Skip to main content

Grimshaw

Grimshaw

Grimshaw is not being well received by the Chesterfield fans, some comments below from their defeat last Saturday

"Grimshaw is shocking. If he had put away the sitter at 1-0 - our only chance in second half - we might have won"

"Grimshaw wide right of a three looked completely awful"

"As for Grimshaw, he's a poor man's Jordan Henderson. Runs around a lot, hit's square balls, but when a bit of quality is needed he falls short whether it's a shot or a pass"

"Grimshaw not good enough"

"Gardner, Grimshaw, Brown were all poor whilst on the pitch"

"Grimshaw is such a poor player. He adds absolutely nothing to the team at all"

"He's been the biggest disappointment for me. At best he is a poor man's Dereck Niven. Expected a lot more from him"

"You shouldn't even mention the words "Grimshaw" and "Niven" in the same sentence. When Derek was fully fit, and when he came on loan, he showed far more enthusiasm, work effic, pace, pride etc than the likes of Grimshaw and Brown"

I don't think it's fair to group Grimshaw with Brown. I wouldn't have faulted Grimshaw's enthusiasm, stamina, even bravery. I'd have faulted his skill set.

Not many comments after the draw at Millwall in midweek as they only took 80 supporters, but one who posted had this to say

"Grimshaw and Gardner, well the less said the better - two extremely poor players who worked hard but just lack distinct quality".

I hope for the lads sake, its just a lack of confidence playing in a poor team, managed by what their fans think is clueless manager.

That said, I work with Grimshaw's brothers best mate and he is not enjoying his time at North End. He wanted to stay at Motherwell, but Man United wanted a fee and Motherwell couldn't/wouldn't pay it.

Hope he can turn it around as he is still only young.
Oh dear. That doesn't look good at all. Gutted for the lad. Let's hope the negative reactions are because a struggling side's supporters were simply expecting someone to come straight in and transform their team and so were a bit blinkered as to what they were expecting.
But our scouts must have seen something in him. I get the feeling he will end up like Ben Davies. Regularly sent out on loan and dividing fan's opinions about whether he has the quality or not.
 
Oh dear. That doesn't look good at all. Gutted for the lad. Let's hope the negative reactions are because a struggling side's supporters were simply expecting someone to come straight in and transform their team and so were a bit blinkered as to what they were expecting.
But our scouts must have seen something in him. I get the feeling he will end up like Ben Davies. Regularly sent out on loan and dividing fan's opinions about whether he has the quality or not.

Doesn't look good but I remember Tranmere fans absolutely slating Hugill. He then went direct to Hartlepool and became a hero.
 
Doesn't look good but I remember Tranmere fans absolutely slating Hugill. He then went direct to Hartlepool and became a hero.

Yes and most Bristol City's fans views of Callum Robinson and the Barnsley fans who thought Pearson was average.

I'd take some positives from this comment "I wouldn't have faulted Grimshaw's enthusiasm, stamina, even bravery. I'd have faulted his skill set" tells me he could be a good holding, ball winning midfielder, sat in front of the back four who can break up play, a bit like a John Welsh. Perhaps some work needed on his distributuion.
 
All i'm getting from this is the fact we've got some quality midfield options; Pearson, Gallagher, Johnson, Browne, Welsh... no surprise Grimshaw has struggled to get a look in with his lack of experience.

Ben Pringle is the one that concerns me as I bet he's a decent earner.

He has to go mate. The way we are we can't have dross draining cash. Beckford and him have to be taken off the books. Hope Simon can sort it.
 
Oh dear. That doesn't look good at all. Gutted for the lad. Let's hope the negative reactions are because a struggling side's supporters were simply expecting someone to come straight in and transform their team and so were a bit blinkered as to what they were expecting.
But our scouts must have seen something in him. I get the feeling he will end up like Ben Davies. Regularly sent out on loan and dividing fan's opinions about whether he has the quality or not.

Not sure how anyone but the coaching staff can have an opinion on Grimshaw yet, positive or negative.

People should always be given a fair chance before we stick the boot in.
 
At least handful of games in his specialist position would probably be a decent starting point!

Remembering that we've had a few young players who didn't show so much in their early days (Macken for example).

He can only do that if he's good enough to get in on merit. Look I know what you're all saying seriously very loyal supporters Preston North Enders, I'm feeling a bit more ruthless 🙂 bit of a hoarding mentally isn't it it's probably better we keep him than let him go and he turn out to be good but realistically what are the chances of that? And why give any special treatment to him? For me if he ain't done owt by now I'd be inclined to shift on an get a new prospect in. Easier said than done granted, but free some wages up, I think we're 2/3 first team singings from a serious crack at promotion.

Grimshaw, Pringle, Beckford, lindgard do not feature in that future.
 
🙂
Is 15months enough?

Or do we give the lad another 15months draining cash on the off chance he might turn into a beast?

In all seriousness, it's a tough one, he's not had a run of games long enough in either side especially in a weak chesterfield side. So I think stick without more than 10 games under his belt even from the chesterfield lot is a bit harsh. But I do understand that a wage is a wage I'd like to see how things pan out for him the rest of the season with them and then another preseason with us where he comes in injury free instead of that niggle he had when we bought him.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
He's clearly not had a proper crack at it here yet but those comments are worryingly bad, and unanimous too. Imho he's been on the back foot right from the start because of the injury when he signed.

All i'm getting from this is the fact we've got some quality midfield options; Pearson, Gallagher, Johnson, Browne, Welsh... no surprise Grimshaw has struggled to get a look in with his lack of experience.

Ben Pringle is the one that concerns me as I bet he's a decent earner.

I think I would probably still sign a central midfielder in the summer. Gallagher is unavailable more frequently now with injuries and Welsh's injury has turned out to be a real shocker. Pringle is really poor too and as you say he's probably on decent money, needs offloading in the summer along with Lindegaard, Beckford, Doyle etc.
 
To go along with those forum comments from Chesterfield fans, some of their comments on Twitter are very, very bad too.

It's hard to see at this point how he will ever make it as a first teamer at PNE.
 
To go along with those forum comments from Chesterfield fans, some of their comments on Twitter are very, very bad too.

It's hard to see at this point how he will ever make it as a first teamer at PNE.

Noted the same.

From the very limited time i have seen of him he appears to lack basic football intelligence. A bit like Walcott, who is just sprinter in football boots. I do not believe this lad will play first team football at PNE.
 
Noted the same.

From the very limited time i have seen of him he appears to lack basic football intelligence. A bit like Walcott, who is just sprinter in football boots. I do not believe this lad will play first team football at PNE.

Well let's hope you're as wrong about Grimshaw as you were about Pearson.
 
Noted the same.

From the very limited time i have seen of him he appears to lack basic football intelligence. A bit like Walcott, who is just sprinter in football boots. I do not believe this lad will play first team football at PNE.

Pardon me, but I think your judgement on central midfielders seems to be a little bit skewed towards the "shit" side of the spectrum after seeing how Pearson turned out.

Also noted about your very limited time having seen him, I don't think that is any indication as to his quality. Andy Little looked like an alright player for about 3 or 4 games.

I'm not saying at all that Grimshaw will be as good as Pearson - virtually impossible due to the quality that Pearson has - but we should at least give him a chance before deciding for him and the club that he isn't good enough.
 
Pardon me, but I think your judgement on central midfielders seems to be a little bit skewed towards the "shit" side of the spectrum after seeing how Pearson turned out.

Also noted about your very limited time having seen him, I don't think that is any indication as to his quality. Andy Little looked like an alright player for about 3 or 4 games.

I'm not saying at all that Grimshaw will be as good as Pearson - virtually impossible due to the quality that Pearson has - but we should at least give him a chance before deciding for him and the club that he isn't good enough.

Why give anyone a chance with a track record like his?
What's the point?
Christ do we wait for another year+ until he has a stormer in a meaningless EFL cup game so you can come on here and say na na na told you so?

Pne player hoarders... Keep em 'just in case'

Fuck that mate, were on the cusp of havin a decent chance next season and lads like grimshaw, nothing personal grimshaw, you're sucking up a wage which we need to strengthen pne for the push.

UTWs
 
Why give anyone a chance with a track record like his?
What's the point?
Christ do we wait for another year+ until he has a stormer in a meaningless EFL cup game so you can come on here and say na na na told you so?

Pne player hoarders... Keep em 'just in case'

Fuck that mate, were on the cusp of havin a decent chance next season and lads like grimshaw, nothing personal grimshaw, you're sucking up a wage which we need to strengthen pne for the push.

UTWs
He's only 22, there's scope for him to improve.

We can't afford to buy the finished article at Steve Bruce prices for any "push", we need to have patience and some nous instead.

This approach has got us to "the cusp of having a decent chance next season", so it isn't all bad news.

Grimshaw won't be on a high wage, he's out on loan, getting games, doing no harm to our results - so why worry?
 
He's only 22, there's scope for him to improve.

We can't afford to buy the finished article at Steve Bruce prices for any "push", we need to have patience and some nous instead.

This approach has got us to "the cusp of having a decent chance next season", so it isn't all bad news.

Grimshaw won't be on a high wage, he's out on loan, getting games, doing no harm to our results - so why worry?

You don't captain Man U at youth level if you haven't got something about you.

Not given up on Grimmy yet.
 
Why give anyone a chance with a track record like his?
What's the point?
Christ do we wait for another year+ until he has a stormer in a meaningless EFL cup game so you can come on here and say na na na told you so?

Pne player hoarders... Keep em 'just in case'

Fuck that mate, were on the cusp of havin a decent chance next season and lads like grimshaw, nothing personal grimshaw, you're sucking up a wage which we need to strengthen pne for the push.

UTWs

Not being funny mate, but he's only played 5 times for us in the league, and none of them were in his preferred position, some at RWB where he is obviously a square peg in a round hole, and only once in midfield in a cup match where we played a second string and it became about damage limitation after a sending off after half an hour against the best side in the league. To say that counts as a track record is laughable.

Are you going to describe him as the worst midfielder we've had since Ian Ashbee if he doesn't play like N'Golo Kante in every single match or something? Or shall we wait until he actually plays in midfield to judge him?

He's 22, comes with a good reputation, captained United at the highest youth level in a position we aren't exactly spoilt for choice in at CDM... as far as I'm aware, that makes him the kind of player we should be taking chances on given the way we've gotten to where we are today!

Give the lad time rather than deciding he's utter shite after 5 games. Pearson and Garner took about half a season to properly get going here when they first joined and Hugill took about 2 years, whereas Johnson and Gallagher hit the ground running. Some players take longer than others to settle in and I still feel he has something to offer if given the time.
 
Back
Top