Skip to main content

Grayson, back or sack?

Grayson, back or sack?

Poll Poll Grayson, back or sack?

  • Back

    Votes: 176 82.6%
  • Sack

    Votes: 37 17.4%

  • Total voters
    213
No it hasn't and people seem to manipulate a post from nearly 12 months ago because they run out of arguments against me, don't be so petty OOOO don't but yourself in the same boat as Mossy.

I don't know with Grayson, minimum to Christmas after that we will have to see.

To be honest I am nothing like the guy you mention but it was pretty black and white mate. You were happy to replace Grayson but that was last season.

Have to see what? If we are still second of bottom and negative tactics?
 
Graysons mind numbing football is just about acceptable when we are winning - when we are not , as now it's a disaster .

It's shown that most , yes , most of the players are nt. up to this level.

Yes he's had some bad luck with injuries and hell , we are up against clubs awash with money but this slow , predictable hoofball will get you nowhere at this level.

I d rather go down fighting - at least with some intent to try to win - that's not Grayson's way and he s not likely to change.
 
Back him until Xmas. If we really get cast adrif by Mid to end November then revue the situation earlier. Clubs that keep changing manager rarely succeed, but never say never.
 
To be honest I am nothing like the guy you mention but it was pretty black and white mate. You were happy to replace Grayson but that was last season.

Have to see what? If we are still second of bottom and negative tactics?

I think the negative tactics thing with Grayson is a myth.

vs Bristol City 13 shots, 3 on target to their 15 shots and 5 on target

vs Sheffield Wednesday 9 shots, 3 on target to their 13 shots and 6 on target

vs Derby 19 shots, 6 on target to their 14 shots and 3 on target

vs Hull 9 shots, 2 on target to their 15 shots and 4 on target

vs Ipswich 16 shots, 5 on target to their 4 shots and 2 on target

vs Brentford 13 shots, 4 on target to their 14 shots and 7 on target

The negative tactics as you call them haven't exactly left us with zero creativity, we matched some of the teams in the list above and then if you look at the Derby and Ipswich games we have created more than them.

Remember as well in all of those games we have been without Beckford and for most of them we have been without Gallagher, get one of the 2 back in the team and see how we do.
 
Back him, for now, but ultimately, the backing that really counts is Hemmings' financial backing. £1m for May was a big outlay by North End's standards and I said at the time that Grayson would stand or fall by that signing. Notwithstanding the mediocre support for the strikers this season, particularly in Gallagher's absence, if May continues to disappoint, I can't see Hemmings trusting Grayson with the money he will certainly need in January. If things aren't looking up by mid November I think Hemmings will be looking to make a change.
 
Last edited:
I think the negative tactics thing with Grayson is a myth.

vs Bristol City 13 shots, 3 on target to their 15 shots and 5 on target

vs Sheffield Wednesday 9 shots, 3 on target to their 13 shots and 6 on target

vs Derby 19 shots, 6 on target to their 14 shots and 3 on target

vs Hull 9 shots, 2 on target to their 15 shots and 4 on target

vs Ipswich 16 shots, 5 on target to their 4 shots and 2 on target

vs Brentford 13 shots, 4 on target to their 14 shots and 7 on target

The negative tactics as you call them haven't exactly left us with zero creativity, we matched some of the teams in the list above and then if you look at the Derby and Ipswich games we have created more than them.

Remember as well in all of those games we have been without Beckford and for most of them we have been without Gallagher, get one of the 2 back in the team and see how we do.


Ron we got 1 point out of those 6 games....

I get the point you are trying to put forward. Ok maybe the strikers he has brought in aren't good enough then.

The argument either way still stacks up against Grayson.

I am not sure how many Gally has missed against those 6 but although those two (Beckford and Gally) are a huge miss we can't rely on two players.
 
Back him until Xmas. If we really get cast adrif by Mid to end November then revue the situation earlier. Clubs that keep changing manager rarely succeed, but never say never.

Certainly the exception to the rule but Watford have had 6 managers in 18 months and aren't doing too badly!
 
I think the negative tactics thing with Grayson is a myth.

vs Bristol City 13 shots, 3 on target to their 15 shots and 5 on target

vs Sheffield Wednesday 9 shots, 3 on target to their 13 shots and 6 on target

vs Derby 19 shots, 6 on target to their 14 shots and 3 on target

vs Hull 9 shots, 2 on target to their 15 shots and 4 on target

vs Ipswich 16 shots, 5 on target to their 4 shots and 2 on target

vs Brentford 13 shots, 4 on target to their 14 shots and 7 on target

The negative tactics as you call them haven't exactly left us with zero creativity, we matched some of the teams in the list above and then if you look at the Derby and Ipswich games we have created more than them.

Remember as well in all of those games we have been without Beckford and for most of them we have been without Gallagher, get one of the 2 back in the team and see how we do.

Stats like that don't necessarily paint a true picture though. Those shots may include pot luck shots from 30 yards out. With the games you mentioned, we were 2nd best against Bristol City (took a worldie strike for us to score), yesterday we never created a chance until 2-0 down and deserved to lose, we never looked like winning against Derby or Hull, were unlucky against Ipswich, and deserved to lose at Brentford.

Teams of our financial resources in this league who have managed to overachieve in some seasons play aggressive, in your face, quick football (Rotherham, Blackpool, Burnley, Bournemouth etc). We are trying to play well organised, keep it tight and play direct football. It's not pretty to the eye. But at this level it's not working. We're conceding easy goals, and not creating enough goal scoring chances. If we concede first, and this was the same in League 1, our record at getting something from the game under Grayson is poor.

I still think Grayson deserves a bit more time, but we can't leave it too late like we did with Darren Ferguson. We got it right when we sacked Paul Simpson. It allowed Irvine chance to implement his coaching methods and tactics, assess the players before making transfers in January. I would give Grayson until the end of the next international break in November, and he needs 7 points from the next 6 games minimum.
 
I'm backing him, but we need to see some wins this month quite frankly. Ask me this question again on 1st November and I may (hopefully not) have a different opinion.
 
Back for now but if there isnt improvement soon I wouldn't even leave it as long as Christmas. When has it ever worked for us?

Also, he shouldn't be fired for his failures, he should be fired because the Riddler has found someone who can manage this team more effectively. Too often we've fired managers because they are under performing without sounding out replacements
 
Stats like that don't necessarily paint a true picture though. Those shots may include pot luck shots from 30 yards out. With the games you mentioned, we were 2nd best against Bristol City (took a worldie strike for us to score), yesterday we never created a chance until 2-0 down and deserved to lose, we never looked like winning against Derby or Hull, were unlucky against Ipswich, and deserved to lose at Brentford.

Teams of our financial resources in this league who have managed to overachieve in some seasons play aggressive, in your face, quick football (Rotherham, Blackpool, Burnley, Bournemouth etc). We are trying to play well organised, keep it tight and play direct football. It's not pretty to the eye. But at this level it's not working. We're conceding easy goals, and not creating enough goal scoring chances. If we concede first, and this was the same in League 1, our record at getting something from the game under Grayson is poor.

I still think Grayson deserves a bit more time, but we can't leave it too late like we did with Darren Ferguson. We got it right when we sacked Paul Simpson. It allowed Irvine chance to implement his coaching methods and tactics, assess the players before making transfers in January. I would give Grayson until the end of the next international break in November, and he needs 7 points from the next 6 games minimum.

Good post, agree with around 70% of it but still a very good post.
 
Ron we got 1 point out of those 6 games....

I get the point you are trying to put forward. Ok maybe the strikers he has brought in aren't good enough then.

The argument either way still stacks up against Grayson.

I am not sure how many Gally has missed against those 6 but although those two (Beckford and Gally) are a huge miss we can't rely on two players.

Or the strikers haven't had time to get to know the team's game, tactics and whereabouts yet.

As a small club in the Championship you will only have 2-3 players to rely on, even the big teams only have 2-3 players to rely on, thats football.
 
Also, he shouldn't be fired for his failures, he should be fired because the Riddler has found someone who can manage this team more effectively. Too often we've fired managers because they are under performing without sounding out replacements

Bang on! I don't want a 3/4 week period fucking about interviewing folk and making a 'carefully considered decision' whilst the players battle on weary of the future under a caretaker - who would that even be for that matter? Snodin would probably go with Grayson, whilst I wouldn't want Thompson near it and hope he'd go with Grayson also if that's what transpired.

It's harsh but all that shit should be done in secret whilst the current manager is still in place on the basis that the change could take place at any given moment, should things not improve under the existing manager.

Harsh and unfair on the existing manager? Yes it dam well is. Welcome to 21st century Football management.
 
Or the strikers haven't had time to get to know the team's game, tactics and whereabouts yet.

As a small club in the Championship you will only have 2-3 players to rely on, even the big teams only have 2-3 players to rely on, thats football.

The strikers don't know their whereabouts? I've heard it all now.

Yes and you spend money on other players and bring loans in to improve your squad. A silly manager would just rely on what they know.
 
Back for now but if there isnt improvement soon I wouldn't even leave it as long as Christmas. When has it ever worked for us?

Also, he shouldn't be fired for his failures, he should be fired because the Riddler has found someone who can manage this team more effectively. Too often we've fired managers because they are under performing without sounding out replacements
Good post, I agree totally.
 
Bang on! I don't want a 3/4 week period fucking about interviewing folk and making a 'carefully considered decision' whilst the players battle on weary of the future under a caretaker - who would that even be for that matter? Snodin would probably go with Grayson, whilst I wouldn't want Thompson near it and hope he'd go with Grayson also if that's what transpired.

It's harsh but all that shit should be done in secret whilst the current manager is still in place on the basis that the change could take place at any given moment, should things not improve under the existing manager.

Harsh and unfair on the existing manager? Yes it dam well is. Welcome to 21st century Football management.

Totally agree. In fact, I wouldn't even interview people. Sound out the man we want, ring him up and invite him in to talk contracts. The interview process gets you talkers, looking at a track record and a footballing philosophy is the way to approach it
 
Bang on! I don't want a 3/4 week period fucking about interviewing folk and making a 'carefully considered decision' whilst the players battle on weary of the future under a caretaker - who would that even be for that matter? Snodin would probably go with Grayson, whilst I wouldn't want Thompson near it and hope he'd go with Grayson also if that's what transpired.

It's harsh but all that shit should be done in secret whilst the current manager is still in place on the basis that the change could take place at any given moment, should things not improve under the existing manager.

Harsh and unfair on the existing manager? Yes it dam well is. Welcome to 21st century Football management.

Good post.

Either SG has to get the players to do much, much better playing to his current strategy of trying to be hard to beat or he has to adopt a different, hopefully more positive strategy of playing with some urgency from the start of the match and trying to actually create some decent chances and score goals.

Unless we see some major improvement very soon then he'll be under real pressure to keep his job.

Football is a ruthless, results based business and he knows that and he'll be concerned that the powers that be will already be considering who the next manager should be.
 
Backing him 100%

We all knew the challenges but I must admit I've underestimated the impact of the inequality of finances. With the new FFP rules and parachute payments it means so much more.
That said we could have had more impact. Sneaked a couple of wins before anyone realised what we are about. Converting home draws to wins. Being without Beckford and Galagher has been a serious blow. Gallagher's contribution Cannot be underestimated in terms of us being successful within our remit over the last couple of seasons. Ask Garner if he misses him. I make direct reference to Joe's first of three V Swindon at home last year and Gally's 20 minute cameo at Wembley as examples. Beckford was immense at the end of last season and played the major part in play off success and promotion. SG is instrumental for him. So I've not enjoyed it so far but recognise our constraints. Better times I hope lie ahead once we establish our best 11 which will take more time. SG will improve the signings he has made. I hope for 20+ points by Xmas and a big push for points in the new year. Has there been a game yet where we have been completely outclassed? even V Derby we were the thickness of a post from a point. Anyway the championship experience hasn't been great so far but I'm not ready to swap it for an afternoon at Bury even though we make up most the crowd. Craven cottage appeals far more. COYW.
 
Back
Top