever face from their employers over here is being dropped down a league or two or being a 4th official for the next match, nothing like this idea. Unless referees are Kettle-esque then a suspension is quite harsh IMO.
 
The problem we have is that many of our top flight refs are egotistical pricks who think they are the star of the show these days. As such, I doubt if many of them would even bother consulting another official sat in a review room about a decision because it would make the refs look like they don't know what they are doing. And you can bet your life there would quickly be some sort of statistical 'league table' shown each week on match of the day to highlight which referees were having to resort to the technology the most. As a result, many refs in my opinion wouldn't use it anyway.
 
The problem we have is that many of our top flight refs are egotistical pricks who think they are the star of the show these days. As such, I doubt if many of them would even bother consulting another official sat in a review room about a decision because it would make the refs look like they don't know what they are doing. And you can bet your life there would quickly be some sort of statistical 'league table' shown each week on match of the day to highlight which referees were having to resort to the technology the most. As a result, many refs in my opinion wouldn't use it anyway.
That's why it needs to be triggered by the manager issuing an on-field "challenge", not by the crap ref.
 
That's why it needs to be triggered by the manager issuing an on-field "challenge", not by the crap ref.

I haven't made my mind up on the pros and cons of such an issue yet, and I'm certainly not against more clarity in decisions. If a "challenge" were to be made however, I wonder how the game could be restarted. Obviously, in the event of the game being stopped, a "challenge" made and being seen to be valid, by the reviewer and referee, and a free-kick/penalty/goal or whatever being awarded, that would be the result. What would happen if the "challenge" was refused? A drop-ball in the penalty area, if it happened there, or six yard box perhaps? A "technical" free-kick to the other team? Would there be a rather farcical situation arising, if both managers, depending on their viewpoint, were able to contest the same incident?
 
That's why it needs to be triggered by the manager issuing an on-field "challenge", not by the crap ref.
How many decisions would they be allowed to challenge per match? Can you seriously imagine someone like Sir Alex (yes, I know he's retired) or Warnock or Holloway, even accepting having one of his challenges over ruled? It'd cause mayhem. It has to be the ref who refers something, surely?
 
How many decisions would they be allowed to challenge per match? Can you seriously imagine someone like Sir Alex (yes, I know he's retired) or Warnock or Holloway, even accepting having one of his challenges over ruled? It'd cause mayhem. It has to be the ref who refers something, surely?

In tennis you get 3 challenges at the beginning of a new set. If you make a challenge against the umpires call and get it right then you still have 3 challenges remaining, get it wrong and you're down to 2. That sounds perfect to me.
 
In tennis you get 3 challenges at the beginning of a new set. If you make a challenge against the umpires call and get it right then you still have 3 challenges remaining, get it wrong and you're down to 2. That sounds perfect to me.
Yeah, that's the sort of system you'd need. Two challenges per half per manager would be my suggestion.

I haven't made my mind up on the pros and cons of such an issue yet, and I'm certainly not against more clarity in decisions. If a "challenge" were to be made however, I wonder how the game could be restarted. Obviously, in the event of the game being stopped, a "challenge" made and being seen to be valid, by the reviewer and referee, and a free-kick/penalty/goal or whatever being awarded, that would be the result. What would happen if the "challenge" was refused? A drop-ball in the penalty area, if it happened there, or six yard box perhaps? A "technical" free-kick to the other team? Would there be a rather farcical situation arising, if both managers, depending on their viewpoint, were able to contest the same incident?
There'd certainly be a bunch of technicalities and weird borderline cases to be ironed out, but I don't think the problems would be impossible to work out.

I think you'd certainly need time limits (extremely short ones) on the manager's ability to challenge following an incident, for a start.

And after the ref blows up with the ball in play, the usual restart method if the challenge was declined would be a dropped ball, I guess.
 
Yeah, that's the sort of system you'd need. Two challenges per half per manager would be my suggestion.

There'd certainly be a bunch of technicalities and weird borderline cases to be ironed out, but I don't think the problems would be impossible to work out.

I think you'd certainly need time limits (extremely short ones) on the manager's ability to challenge following an incident, for a start.

And after the ref blows up with the ball in play, the usual restart method if the challenge was declined would be a dropped ball, I guess.

I think I'd prefer to leave it at as it is rather than go through all that. It would be like in cricket where the batsman looks towards the dressing room no doubt to see if someone had a good view on the TV so I could see teams sitting someone in the stand with the manager looking around for guidance as to whether to risk the appeal or not.

One of these every 10-12 minutes would just kill games to me, we already moan about the ref not letting the games flow.

Aren't they trialling this in Serie B next season or something?
 
If refereeing was as easy as punditry we would be over run with ex professional players. Let referees make decisions based on how they see it not how they are supposed to do it when being assessed in the stand by another official. Autonomy has been taken away from them.
 
It aint gonna change any time soon, so get used to it.
Tennis and Rugby have taken it on board - a singles and team games. Football, the most popular world game, must see how video review is working in these other sports. Multi-millions of pounds can depend on human error. It's not right. FIFA will block it as long as they can, but their light is fading and I'll give them another 15 years tops till a more credible organisation is formed to run the game. The best FIFA came up with was 2 more officials instead of goal line technology, well proven with Hawkeye in tennis etc a decade beforehand. As soon as Blatter pops his clogs (and for me, the sooner the better) a breath of fresh air might sweep across the rules of the professional game.
 
Back
Top