Skip to main content

Grimshaw

Grimshaw

Not being funny mate, but he's only played 5 times for us in the league, and none of them were in his preferred position, some at RWB where he is obviously a square peg in a round hole, and only once in midfield in a cup match where we played a second string and it became about damage limitation after a sending off after half an hour against the best side in the league. To say that counts as a track record is laughable.

Are you going to describe him as the worst midfielder we've had since Ian Ashbee if he doesn't play like N'Golo Kante in every single match or something? Or shall we wait until he actually plays in midfield to judge him?

He's 22, comes with a good reputation, captained United at the highest youth level in a position we aren't exactly spoilt for choice in at CDM... as far as I'm aware, that makes him the kind of player we should be taking chances on given the way we've gotten to where we are today!

Give the lad time rather than deciding he's utter shite after 5 games. Pearson and Garner took about half a season to properly get going here when they first joined and Hugill took about 2 years, whereas Johnson and Gallagher hit the ground running. Some players take longer than others to settle in and I still feel he has something to offer if given the time.


Totally agree, and even referring to this current Chesterfield team that he's playing in who are most likely going to be relegated I think it's unfair to judge him after such little game time and like you said apart from 1 run in the team in his preferred position in a damage limitation game. I have faith he will come good, another pre-season under his belt when he's fit could do him the world of good, look at Pearson!
 
Not being funny mate, but he's only played 5 times for us in the league, and none of them were in his preferred position, some at RWB where he is obviously a square peg in a round hole, and only once in midfield in a cup match where we played a second string and it became about damage limitation after a sending off after half an hour against the best side in the league. To say that counts as a track record is laughable.

Are you going to describe him as the worst midfielder we've had since Ian Ashbee if he doesn't play like N'Golo Kante in every single match or something? Or shall we wait until he actually plays in midfield to judge him?

He's 22, comes with a good reputation, captained United at the highest youth level in a position we aren't exactly spoilt for choice in at CDM... as far as I'm aware, that makes him the kind of player we should be taking chances on given the way we've gotten to where we are today!

Give the lad time rather than deciding he's utter shite after 5 games. Pearson and Garner took about half a season to properly get going here when they first joined and Hugill took about 2 years, whereas Johnson and Gallagher hit the ground running. Some players take longer than others to settle in and I still feel he has something to offer if given the time.

Spot on, as a Championship club we're afforded the luxury of being able to develop players rather than throw them in the deep end.

Clubs like Brighton have development teams, 'carrying' around 20 Liam Grimshaws.
 
Why give anyone a chance with a track record like his?
What's the point?
Christ do we wait for another year+ until he has a stormer in a meaningless EFL cup game so you can come on here and say na na na told you so?

Pne player hoarders... Keep em 'just in case'

Fuck that mate, were on the cusp of havin a decent chance next season and lads like grimshaw, nothing personal grimshaw, you're sucking up a wage which we need to strengthen pne for the push.

UTWs

Whether Grimshaw will ever be good enough is up for debate. He looked very poor at the start of the season (yes, at right back, but wasn't he meant to be comfortable in that role ?) and the comments from Chesterfield supporters are worryingly bad.

However I don't think wages come into it to be honest, because he won't be on much.

The ones "sucking up a wage" are the likes of Beckford, Doyle, Pringle and Lindegaard who will all be on a decent wedge per week and contribute next to nothing. The same applies to May too although the injury has been a factor in that.

So whether you think the likes of Grimshaw and Ben Davies are good enough is up to you, but it's other non-contributers that we should worry about in terms of wages.
 
The only question I have is this.

Who do you realistically see him replacing / being better than, in the current midfield?

This, for me, is the key issue.

Pearson, DJ, Browne, Gally and probably Welsh are ahead of him. All are under contract next season. His final year (2018-19), which will coincidence will Welsh being on a Free in 2018, will be massive for the lad. His best bet I feel will be if either, or both (and I hope they aren't) DJ and Pearson are sold.

Even then, I suspect that SG would go out and buy a quality replacement who could slot straight in. I am trying to view this in a realistic manner rather than dissing the lad.

Sometimes, the competition, as it currently is here, is just too strong and you only have 6 outfield Subs which cover a multitude of positions which limits your options even further.

I can see him out on Loan for a full season next August.
 
Whether Grimshaw will ever be good enough is up for debate. He looked very poor at the start of the season (yes, at right back, but wasn't he meant to be comfortable in that role ?) and the comments from Chesterfield supporters are worryingly bad.

However I don't think wages come into it to be honest, because he won't be on much.

The ones "sucking up a wage" are the likes of Beckford, Doyle, Pringle and Lindegaard who will all be on a decent wedge per week and contribute next to nothing. The same applies to May too although the injury has been a factor in that.

So whether you think the likes of Grimshaw and Ben Davies are good enough is up to you, but it's other non-contributers that we should worry about in terms of wages.

100% correct on the 4 players you mentioned.

Allowing 2 to leave on Frees whilst hopefully offloading the other 2 (who still have 2 years left on their contracts ffs) is the way to go to free up both space in the squad and funds.

Quality, not quantity in the summer and I feel we will be right in the top end mix next season.
 
100% correct on the 4 players you mentioned.

Allowing 2 to leave on Frees whilst hopefully offloading the other 2 (who still have 2 years left on their contracts ffs) is the way to go to free up both space in the squad and funds.

Quality, not quantity in the summer and I feel we will be right in the top end mix next season.

Agree, we need 4-5 good new faces in then hold on to most of what we have. A few good loans and a couple of smart buys and we can continue to improve.

By all accounts, Lindegaard is on quite a hefty wage, especially for someone who's ended up as no.2. We need a more cost effective option as competition for Maxwell.

Doyle and Beckford out, a couple of strikers in. Pringle can just go without any sort of 'replacement'. He doesn't fit into this squad at all and is a League 1 player. Nobody even knows what his best position is.

After the uncertainty at right back all season, and Woods returning from an awful injury, I would probably sign another. Don't really rate Vermijl and don't think Browning will be here next season, Baptiste might be though which would be good. What a faff that position has been all season covering with loans and etc. Can't legislate for the amount of injuries we've had in that area.

Wouldn't be against another quality CM although I don't see it as a requirement, especially now we are playing 4-4-2 most weeks and only playing 2 in the middle as oppose to 3 central midfielders for most of last season.
 
Agree, we need 4-5 good new faces in then hold on to most of what we have. A few good loans and a couple of smart buys and we can continue to improve.

By all accounts, Lindegaard is on quite a hefty wage, especially for someone who's ended up as no.2. We need a more cost effective option as competition for Maxwell.

Doyle and Beckford out, a couple of strikers in. Pringle can just go without any sort of 'replacement'. He doesn't fit into this squad at all and is a League 1 player. Nobody even knows what his best position is.

After the uncertainty at right back all season, and Woods returning from an awful injury, I would probably sign another. Don't really rate Vermijl and don't think Browning will be here next season, Baptiste might be though which would be good. What a faff that position has been all season covering with loans and etc. Can't legislate for the amount of injuries we've had in that area.

Wouldn't be against another quality CM although I don't see it as a requirement, especially now we are playing 4-4-2 most weeks and only playing 2 in the middle as oppose to 3 central midfielders for most of last season.

Get rid -

Doyle
Makienok
Beckford
Lindegaard
Browning

Possible Signings -

Mclaughin - Permanent
Armstrong - Loan
Baptiste - Permanent
 
Get rid -

Doyle
Makienok
Beckford
Lindegaard
Browning

Possible Signings -

Mclaughin - Permanent
Armstrong - Loan
Baptiste - Permanent

Wouldn't be totally against Makienok staying in some capacity personally. Probably won't play regularly because of the type of player he is but when he had a run of games he started scoring and defenders struggled to handle him. I understand big lanky forwards like him divide opinion though.
 
The only question I have is this.

Who do you realistically see him replacing / being better than, in the current midfield?

This, for me, is the key issue.

Pearson, DJ, Browne, Gally and probably Welsh are ahead of him. All are under contract next season. His final year (2018-19), which will coincidence will Welsh being on a Free in 2018, will be massive for the lad. His best bet I feel will be if either, or both (and I hope they aren't) DJ and Pearson are sold.

Even then, I suspect that SG would go out and buy a quality replacement who could slot straight in. I am trying to view this in a realistic manner rather than dissing the lad.

Sometimes, the competition, as it currently is here, is just too strong and you only have 6 outfield Subs which cover a multitude of positions which limits your options even further.

I can see him out on Loan for a full season next August.

agree with this !

If what I have read on here about him not being happy at PNE as he wanted to stay at Motherwell , sending him out into a relegation battle is a throw of the dice to possibly say "look how good you have it here" a total guess but his attitude in training and in and around the club might not be great , this may just kick him into a different attitude when he comes back (looks like it worked with Jordan) All admitted a complete guess as he might have a great attitude , seemed a bit rough to send him in the deep end at Chesterfield if this is the case.

If he is loaned out next year hopefully it will be to a club that plays football on the floor and not in a relegation fight.
 
Wouldn't be totally against Makienok staying in some capacity personally. Probably won't play regularly because of the type of player he is but when he had a run of games he started scoring and defenders struggled to handle him. I understand big lanky forwards like him divide opinion though.

Exactly, Makienok is our second most effective striker this season behind only Hugill and to reward that with a "get rid" is harsh IMO. I also feel that Browning is worth another look next season but obviously it's still early days and with his injury it's difficult to gauge him just yet, but Pringle should be on the list to go - I wouldn't be surprised if he went back to Rotherham.
 
Exactly, Makienok is our second most effective striker this season behind only Hugill and to reward that with a "get rid" is harsh IMO. I also feel that Browning is worth another look next season but obviously it's still early days and with his injury it's difficult to gauge him just yet, but Pringle should be on the list to go - I wouldn't be surprised if he went back to Rotherham.

Apparently Swansea are looking at Browning......could be nonsense though - http://www.hitc.com/en-gb/2017/02/2...tracking-prestons-on-loan-everton-defender-t/

Good shout about Pringle to Rotherham. Could see him dropping back to League 1 to rejoin them.
 
Get rid -

Doyle
Makienok
Beckford
Lindegaard
Browning

Possible Signings -

Mclaughin - Permanent
Armstrong - Loan
Baptiste - Permanent

You'd keep Pringle? The one who can't even get on the bench and even when he did, it was obviously just to make the numbers up as Grayson didn't rate him enough (correctly) to even bring him on.

Waste of a 3 year contract.

Get Rid.
 
agree with this !

If what I have read on here about him not being happy at PNE as he wanted to stay at Motherwell , sending him out into a relegation battle is a throw of the dice to possibly say "look how good you have it here" a total guess but his attitude in training and in and around the club might not be great , this may just kick him into a different attitude when he comes back (looks like it worked with Jordan) All admitted a complete guess as he might have a great attitude , seemed a bit rough to send him in the deep end at Chesterfield if this is the case.

If he is loaned out next year hopefully it will be to a club that plays football on the floor and not in a relegation fight.

I did see him at Preston train station this summer before the squad went down to QPR away and the thing I noticed was that he was isolated from the squad - other new lads like Spurr, Pringle and Makienok were really relaxed and messing about with our more established players, but Grimshaw was on the train ASAP, on his phone, not interested. Even then he didn't look happy, and the story about him not enjoying his time here so far doesn't surprise me.
 
Exactly, Makienok is our second most effective striker this season behind only Hugill and to reward that with a "get rid" is harsh IMO. I also feel that Browning is worth another look next season but obviously it's still early days and with his injury it's difficult to gauge him just yet, but Pringle should be on the list to go - I wouldn't be surprised if he went back to Rotherham.

Makienok? 2nd most effective? I think Robinson might disagree with you here.

Makienok has scored in just 4 games, yes I realised his game time post Xmas has been limited but ask yourself why?

Whilst he has some plus points, I don't think he has enough plus points to justify the probable expensive outlay. We can and must do better. Just my opinion.

Browning I like what I have seen to date. A loan next season gets the Thumbs Up from me.
 
Exactly, Makienok is our second most effective striker this season behind only Hugill and to reward that with a "get rid" is harsh IMO. I also feel that Browning is worth another look next season but obviously it's still early days and with his injury it's difficult to gauge him just yet, but Pringle should be on the list to go - I wouldn't be surprised if he went back to Rotherham.

Robinson is our second most effective striker. He's only two goals behind Hugill.
 
Makienok? 2nd most effective? I think Robinson might disagree with you here.

Makienok has scored in just 4 games, yes I realised his game time post Xmas has been limited but ask yourself why?

Whilst he has some plus points, I don't think he has enough plus points to justify the probable expensive outlay. We can and must do better. Just my opinion.

Browning I like what I have seen to date. A loan next season gets the Thumbs Up from me.
Robinson is our second most effective striker. He's only two goals behind Hugill.

Robinson isn't a striker for me, he's a winger who can play up front. But I can see where you're both coming from since he's been played up front.

Makienok isn't all about the goals, he's very much a battering ram due to his size and I can understand why you've said he isn't worth keeping on - players like him split opinions - but for me he's a useful asset when we're under pressure or in a tough game and we need someone to give the oppositions CBs a tough game.
 
From what we've seen so far, Grimshaw is pretty average. However:

- When he first played, Garner wasnt banging the ball in regularly and was being written off
- When he first played, Pearson wasnt performing well at all and was being written off
- When he first played, Vermaijl wasnt doing too well and was being written off

Point being, let Grayson be the judge on if they are good enough. By and large, he's got them right so far in a strong 4 years for the club. If Grimshaw has a good pre-season then who knows, maybe he will step up to the plate. If not, I'm sure the club will act accordingly and agree a sale that suits all parties.

Of all the experts on the forum, how many have actually been successful football league managers
 
From what we've seen so far, Grimshaw is pretty average. However:

- When he first played, Garner wasnt banging the ball in regularly and was being written off
- When he first played, Pearson wasnt performing well at all and was being written off
- When he first played, Vermaijl wasnt doing too well and was being written off

Point being, let Grayson be the judge on if they are good enough. By and large, he's got them right so far in a strong 4 years for the club. If Grimshaw has a good pre-season then who knows, maybe he will step up to the plate. If not, I'm sure the club will act accordingly and agree a sale that suits all parties.

Of all the experts on the forum, how many have actually been successful football league managers

Me ��

If you have to be a successful manager to comment on a message board it would be a quiet place.

All this is well and good but we ain't Brighton fof Christ's sake, and thank the Lord for that!
Grimshaw isn't Joe garner or Pearson cause they both delivered, not after 16 months of no output but after a few months of trying.

My opinion is you're all hoarders and scared he might do something somewhere else. Well. My opinion is that's bollox cause he ain't up to it, that opinion is based on his clear lack of output.

Josh brownhiill got the same rants on here this time last year, gone to Bristol and done sod all of any note.

Slim the squad down, free up the wage quality not quantity as a poster said before. We are so so so so close to doing it its time we realised it. Genuinely this era has one last go at this before our assets are poached and that goes for Grayson also. We need 3/4 more first team starters and we can do it and go up properly!

UTWs
 
Me ��

If you have to be a successful manager to comment on a message board it would be a quiet place.

All this is well and good but we ain't Brighton fof Christ's sake, and thank the Lord for that!
Grimshaw isn't Joe garner or Pearson cause they both delivered, not after 16 months of no output but after a few months of trying.

My opinion is you're all hoarders and scared he might do something somewhere else. Well. My opinion is that's bollox cause he ain't up to it, that opinion is based on his clear lack of output.

Josh brownhiill got the same rants on here this time last year, gone to Bristol and done sod all of any note.

Slim the squad down, free up the wage quality not quantity as a poster said before. We are so so so so close to doing it its time we realised it. Genuinely this era has one last go at this before our assets are poached and that goes for Grayson also. We need 3/4 more first team starters and we can do it and go up properly!

UTWs

So your opinion is that because one of our other young midfielders got moved on and hasn't done anything we should get rid of anyone in the squad who doesn't play every week?

That might be a generalisation, but there shouldn't be any problems with that since you just made one about everyone who wants to keep Grimshaw being a hoarder.

I'm honestly not scared he might do something somewhere else. My opinion is that I want to see him more in his preferred position before making my mind up rather than people like you who want him gone because you've seen him twice and he isn't delivering right this very second.
 
Slim the squad down, free up the wage quality not quantity as a poster said before. We are so so so so close to doing it its time we realised it. Genuinely this era has one last go at this before our assets are poached and that goes for Grayson also. We need 3/4 more first team starters and we can do it and go up properly!

UTWs

This.

After next season, part of this squad will be broken up, incoming money dictates (as well as contracts running out in 2019 so next summer sees a lot of bloody good players with possibly only 12 months left on their contracts if no new renewals arrive this side of Xmas 17) which is why this summer is probably our most important for well over a decade.

We'll get one shot at it imo with this squad - 2017-18.
 
Back
Top