Skip to main content

Crap Refs

Crap Refs

Tennis and Rugby have taken it on board - a singles and team games. Football, the most popular world game, must see how video review is working in these other sports. Multi-millions of pounds can depend on human error. It's not right. FIFA will block it as long as they can, but their light is fading and I'll give them another 15 years tops till a more credible organisation is formed to run the game. The best FIFA came up with was 2 more officials instead of goal line technology, well proven with Hawkeye in tennis etc a decade beforehand. As soon as Blatter pops his clogs (and for me, the sooner the better) a breath of fresh air might sweep across the rules of the professional game.
Sepps not been involved in the game for a while now, posts on here quite a bit tho 🙂
 
The main difference with those sports you mentioned is that they are reviewing facts i.e. was the pass 'complete' in NFL or was the batsman back to the crease in time for a run out.

Reviewing tackles in the box etc. would still be down to the opinion of one man sat in the stand. Now he will have the benefit of TV replays of course, but they aren't always conclusive (and would unlikely to filter down to Championship level) and even on MotD and when they're chatting about the games on Sky there are always disagreements about whether the decision given i.e. a penalty was correct.

If a ref in the stand would have said the challenge on Beckford wasn't a foul would we all then have accepted it? No. Some would still have disagreed. For me technology in football should be used where someones opinion is taken out of it which is the good thing about the goal line technology and I'd focus on filtering goal line technology down through the leagues first. A goal not given in league 2 might send a club out of league football.

Some valid (but old fashioned points there Tino).

As pointed out by Thracia in the response to you, a ref has a split second to a) view the incident, and b) come to a decision, but what if he is unsighted?

Then of course the most blatant of fouls will be missed because from what I see of the "assistant referees" they may as well not be there.

So it takes a fifth or sixth official sat in the stand maybe anywhere between 30 seconds and lets say a maximum of 120 seconds to re-view and re-play on a screen the said incident.

Now if he is still undecided, then fair enough, we have given every opportunity for what could be a game changing decision to be made, and I can live with that.

But when you see a player like Vermijl knocked to the ground as he was v Wolves, and then Johnson also tripped or edged (use whatever word you wish) a few seconds later also to the ground, then surely, in all fairness, a couple of minutes is nothing in the big picture of an afternoon out for fans that may start hours before kick off (if travel is involved) and not end until hours after the final whistle has blown.

If an extra few minutes with obviously limited challenges by the managers is too much to be acceptable, then why bother playing the game in the first place?

Personally I would start it with just one challenge per game for each manager, that can't take more than four minutes maximum, as a 2 minute rule could be brought in for example. If it runs smoothly, then a possible challenger per half could be considered and so on.

Similar to when subs were first introduced, initially it was just one for injury only, then also for tactical reasons, (?), then it went to two, now it is three.

And considering that the Championship play off final (I believe) hold the most financially lucrative prize for the winner in the whole of football, it had better filter down to the Championship.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top