Skip to main content

Highlights

Highlights

That was an absolutley disgraceful scene by Kilkenny, not only should the club fine him 2 weeks wages as Jack suggested but the Football League need to make an example of Kilkenny and give him another 3 match ban for his pathetic attempt at trying to con the referee by feigning injury. If Kilkenny hadn't cheated then neither player would have been sent off, the ref would have seen it as handbags at dawn and just told them to calm down and get on with the game.
We don't need this and players like him ruining our beautiful game.

How sad. Your club has fallen down the league since we last played so you feel the need to come to a much superior side's forum.
 
Isn't it 9 home games without a home win for Bradford now?

If it's a decent point for us, then presumably it was a decent point (or more) for the previous 8 visiting teams too!!

Yeah D6 L3. Lost to Tranmere, Wolves and Rotherham but also drew to Orient, Coventry and Swindon (as well as some shit teams).

Obviously when you put it into context, including form etc., it's disappointing not to win. But like I said, in the grand scheme of things i.e. taking the season as a whole into account, a point away from home at a reasonable side (who were play-off contenders not long ago) is a decent result.

If we were genuine top 2 contenders then yes it would be a bad result, but realistically we're chasing a play-off spot and so therefore I think it's a decent point.
 
Last edited:
That was an absolutley disgraceful scene by Kilkenny, not only should the club fine him 2 weeks wages as Jack suggested but the Football League need to make an example of Kilkenny and give him another 3 match ban for his pathetic attempt at trying to con the referee by feigning injury. If Kilkenny hadn't cheated then neither player would have been sent off, the ref would have seen it as handbags at dawn and just told them to calm down and get on with the game.
We don't need this and players like him ruining our beautiful game.

Yep - mind you it is unlikely you would ever see anywhere near a beautiful game in that magnificent stadium of yours.
 
I was sat right behind a photographer who was quite happy to go through his shots with me. This incident was one he caught really well, and from looking at his pics, Kilkenny will say that the other lad stuck his fingers into his throat.

Although I agree that the reaction was way over the top, the picture was actually pretty incriminating.

The Head of Refereeing was at the game and he said that the referee was correct.

Both players acted like stupid knobs and will miss 3 games so was it worth it.
 
That was an absolutley disgraceful scene by Kilkenny, not only should the club fine him 2 weeks wages as Jack suggested but the Football League need to make an example of Kilkenny and give him another 3 match ban for his pathetic attempt at trying to con the referee by feigning injury. If Kilkenny hadn't cheated then neither player would have been sent off, the ref would have seen it as handbags at dawn and just told them to calm down and get on with the game.
We don't need this and players like him ruining our beautiful game.

I agree Kilkenny was embarrassing.. but I think the suggestion of a 6-match ban might be somewhat disproportionate 🙄

Was this your first football match?
 
The Head of Refereeing was at the game and he said that the referee was correct.

Both players acted like stupid knobs and will miss 3 games so was it worth it.
Talk Sport just mentioned his acting on 'Heads Gone', reckon his elaborate feign will become a classic.

Oh well, maybe he will learn from it.
 
Its the fact that he stays up for a few seconds after the incident and drops to the floor as soon as the ref blows.
 
I agree Kilkenny was embarrassing.. but I think the suggestion of a 6-match ban might be somewhat disproportionate 🙄

Was this your first football match?

I don't think it was disproportionate at all Regardless. If players deliberately feign injury so blatantly as what Kilkenny did last night then yes a longer ban should be enforced, how else can deliberate cheating be eradicated from the game.
We live in a world of technology, cameras at every game, use them and punish the offenders regardless of who they play for.
 
Last edited:
Manager needs to have a word. Beavon, Garner,Gallagher,Davies and now Kilkenny sent off. Mind you I think the current refs are really spoiling the game. They've no experience of playing and try to run matches by the letter of the law, instead of using common sense. Watched Liverpool's penalty last night when Howard brought down Stirling and the ref gave the pen and never gave the keeper any sort of card. Where is the continuity there ?
 
Manager needs to have a word. Beavon, Garner,Gallagher,Davies and now Kilkenny sent off. Mind you I think the current refs are really spoiling the game. They've no experience of playing and try to run matches by the letter of the law, instead of using common sense. Watched Liverpool's penalty last night when Howard brought down Stirling and the ref gave the pen and never gave the keeper any sort of card. Where is the continuity there ?

I'd suggest that Garner was very unlucky to be sent off vs Port Vale and I'm not going to criticise Davies for putting a tackle in - these things happen.

Gallagher and Kilkenny's were both avoidable and I'm sure they've been told so. I can't remember Beavon's.

Looking at the league one discipline records is interesting. We've got the 9th most yellows (49) compared with Notts County at 60 and 7th most reds (4 in league) compared with Tranmere and Peterborough with 7. Third most fouls though!!

So we're no angels but theres several teams worse than us although we've had a bad run of reds lately.
 
Gary Jones very lucky not to be booked in that incident imo. Kilkenny deserved red for trying to get their lad sent off!!
 
Kilkenny must have picked that up in Australia. Utterly pathetic and very disappointing. I'm glad he's suspended, even it means we will now probably falter in the engine room with the return of Keano.
 
Just wondering - and I am sure that people will have the answer - what is the precise rule that suggests a player should be sent off for feigning injury?

Not certain, but probably the same as simulation for a dive... yellow card.

I would support a rule where a red was issued - so long as the ref is 100% sure.

Trouble is, like diving, it's sometimes not clearcut even with slow motion. Anyone who's played the game at any level knows that sometime you do just crumple... from a twist, slip, accidental but near invisible ankle tap... or just sheer exhaustion. And it looks like a dive. Same with feigning injury. If a fingernail at the end of a flailing arm catches your eyeball - you go down big time, but everyone thinks your feigning.

In this instance, Kilkenny could claim that he got an apparently minor but painful blow to the throat/adam's apple. He might even be telling the truth, though I'd doubt it. He was struck (apparenly with all the force of a hamster) in the jaw/throat area. Would he be found guily of simulation? In this case, probably yes... but you get the point.
 
To me, Garner is 1 or 2 yards in front of the penalty spot = 7/8 yds into the area too.

Although first view would say that the guy beyond the back stick is not playing him on... I'd also say that he looks to be at least 7/8 yds from the edge of the area!

EDIT... actually, if you watch the video a few times... AFTER the ball's been flicked on, that guy is fairly stationary... he takes a 2 or 3 short steps towards his own goal, and suddenly he's only a couple of yards outside the 6yd box... suggesting he was deeper into his own box than first appears. It is so difficult to judge on that 2D, distant photo.

Having at first thought Garner was probably just off side, having watched the movement of the left back a few times, I'm now thinking that he was probably ONside. I'd certainly say that Garner was pretty unlucky to be flagged for that - but not clearcut

garnervbradford_zpsb7eb8b71.jpg
 
Last edited:
Back
Top