Skip to main content

Crap Refs

Crap Refs

Tark

The Gentry (RIP)
Joined
Jun 23, 2004
Messages
6,253
Location
Avenham
Anyone know the best forum to discuss this on? My Google Search left be disappointed after, um, 10 seconds.
Hugill was called foul every time just for jumping today and got booked for rightly moaning about it after an hour of unpunished assaults upon him. Meanwhile, Wolves players could openly and illegally manhandle any white shirt without a whistle.
Surely the FA with all it's money can fund a 'professional ref' school at St George's in Burton who are required to talk to the media afterwards - and are paid similar money to the blokes they are reffing - so us fans get some answers.
Where does a ref saying after a match, "I should have given 2 pens to PNE against Newcastle" get anyone?
Professional players. Professional refs.
The FA & FL are as useless as FIFA is corrupt.
 
do we do ourselves any favours with refs, at times though?

I dont know if anyone else noticed Hugill as they came out after half time? Im sat in the stand so no idea what was said but lets just say he didnt look like he was exchanging pleasantries with him.
 
do we do ourselves any favours with refs, at times though?

I dont know if anyone else noticed Hugill as they came out after half time? Im sat in the stand so no idea what was said but lets just say he didnt look like he was exchanging pleasantries with him.

He was his own worst enemy yesterday. Whatever the rights and wrongs of the referee's decisions, you simply cannot react to decisions with a sustained amount of dissent - he was quite rightly booked for doing so. The Wolves defenders were actually very good at seeing what he was doing, waiting for the ball and trying to either lay it off or control it rather than moving towards it - and they stopped him from doing it effectively. If he's going to progress, he'll need to learn from yesterday and when it's clear he's not going to get the decisions change tack.

Out of interest, the referee yesterday is in the second tier of select referees and as such has the training mentioned in the original post.
 
Yesterday's Ref was crap.
The Ref in the Newcastle game was a cheat.
I cant say refs have never cheated but I can say it is very rare. the problem for refs when it comes to major decisions, like penalties, is to decide, instantaneously, who is and who isnt actually cheating.

Ive been against it but perhaps its time for technology to be used in decisions like this.
 
I think we should have had a penalty yesterday, other than that there was a few dubious decisions. Hugill was rightly booked for mouthing off. The only other problem he loved to have the whistle in his mouth, hardly let the game flow.

Both teams didn't contribute to the game until late in the second half. It wasn't just down the referee, both teams were poor.
 
He was his own worst enemy yesterday. Whatever the rights and wrongs of the referee's decisions, you simply cannot react to decisions with a sustained amount of dissent - he was quite rightly booked for doing so. The Wolves defenders were actually very good at seeing what he was doing, waiting for the ball and trying to either lay it off or control it rather than moving towards it - and they stopped him from doing it effectively. If he's going to progress, he'll need to learn from yesterday and when it's clear he's not going to get the decisions change tack.

Out of interest, the referee yesterday is in the second tier of select referees and as such has the training mentioned in the original post.

He had the training mentioned!? Really!? Think they need to change their training methods.
 
I don't think there was a penalty in the game.
The ref ruined the game but no major decisions were wrong imho.
 
Yesterday's ref was appalling, but so was the Newcastle one.

The overall standard is dire and paying customers expect better otherwise the game will have a serious problem on its hands.

For the money in the game there needs to be a higher standard and certainly accountability for the poor decisions being made.

I think our 'lowly' status in comparison to some clubs means a) we don't get the best refs available and b) we don't get decisions against bigger clubs.

That would have been a penalty all day long if Wolves were the home team appealing for it. Same with the Newcastle one.

SG was diplomatic post match but it's about time North End started making more of a fuss, otherwise we will continue to be unfairly treated by officials.

Two home games, 3 points potentially lost through decisions that weren't even debatable.

Time we stood up for ourselves now . . .
 
Ive been against it but perhaps its time for technology to be used in decisions like this.
It's long overdue.

Give both teams a couple of "challenges" per half, and let the video ref rule on the big decisions that the guy on the field currently gets away with bottling.
 
do we do ourselves any favours with refs, at times though?

I dont know if anyone else noticed Hugill as they came out after half time? Im sat in the stand so no idea what was said but lets just say he didnt look like he was exchanging pleasantries with him.

To be fair to Hugill prior to this booking he was armed in the face right in front of the referee and lineman on the IPS side. Prior to this he had been given nothing. Bookings for dissent are irritating but I was with Jordon on that one.

Overall the officials are no better than in league one, yet no doubt they favour the bigger clubs. There was about ten bookings yesterday and not a bad tackle in the game. The way he sprinted to book Maxwell sum his performance up.

The length of time its been since we had a penalty says it all.

It won't change though, it's just something we have put put up with sadly.
 
The problem will always be, The type of person attracted to becoming a referee, is nearly always, the exact type of person you do not want refereeing, i.e. self centred, attention seeking, jumped up, petty , small minded, anorak,never played the game at any level with any success, take the ball home when its not going their way type person !!
Make all refs ex pro players on a salary decent enough to attract them and send the current crop back to be traffic wardens, pne stewards or some other jobsworth type position, and by the way before they go, take their cans of spray foam and stick em where the sun dont shine, just to give em something to consider while on their journey !!
 
I don't think there was a penalty in the game.
The ref ruined the game but no major decisions were wrong imho.

Have a look at the highlights before McGeady hits the side netting. One, possibly two penalties in the space of a few seconds. Referee watching closely.
 
Have a look at the highlights before McGeady hits the side netting. One, possibly two penalties in the space of a few seconds. Referee watching closely.

I'd forgotten that bit, possible hyperthermia setting in.
I thought Vermil had slipped but Johnson was tripped but didn't appeal.
 
Back
Top