Skip to main content

Flashback

Flashback

We all thought we'd discovered a great new striker Brian greenhalgh ! QUOTE]

Greenhalgh had, in fact, scored a hat-trick not too long previously in a 3-1 away win at Bolton when he deputised for the injured Alex Dawson. But the following match was the FA Cup 6th Round at home to Man Utd for which Dawson was restored and scored. Greenhalgh is perhaps the only player for PNE to be 'dropped' after scoring a hat-trick. He was actually a talented player and when he and Brian Godfrey were subsequently simultaneously transferred to Aston Villa they were for a short time at least quite sensational.

In truth Godfrey's goals at PNE had started to dry up considerably, and he was used more as a scheming inside-forward. Greenhalgh had some skill but no pace, and the LEP reports of the time contained, for me, the classic line stating that when he ran forwards, he made little headway as "it was like running on the spot in treacle". He scored a few goals true, but if was to be between him and Alex Dawson, well..........

The season Godfrey and Greenhalgh were transferred also saw Gemmill, Derek Temple, and Willie Irvine appear, on the scene, as well as Heppolette if memory serves me correctly, maybe also Ken Knighton. All were good players, despite a decline in league postion, which was mostly due to manager Bobby Seith's incomprehensible tactics (his first manager's job being at Deepdale). It was he who didn't like Godfrey and Greenhalgh, but sold them on for decent money. Mind you, earlier, he hadn't liked Alex Dawson either, and got rid of him just before the in-season mid-March transfer deadline of the time. Then he got in Jim Forrest, ex big noise goalscorer from... Rangers(?). He got rid of Dawson with one goal every other game that season on average, and brought in Forrest who scored about 5 in 25, before shipping him out as well. I remember that time when Seith, the manager had a lot of money given to him, to bring in players of previously good quality, who played under Seith's mysterious tactics, and proceeded to deteriorate rapidly. "Only"... one goal every two games from a CF. Who wouldn't take that now?
 
The season Godfrey and Greenhalgh were transferred also saw Gemmill, Derek Temple, and Willie Irvine appear, on the scene, as well as Heppolette if memory serves me correctly, maybe also Ken Knighton.

Yes - season 66-67 was the one in which the team that had got to the Cup Final in 64 and largely persisted throughout the next two seasons was dismantled. Archie Gemmil arrived in the close season before the start of the 67-68 campaign and Willie Irvine during it, as I remember. Was Derek Temple brought in by Jimmy Milne before he retired or by Seith? The latter was given money to spend and in fairness spent it well - Graham Hawkins, Ken Knighton and Willie Irvine were all excellent buys - but he could not get them to gel as a consistently effective team. The comparison between Seith and a later - more rotund - Scottish manager in that respect is quite striking.
 
Certainly had shades of Derby and Charlton about it.

Didn't blame Phil Brown quite so much given just how poor the squad was at Charlton , but the team mismanaged to the humiliation at Derby by charlatan Craig was really strong (apart from Marlon Broomes of course).
 
Yes - season 66-67 was the one in which the team that had got to the Cup Final in 64 and largely persisted throughout the next two seasons was dismantled. Archie Gemmil arrived in the close season before the start of the 67-68 campaign and Willie Irvine during it, as I remember. Was Derek Temple brought in by Jimmy Milne before he retired or by Seith? The latter was given money to spend and in fairness spent it well - Graham Hawkins, Ken Knighton and Willie Irvine were all excellent buys - but he could not get them to gel as a consistently effective team. The comparison between Seith and a later - more rotund - Scottish manager in that respect is quite striking.

I thought Seith palyed no small part in our long term demise.Milne had teams set up to play attacking football Seith was the opposite.
 
Greenhalgh had, in fact, scored a hat-trick not too long previously in a 3-1 away win at Bolton when he deputised for the injured Alex Dawson. But the following match was the FA Cup 6th Round at home to Man Utd for which Dawson was restored and scored. Greenhalgh is perhaps the only player for PNE to be 'dropped' after scoring a hat-trick. He was actually a talented player and when he and Brian Godfrey were subsequently simultaneously transferred to Aston Villa they were for a short time at least quite sensational.

And then he took up baking. P.S. I remember Godfrey playing for Aston Villa and being good.. no recollection of Greenhalgh at Villa though.
 
In truth Godfrey's goals at PNE had started to dry up considerably, and he was used more as a scheming inside-forward. Greenhalgh had some skill but no pace, and the LEP reports of the time contained, for me, the classic line stating that when he ran forwards, he made little headway as "it was like running on the spot in treacle". He scored a few goals true, but if was to be between him and Alex Dawson, well..........

The season Godfrey and Greenhalgh were transferred also saw Gemmill, Derek Temple, and Willie Irvine appear, on the scene, as well as Heppolette if memory serves me correctly, maybe also Ken Knighton. All were good players, despite a decline in league postion, which was mostly due to manager Bobby Seith's incomprehensible tactics (his first manager's job being at Deepdale). It was he who didn't like Godfrey and Greenhalgh, but sold them on for decent money. Mind you, earlier, he hadn't liked Alex Dawson either, and got rid of him just before the in-season mid-March transfer deadline of the time. Then he got in Jim Forrest, ex big noise goalscorer from... Rangers(?). He got rid of Dawson with one goal every other game that season on average, and brought in Forrest who scored about 5 in 25, before shipping him out as well. I remember that time when Seith, the manager had a lot of money given to him, to bring in players of previously good quality, who played under Seith's mysterious tactics, and proceeded to deteriorate rapidly. "Only"... one goal every two games from a CF. Who wouldn't take that now?

Jim Forrest Rangers.. scored two in his first game if I remember then hardly did anything after that.

Amazing Ricky Heppolete to this day remains one of few Asians to do well in football
 
Jim Forrest Rangers.. scored two in his first game if I remember then hardly did anything after that.

Amazing Ricky Heppolete to this day remains one of few Asians to do well in football

He scored one in a 2-0 over Derby County and played well for the rest of that season but couldn't settle and eventually went back to Scotland where he played well for Aberdeen. As for Ricky Heppolette he was always described as 'Anglo-Indian' which may mean that one or other of his parents were British, which could be a factor in his being such a good footballer. Otherwise despite their British links the 'Asian' countries of India, Pakistan and Sri Lanka simply aren't places where football ever took root unlike cricket and they just haven't produced players of any note.
 
I thought Seith palyed no small part in our long term demise.Milne had teams set up to play attacking football Seith was the opposite.

Quote Originally Posted by ernest View Post
The season Godfrey and Greenhalgh were transferred also saw Gemmill, Derek Temple, and Willie Irvine appear, on the scene, as well as Heppolette if memory serves me correctly, maybe also Ken Knighton.
Yes - season 66-67 was the one in which the team that had got to the Cup Final in 64 and largely persisted throughout the next two seasons was dismantled. Archie Gemmil arrived in the close season before the start of the 67-68 campaign and Willie Irvine during it, as I remember. Was Derek Temple brought in by Jimmy Milne before he retired or by Seith? The latter was given money to spend and in fairness spent it well - Graham Hawkins, Ken Knighton and Willie Irvine were all excellent buys - but he could not get them to gel as a consistently effective team. The comparison between Seith and a later - more rotund - Scottish manager in that respect is quite striking.

Ernest: Seith came in November-ish '66, sold Godfrey and Greenhalgh early September '67, and bought Temple late September '67. He'd, mistakenly, previously got rid of Dawson, bought and sold Forrest (useless after a bright, very early, start as a replacement), got in Ray Charnley from Blackpool, another useless had-been, and got rid of him. It is true that he bought in some good players; he was given quite a bit of £££, to do so (if only that were true nowadays...). However as Proton says, he was the architect, engineer, clerk of works, and general factotum of the '60s demise of PNE after Jimmy Milne left.

In my opinion Milne was far and away the best post-war manager PNE have had; it was he who had been in charge circa 1960, of PNE's own youth team "golden generation" of Thompson, Wilson, Spavin, Singleton et al; he also bought very wisely after Finney left, got them to within a whisker of a remarkable "double" of his own at the time in '64, and in my opinion again, bought, and fostered, the best CF, in Dawson, that PNE had in years. Milne always had PNE set up to attack. People should have another look at the '64 Cup Final for proof of that. Milne also set up North End's vast scouting system of the time, which would put to shame the present day ones. He used to send out over 20 scouts nation-wide every Saturday. Seith by contrast was in the vanguard of the new generation of "thinking man's" manager, track-suited, depending on clip-board waving nonsense. In that respect he was also nothing like Craig Brown, who shouldn't be sullied by such a comparison. He (CB) didn't have the success we wanted, but was not responsible for the subsequent PNE failures. Far from it.
 
Jimmy Milne also looked at a Preston Grammar School player, and said he was too small to become a professional player.

Whoops.

This lad ended up with League Championship titles, and A European Cup Medal.

Brian Hall, ended up in a certain Liverpool team.
 
Ernest: Seith came in November-ish '66QUOTE]

I thought it was a bit later. I agree that overall he was a disaster, but there were times during his tenure when it looked like things might be coming together - the 3-0 FA Cup win over Nottingham Forest was probably the highlight of his whole time with us. The bodyblows to his team were the transfer of Ken Knighton and the injury to Willie Irvine - I think Derek Temple got clogged a lot too. Jimmy Forrest stayed ineffectively till mid-69, Charnley was a short-term expedient to fill in for Forrest's failure and viewed in that way was quite sucessful. Then there was Gerry Ingram....
 
In my opinion Milne was far and away the best post-war manager PNE have had;

Really? Let's just ignore for a moment the FA cup final, and one or two other very good cup runs, and focus on our final league position in the old div 2 under Jimmy Milne to see if the evidence supports your claim.

1961/62..............10th
1962/63..............17th
1963/64................3rd
1964/65..............12th
1965/66..............17th
1966/67..............13th
1967/68..............20th.

I am not sure exactly which season was Milne's last in charge, but wiki says he was manager from 1961 to 1968, but you say Seith took over in 1966?

Don't forget, Milne took over a club that had just prior to relegation had 10 consecutive very successful seasons as a first division (now premiership) club.

If he was in charge until 1968, his average finishing position was 13th. If he was only in charge lets say until the end of the 1965/66 season, it was 12th, either way, not what I would describe as a record for the "far and away best post war manager", in fact nothing like it.

Billy Davies for example had just two seasons in charge and got us in the play offs both times with I think a 4th and then a 5th placed finish.

And without checking Moyes average at the same level for his two seasons or so in charge, it was certainly better than Milne's, and he inherited a 3rd tier team, not one that had just been relegated from the top division.

Hey, I am not knocking Jimmy Milne, just trying to present a balanced debate about who was and who wasn't our best manager (by far and away you wrote) of the post war era.

Don't forget during the 1950's, PNE also experienced a cup final, and other good cup runs, came runners up in the league I think twice and 3rd once, so don't you think the manager of the day (Scott Symon at the time of the cup final) would have something to say about your remark about Jimmy Milne being the best post war manager?

I would say Milne was about our 4th best post war manager, maybe even 5th, as PNE under his management (other than one season) didn't even come close to promotion out of the old div 2 unlike in 1949/50 when they went up as champions, so maybe the manager of the day at that time (Will Scott) would also challenge you on your opinion re Mr Milne's managerial status at PNE.

The truth is (and I saw almost all of the games at home and many away of Jimmy Milne's time in charge) that we had one outstanding season under him, and the rest were average, as the final finishing positions under his leadership illustrate.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top