Skip to main content

Grayson, back or sack?

Grayson, back or sack?

Poll Poll Grayson, back or sack?

  • Back

    Votes: 176 82.6%
  • Sack

    Votes: 37 17.4%

  • Total voters
    213
Backing Grayson.. recent results have gone against us, he has lost both Gallagher and Beckford both influential players from last season, garner has been misfiring too. Grayson has had to introduce new players this year such as reach, may, doyle , keane, vermaji, McCarthy and I think it will take time to get them to gel. A few wins would help Grayson tho
 
Or the strikers haven't had time to get to know the team's game, tactics and whereabouts yet.

As a small club in the Championship you will only have 2-3 players to rely on, even the big teams only have 2-3 players to rely on, thats football.

Tactics for a striker-------------- Bloody shoot.
 
Totally agree. In fact, I wouldn't even interview people. Sound out the man we want, ring him up and invite him in to talk contracts. The interview process gets you talkers, looking at a track record and a footballing philosophy is the way to approach it


That's the one........ And if you haven't got that strategy in place then there's no point bothering.
 
Just watched the highlights from yesterday and my god Sheffield Wednesday tore our defenders a new asshole. They were absolutely woeful. Tom Clarke is not good enough and no where near captain material. I'm 50/50 on wether he should be sacked or backed because that looked worse and worse! Things have to change but it just goes to prove a couple quick and sharp passing movements open a sink hole in our defense.
 
Grayson, back or sack?

Out of interest does anyone know SG entire manager stats difference as a L1 manager compared To being Championship manager , if not does anyone know where I can find that stat? Just curious on what is his win %
Is as a L1 manager compared to a Championship manager is ?
 
Out of interest does anyone know SG entire manager stats difference as a L1 manager compared To being Championship manager , if not does anyone know where I can find that stat? Just curious on what is his win %
Is as a L1 manager compared to a Championship manager is ?

Well last season he had a 50% win ratio (may be over 2 seasons)

I don't really care about other clubs but if you look at his record this season for us that will be his win% for us in championship, similarly check out what Blackpool managed in their first season back, roughly their win% as he left towards the end I think? For Leeds who are the only team he has done 'well' with at this level, but remember they had Howson, Johnson, Beckford and a couple others that went on to play prem football (so not a bad team at all).
 
Just watched the highlights from yesterday and my god Sheffield Wednesday tore our defenders a new asshole. They were absolutely woeful. Tom Clarke is not good enough and no where near captain material. I'm 50/50 on wether he should be sacked or backed because that looked worse and worse! Things have to change but it just goes to prove a couple quick and sharp passing movements open a sink hole in our defense.

I said last season that Clarke gets away with a lot from the fans simply because he scored against Blackpoo.

He is a decent L1 player, no problems there but he struggles on the turn and is very quiet - it seems to me - vocally for a Captain. Just my observations.

Yes, I accept he has been played out of position to a degree at RB. The manager has to take the majority of the blame here.

Basically, we require a CB with pace who can also turn with ease when faced with a quick striker taking the diagonal ball on. Take Derbys 1st goal as a Deepdale example. The ball cut diagonally straight across the defence and BOOM!, we go 1 down. Great goal.

Some players are too comfy in the 1st XI knowing that there is nobody outside the XI to challenge them.

All about opinions, some will agree, some won't. That's debate for you.
 
I said last season that Clarke gets away with a lot from the fans simply because he scored against Blackpoo.

He is a decent L1 player, no problems there but he struggles on the turn and is very quiet - it seems to me - vocally for a Captain. Just my observations.

Yes, I accept he has been played out of position to a degree at RB. The manager has to take the majority of the blame here.

Basically, we require a CB with pace who can also turn with ease when faced with a quick striker taking the diagonal ball on. Take Derbys 1st goal as a Deepdale example. The ball cut diagonally straight across the defence and BOOM!, we go 1 down. Great goal.

Some players are too comfy in the 1st XI knowing that there is nobody outside the XI to challenge them.

All about opinions, some will agree, some won't. That's debate for you.

Totally agree. We needed to get a new centre half that would push these guys. Clarke isn't really skipper material either as isn't vocal enough...
 
Backing him 100%

We all knew the challenges but I must admit I've underestimated the impact of the inequality of finances. With the new FFP rules and parachute payments it means so much more.
That said we could have had more impact. Sneaked a couple of wins before anyone realised what we are about. Converting home draws to wins. Being without Beckford and Galagher has been a serious blow. Gallagher's contribution Cannot be underestimated in terms of us being successful within our remit over the last couple of seasons. Ask Garner if he misses him. I make direct reference to Joe's first of three V Swindon at home last year and Gally's 20 minute cameo at Wembley as examples. Beckford was immense at the end of last season and played the major part in play off success and promotion. SG is instrumental for him. So I've not enjoyed it so far but recognise our constraints. Better times I hope lie ahead once we establish our best 11 which will take more time. SG will improve the signings he has made. I hope for 20+ points by Xmas and a big push for points in the new year. Has there been a game yet where we have been completely outclassed? even V Derby we were the thickness of a post from a point. Anyway the championship experience hasn't been great so far but I'm not ready to swap it for an afternoon at Bury even though we make up most the crowd. Craven cottage appeals far more. COYW.

The way it is looking at this moment in time there is a chance that we could be swapping places with Bury next season (shudder!) .. I am optimistic that our results will improve though. There has been recent signs that the penny has dropped with Grayson & he realises that we have to have a go at teams (especially at home) to get results. Unfortunately, the penny dropping has coincided with injuries to key players, a particualr diabolical refereeing display & the subsequent suspensions. Hopefully Grayson will have the luxury of a near first choice 11 on the pitch shortly with good options on the bench. He needs key players back firing & soon. The next 4 results are crucial I feel. If it goes wrong & we are looking like we are being cast adrift then the panic button may be pressed. A defining few weeks ahead
 
I said last season that Clarke gets away with a lot from the fans simply because he scored against Blackpoo.

He is a decent L1 player, no problems there but he struggles on the turn and is very quiet - it seems to me - vocally for a Captain. Just my observations.

Yes, I accept he has been played out of position to a degree at RB. The manager has to take the majority of the blame here.

Basically, we require a CB with pace who can also turn with ease when faced with a quick striker taking the diagonal ball on. Take Derbys 1st goal as a Deepdale example. The ball cut diagonally straight across the defence and BOOM!, we go 1 down. Great goal.

Some players are too comfy in the 1st XI knowing that there is nobody outside the XI to challenge them.

All about opinions, some will agree, some won't. That's debate for you.

I think Tom Clarke and Bailey Wright are the best CB pairing we could have in the Championship, Huntington was class last season but he is a good L1 defender and that is it, he has been suspect to much this season and Grayson can't be afraid to drop him even though he gave him a new 2 year contract.

The problem with our defence is the RB slot, Vermijl has been crap, Clarke is not good enough at RB for the Championship and Woods inconsistent.

The missed signing of Darikwa, suspension to Wright, injury to Huntington, injury to Mcarthy and poor showing of Vermijl has led to a major disruption in our always present back line that made up very difficult to break down last season.

We need to get a settled back 4 ASAP and stick with it, top of my shopping list in January would be an accomplished Championship or up and coming league 1 RB. This allows us to ditch the 3 at the back formation and go with a more attacking 4-4-2 or 4-3-3.

From now on my back 4 would be Woods - Clarke - Wright - Cunningham and stick with it.

The midfield and forwards sort of pick themselves.
 
Back, all day long.

After seeing various managers come and go whilst we dropped into League 1 and stayed there for quite some time, he is the man that came along and got us out of there. Whilst football is not a sentimental sport, he at least deserves credit for what he did.

These injuries and suspensions have proper done us over it seems. I like a bit of stability, so I would say let him get on with it until January. I have faith in him, and I still believe that we will at least stay up.

Grayson in! COYW!
 
I said last season that Clarke gets away with a lot from the fans simply because he scored against Blackpoo.

He is a decent L1 player, no problems there but he struggles on the turn and is very quiet - it seems to me - vocally for a Captain. Just my observations.

Yes, I accept he has been played out of position to a degree at RB. The manager has to take the majority of the blame here.

Basically, we require a CB with pace who can also turn with ease when faced with a quick striker taking the diagonal ball on. Take Derbys 1st goal as a Deepdale example. The ball cut diagonally straight across the defence and BOOM!, we go 1 down. Great goal.

Some players are too comfy in the 1st XI knowing that there is nobody outside the XI to challenge them.

All about opinions, some will agree, some won't. That's debate for you.

Our defence wasn't exactly the speediest in League One, and now that is being exposed more now we're in the Championship. Once all the CBs are fit we'll finally have competition in that area so nobody will be safe if they have a few bad games.


The problem with our defence is the RB slot, Vermijl has been crap, Clarke is not good enough at RB for the Championship and Woods inconsistent.

+1

Once all the CBs are fit we'll be fine in that area imo, the issue lays at right back. Woods is alright but is also, as you say, inconsistent, and pretty injury prone as well. He seems to pick up quite a few muscle injuries.

One of the priorities in the January window, regardless of who the manager is then, has to be bringing a solid RB to the club on a permanent basis. No more messing around, just get the position sorted out for good.
 
Last edited:
IFrom now on my back 4 would be Woods - Clarke - Wright - Cunningham and stick with it.

The midfield and forwards sort of pick themselves.

Agree with what you say about the defence and slowly but surely the core of the midfield is beginning establish itself as Browne, Welsh and Johnson though I am increasingly uncertain that Welsh is up to what is required in this division - a replacement may be required come the January window, possibly loan system obliging beforehand. That leaves three places of which one surely has to be Gallagher playing a free role in support of two strikers of whom one has to be Garner with the leading candidates for the other place being at the moment Hugill and Doyle.

The new lad Reach is an option for broadening things out though not at the expense of either one of the strikers or the main holding midfielder - could he be a wide player in a 4.3.3. As for the three at the back formation it may still have its uses on occasion - when Humphrey and Cunningham will be the wing-backs though maybe Browne might be an option - but for the most part we have to attack. Sitting back in this division can too often mean asking for trouble.
 
Back, all day long.

After seeing various managers come and go whilst we dropped into League 1 and stayed there for quite some time, he is the man that came along and got us out of there. Whilst football is not a sentimental sport, he at least deserves credit for what he did.

These injuries and suspensions have proper done us over it seems. I like a bit of stability, so I would say let him get on with it until January. I have faith in him, and I still believe that we will at least stay up.

Grayson in! COYW!

Totally agree with this. I know the saying "make your own luck" but how the hell do you make any when a defender gets injured after 8 minutes of a debut? When you have a referee hell bent on getting one over on you? When your star striker is injured for months before a league game ball has been kicked? When you best goal provider is injured for several weeks? There is only so much of your own luck you can make when events conspire against you.
 
Pickford

Woods
Clarke
hunts
Cunningham

Browne

Gally
Johnson
Reach

Garner
Doyle

I would go with this, maybe the only change being Welsh, who can tackle, for Browne.

Obviously, the front 2, for differing reasons, cannot play v Cardiff so it would be Hugill and May for the Big Man / Little Man partnership.
 
Chose Browne as he can pass as well and is energetic

Yes, it'a a trickey call.

Youth v Old Head
Innocence v Experience
Passing v Tackling

Someone combining Youth, Experience, Passing, Tackling would fit the bill.
 
Back
Top