In my opinion Milne was far and away the best post-war manager PNE have had;
Really? Let's just ignore for a moment the FA cup final, and one or two other very good cup runs, and focus on our final league position in the old div 2 under Jimmy Milne to see if the evidence supports your claim.
1961/62..............10th
1962/63..............17th
1963/64................3rd
1964/65..............12th
1965/66..............17th
1966/67..............13th
1967/68..............20th.
I am not sure exactly which season was Milne's last in charge, but wiki says he was manager from 1961 to 1968, but you say Seith took over in 1966?
Don't forget, Milne took over a club that had just prior to relegation had 10 consecutive very successful seasons as a first division (now premiership) club.
If he was in charge until 1968, his average finishing position was 13th. If he was only in charge lets say until the end of the 1965/66 season, it was 12th, either way, not what I would describe as a record for the "far and away best post war manager", in fact nothing like it.
Billy Davies for example had just two seasons in charge and got us in the play offs both times with I think a 4th and then a 5th placed finish.
And without checking Moyes average at the same level for his two seasons or so in charge, it was certainly better than Milne's, and he inherited a 3rd tier team, not one that had just been relegated from the top division.
Hey, I am not knocking Jimmy Milne, just trying to present a balanced debate about who was and who wasn't our best manager (by far and away you wrote) of the post war era.
Don't forget during the 1950's, PNE also experienced a cup final, and other good cup runs, came runners up in the league I think twice and 3rd once, so don't you think the manager of the day (Scott Symon at the time of the cup final) would have something to say about your remark about Jimmy Milne being the best post war manager?
I would say Milne was about our 4th best post war manager, maybe even 5th, as PNE under his management (other than one season) didn't even come close to promotion out of the old div 2 unlike in 1949/50 when they went up as champions, so maybe the manager of the day at that time (Will Scott) would also challenge you on your opinion re Mr Milne's managerial status at PNE.
The truth is (and I saw almost all of the games at home and many away of Jimmy Milne's time in charge) that we had one outstanding season under him, and the rest were average, as the final finishing positions under his leadership illustrate.