Do you lads know how long it took Alan Kelly Snr to be accepted after Fred Else left this club. Back off and give him a good chance. He may turn out ok
Goalkeeper
I liked what I saw at Rochdale.
It comes as no surprise though that people are writing him off already - after all they can then tell us later that when his form inevitably drops from lack of confidence that they were right all along. Nothing like being right on an internet forum.
I am with many others on this issue, just 2 goals conceded means he must be doing something right.
It comes as no surprise though that people are writing him off already - after all they can then tell us later that when his form inevitably drops from lack of confidence that they were right all along. Nothing like being right on an internet forum.
I am with many others on this issue, just 2 goals conceded means he must be doing something right.
Another thing to consider is that he's only 25, which is relatively young for a keeper and only 2 years older than Rudd!
I was impressed at Doncaster by his calmness and organisation. Give the lad a chance and get behind him. Football is a game of mistakes which are happening all over the pitch. You can find fault and point out a misplaced pass or missed tackle from any player on both sides usually. I think he's going to be good and consistent.
He's a good looking lad.
One thing I've noticed about him is he's good at catching shots rather than parrying them. Makes a big difference.
He's certainly not lacking in confidence, and has a very calm air about him.
I like him, he'll do us just fine.
Agreed, a lot of shots that he catches I think Rudd would have parried back into danger. Theres no question that Rudd's shot stopping ability was brilliant but he had the odd mistake in him.
Jones is very calm for me doesn't panic and that can only give the back 4 confidence. Against Doncaster when Coppinger cut through our team like a hot knife through butter Jones stood his ground and calmly caught his shot.
I liked what I saw at Rochdale.
It comes as no surprise though that people are writing him off already - after all they can then tell us later that when his form inevitably drops from lack of confidence that they were right all along. Nothing like being right on an internet forum.
I am with many others on this issue, just 2 goals conceded means he must be doing something right.
I mentioned it on a thread weeks ago that some people berate players and put the team down because its easier than actually putting your neck on the line and supporting a player. It feeds the ego for most and its a pathetic way to support your team because its a win win situation for them. If Jones becomes a world beater they will stay silent and enjoy his performances, a win, but if he is shit they get to parade themselves on the forum boasting about there higher knowledge of football, also a win. The people on here know who they are and you can spot them a mile away because you constantly get annoyed at there threads and posts.
I want him to succeed and I'll not have a go at him during games, I back my team rather than barrack them. Forums are where you give your honest opinion and mine is that I don't think he's good enough from what I've seen so far, be it very early days.
If forums should only allow positivity about players in case they read what's put there'd be very few posts. Also as a professional keeper he will or should be strong enough to brush off comments from fans on a forum. Strong people will say "f--k em, I'll prove them wrong" which is what I hope he does.
If forums should only allow positivity about players in case they read what's put there'd be very few posts. Also as a professional keeper he will or should be strong enough to brush off comments from fans on a forum. Strong people will say "f--k em, I'll prove them wrong" which is what I hope he does.
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2004
- Messages
- 19,671
I seem to remember Nash not having the best of starts at the club, including letting a simple shot through his hands I think at Rotherham yet he's garded by many as the best they've seen at Deepdale. How many seem to have already decided he isn't good enough is beyond me.
Give the lad a chance, he's playing behind a new back 4 so there's an added complication there as well.
Give the lad a chance, he's playing behind a new back 4 so there's an added complication there as well.
Sorry Ron, there was an element of sarcasm there. Rudd made a number of mistakes which led to goals, but he was still a good keeper. This lad has made a couple of mistakes (if we blame him for the Notts County goal). Does that make him a bad keeper? I think not, and as you point out there were other parties to blame for the two goals we have conceded in 4 games.Rudd did make mistakes, or did everyone forget the Peterborough away game. Rudd tended to parry a lot of shots compared to (I know its early) Jones. And if you looked back at last season a couple of the parried shots ended up getting followed in.
But Rudd was a class keeper and was always going to be a tough act to follow.
I don't think Jones has made than many mistakes, he maybe got caught under the cross against Doncaster but to be fair that ball should have been won by one of our CB's.
Notts County was the CB's fault again for not winning the ball and going to sleep at a throw in.
Jones for me is very calm and doesn't seem to panic, which means he doesnt parry the ball back into the path of opposition players.
I think he is too short to be a great keeper, his lack of height probably cost us that goal on Tuesday night.
I want him to succeed and I'll not have a go at him during games, I back my team rather than barrack them. Forums are where you give your honest opinion and mine is that I don't think he's good enough from what I've seen so far, be it very early days.
If forums should only allow positivity about players in case they read what's put there'd be very few posts. Also as a professional keeper he will or should be strong enough to brush off comments from fans on a forum. Strong people will say "f--k em, I'll prove them wrong" which is what I hope he does.
Your opinion is your opinion and on a forum is where it is challenged. I just don't think you can say he isn't good enough after conceding 2 goals in 4 games and possibly 1 mistake to boot coupled together with he is playing with a new back 4.
Sorry Ron, there was an element of sarcasm there. Rudd made a number of mistakes which led to goals, but he was still a good keeper. This lad has made a couple of mistakes (if we blame him for the Notts County goal). Does that make him a bad keeper? I think not, and as you point out there were other parties to blame for the two goals we have conceded in 4 games.
I apologise then, its hard to get the tone of some peoples posts on here at times. I do hold your opinion in quite high regard compared to others.
That brief spell at the top of the League the other night was down to our goal-difference. Yeah, the 4 against Scunny were a factor, but so was the fact that JJ had only let 2 past him.
He's more than capable.
He's more than capable.