Skip to main content

How long comparison.

How long comparison.

Back to the question in hand. The only way we are going to stay in this league is if we start winning our home games and have a go at teams. Yes we won't win every game but I do believe whilst the squad is clearly not good enough to challenge at the top end it is good enough to stay in the league. Simon's Presser after Sheff Wed worried me but I hope just like back in January he can turn around the slide and push us on in the league.

Good post, and this bit is spot on, and is the main issue.

As a newly promoted side in this league who aren't as financially capable as others, picking up points away from home is going to be very difficult. Any away point is good in the Championship.

However, you have to win your home games if you're to stay up, and as you say, we will only begin to do this if we have a go at teams. Our home form in League 1 last season was 13 wins, 9 draws and 1 defeat out of the 23 home games. To only lose 1 is outstanding, but 9 draws was far too many at home, and was probably what cost us automatic promotion. Was this down to Grayson's overly cautious approach ? Quite possibly. Playing 3-5-2 at home to Yeovil for example.

We are starting to see that again at home this season. 3 points from 15 at Deepdale so far, courtesy of 3 draws, no wins. In the Derby and Bristol games in quick succession, SG played 3 at the back and 2 sitting midfielders, at home, leaving our only real attacking players as Johnson and the 2 strikers. To only have 3 real attacking players on the pitch at home is far too negative. This risk averse approach to everything has to stop or for Grayson, it will probably end the same way as it did at Huddersfield. He seems like a nice bloke, and it would be a shame if he has to go, but his tactics just are not working at this level and he doesn't seem to be changing them anytime soon.
 
I can't see him lasting much longer, just gut feeling.

The sad thing is I would love nothing more for him to turn it around and realise he has to try and win, rather than try and not get beat!

There is a constant debate between Graysons try not to get beat philosophy opposed to a try and win philosophy.

But with the players at his disposal and the budget can he afford to change his style as we might start to get torn apart week in week out, he could change his style but there is no guarantee it would work.
 
Would potting Grayson upset the togetherness and spirit within the dressing room that has been built by him?

If he was to go the only person I would look at would be Karl Robinson, plays very good football on a shoestring budget and knows how to use the premiership loan market effectively.

Attracting players to PNE compared to MK dons could see him build quite a competitive squad.



Is this the same Karl Robinson who's team are struggling just like ours after going up automatic ?
 
Would potting Grayson upset the togetherness and spirit within the dressing room that has been built by him?

If he was to go the only person I would look at would be Karl Robinson, plays very good football on a shoestring budget and knows how to use the premiership loan market effectively.

Attracting players to PNE compared to MK dons could see him build quite a competitive squad.

As you mentioned a while ago, the young, hungry, positive manager approach that Birmingham took by appointing Gary Rowett has really worked wonders for them. It's obviously a bit of a risk, but I wouldn't mind us going down a similar route.
 
There is a constant debate between Graysons try not to get beat philosophy opposed to a try and win philosophy.

But with the players at his disposal and the budget can he afford to change his style as we might start to get torn apart week in week out, he could change his style but there is no guarantee it would work.
I would agree with that apart from 2 points:

1. When we have suddenly realised that we are a couple of goals behind and push forward we can and do create chances.

2. I would rather get beat trying than just get demoted with a whimper.
 
Would potting Grayson upset the togetherness and spirit within the dressing room that has been built by him?

If he was to go the only person I would look at would be Karl Robinson, plays very good football on a shoestring budget and knows how to use the premiership loan market effectively.

Attracting players to PNE compared to MK dons could see him build quite a competitive squad.
I don't think there can ever be a 'togetherness' in a team that is threatened with relegation. Cracks will appear either through some not having the fight, or some not having the ability. You can't carry people at this level.
 
Grayson has a lot of support amongst our fans. And rightly so for that magical day at Wembley. However, if we sacked Grayson at the weekend, and a poll was done asking if it was the right decision, there would be a higher % agreeing with it then current polls suggest. Some football fans support whatever the club decide to do.

I generally hope he turns things well. As the spokesman of our club, he's been nothing a top professional. But I do think he's not good enough to keep us up in this league. And with the players at our disposal we are under achieving. The next 6 games I think will determine whether Grayson will be in charge come Xmas. And he needs a minimum 7 points to be safe.
 
I can't see him lasting much longer, just gut feeling.

The sad thing is I would love nothing more for him to turn it around and realise he has to try and win, rather than try and not get beat!

Grayson isn't going to change. People have different views of Grayson's tenure, mine is that it has been boring and predictable with the frustrations and disappointments outnumbering the few times of enjoyment and satisfaction, by a significant margin.

I don't think we far away from getting it right though. With our better players restored to the first 11, and if we replicate the attacking intent we've shown in our last couple of home games I think we'll start winning our home games, which is, of course, absolutely imperative.

When Grayson is inevitably potted, the alternatives are out there. Warnock is too much like Grayson, old, dour, miserable and archaic. We've been down this road with Grayson, and it's bore very little fruit in terms of excitement, achievement and attracting fans. Roy Keane would be my choice for next manager.
 
Unlike many of our recent previous managers I actually like Simon Grayson. When Sir Tom passed away I thought Grayson and the club as a whole conducted themselves with great dignity and I was pleased it was someone like Grayson who was in charge at the time. He is a decent bloke and has been a very good figure head for the club after the debacle of the medal winners era. He was a steady calming influence and ultimately brought us the play off victory that we all craved.

Beckford was an inspired signing and despite his illness something just works with Grayson. Daniel Johnson has also been a tremendous signing and it has been a good while since we signed someone young with the potential to make us some serious money in the future.

He was very close to getting the boot during January and had we not got that result at Sheff Utd I think he would have been a goner. There is no doubt that the result that night sent us on a great run of results (putting aside the garbage at Colchester) which culminated with one of the most memorable days I've ever had at Wembley.

This season was always going to be a tough one for the club and I don't think Simon has been helped by some interference and dithering by others in the transfer window one win in ten speaks for itself. Non of our strikers have scored in the league and lets be honest we don't look like scoring more than one in a league game any time soon. Gallagher & Beckford have been a huge miss and we also got robbed blind by Trevor Kettle but we just don't look anywhere near good enough and I'm struggling to see Simon changing his defensive first tactics (which just don't work in the championship).

Preston North End can not afford to get relegated again, financially it would be a disaster and I think our fan base would drop even lower.

Back to the question in hand. The only way we are going to stay in this league is if we start winning our home games and have a go at teams. Yes we won't win every game but I do believe whilst the squad is clearly not good enough to challenge at the top end it is good enough to stay in the league. Simon's Presser after Sheff Wed worried me but I hope just like back in January he can turn around the slide and push us on in the league.

However if we lose on Saturday in a similar manner to previous losses I don't think anyone could grumble if Trevor pulls the plug, I think the club will have been very naïve not to be looking at their options. December would be too late to change managers again.....

We have to stay up..... Do I believe that we will achieve that under Grayson? I honestly don't know and that is what worries me.

A very good post JK and some very good points, we simply must stay up, relegation must be avoided as it would be disastrous both on and off the field for North End. The next four games for me could be pivotal to our season and for SG in his position as manager. If we can accumulate 7 points from the next four games then the pressure will be off SG and bring fans back on side, I just hope we can start to pull things around and get out of the bottom three as quickly as possible.
 
Grayson isn't going to change. People have different views of Grayson's tenure, mine is that it has been boring and predictable with the frustrations and disappointments outnumbering the few times of enjoyment and satisfaction, by a significant margin.

I don't think we far away from getting it right though. With our better players restored to the first 11, and if we replicate the attacking intent we've shown in our last couple of home games I think we'll start winning our home games, which is, of course, absolutely imperative.

When Grayson is inevitably potted, the alternatives are out there. Warnock is too much like Grayson, old, dour, miserable and archaic. We've been down this road with Grayson, and it's bore very little fruit in terms of excitement, achievement and attracting fans. Roy Keane would be my choice for next manager.

Too much ego.
 
Unlike many of our recent previous managers I actually like Simon Grayson. When Sir Tom passed away I thought Grayson and the club as a whole conducted themselves with great dignity and I was pleased it was someone like Grayson who was in charge at the time. He is a decent bloke and has been a very good figure head for the club after the debacle of the medal winners era. He was a steady calming influence and ultimately brought us the play off victory that we all craved.

Beckford was an inspired signing and despite his illness something just works with Grayson. Daniel Johnson has also been a tremendous signing and it has been a good while since we signed someone young with the potential to make us some serious money in the future.

He was very close to getting the boot during January and had we not got that result at Sheff Utd I think he would have been a goner. There is no doubt that the result that night sent us on a great run of results (putting aside the garbage at Colchester) which culminated with one of the most memorable days I've ever had at Wembley.

This season was always going to be a tough one for the club and I don't think Simon has been helped by some interference and dithering by others in the transfer window one win in ten speaks for itself. Non of our strikers have scored in the league and lets be honest we don't look like scoring more than one in a league game any time soon. Gallagher & Beckford have been a huge miss and we also got robbed blind by Trevor Kettle but we just don't look anywhere near good enough and I'm struggling to see Simon changing his defensive first tactics (which just don't work in the championship).

Preston North End can not afford to get relegated again, financially it would be a disaster and I think our fan base would drop even lower.

Back to the question in hand. The only way we are going to stay in this league is if we start winning our home games and have a go at teams. Yes we won't win every game but I do believe whilst the squad is clearly not good enough to challenge at the top end it is good enough to stay in the league. Simon's Presser after Sheff Wed worried me but I hope just like back in January he can turn around the slide and push us on in the league.

However if we lose on Saturday in a similar manner to previous losses I don't think anyone could grumble if Trevor pulls the plug, I think the club will have been very naïve not to be looking at their options. December would be too late to change managers again.....

We have to stay up..... Do I believe that we will achieve that under Grayson? I honestly don't know and that is what worries me.

Totally with you on this
 
Too late for Larry i feel the knives are well and truely out , even if he turned the results round there will still be people calling for his head

Doesn't matter who is manager when we are 3 good players away from a competing team.

The gamble has been taken, some of the guys who did so well last season haven't made the step up, time to strengthen or struggle.
 
Doesn't matter who is manager when we are 3 good players away from a competing team.

The gamble has been taken, some of the guys who did so well last season haven't made the step up, time to strengthen or struggle.

How do you know that unless a different Manager tries different tactics ?
 
For me he has till the next international break. If we still see no improvement then he has to go. Get a new manager in, give him all December to assess the squad so he can see where he thinks needs improving.
 
Too much ego.

Keane? Possibly, would be great value though. I think him (or someone like him) is just what North End need; breathe a bit of life back into the club, add an initial few thousand onto the gates in the short term and create a winning team in the long run.

With regards to 'ego' etc. I think you're being a bit harsh. Keane is a realist who talks honestly (not your standard boring cliche merchant, e.g. Grayson), is completely anti-establishment and has never shied away from speaking his mind, presumably to some significant financial cost at times.

Of course, he's certainly picking up a more than decent wage from his coaching/media/book writing (worth a read) jobs at the moment, but I don't think his ego needs massaging at all. It would be worth asking whether he wants to get back into management after 5 or so years out when Grayson does go IMO.
 
Got lucky with Sunderland. Crap ever since. Also a total hypocrit.

Got lucky?

He took over Sunderland from Niall Quinn with them bottom in 24th with 0 points off 5 games meaning he had 41 games.

The result 41 games later?

Champions.

He then kept Sunderland up in the Prem.

Ipswich prior to Mick McCarthy was a poisoned chalice of a job. No shame here and fair play to Mick and the job he has done since. Others failed there before Mick.

Not saying Keane is or isn't the answer but lets have it right about his managerial history, yeah. He was bloody decent for Sunderland when you see how managers after him have performed!
 
Got lucky?

He took over Sunderland from Niall Quinn with them bottom in 24th with 0 points off 5 games meaning he had 41 games.

The result 41 games later?

Champions.

He then kept Sunderland up in the Prem.

Ipswich prior to Mick McCarthy was a poisoned chalice of a job. No shame here and fair play to Mick and the job he has done since. Others failed there before Mick.

Not saying Keane is or isn't the answer but lets have it right about his managerial history, yeah. He was bloody decent for Sunderland when you see how managers after him have performed!

Sounds good, but still I dont think Keane is what we need.
 
Sounds good, but still I dont think Keane is what we need.

Agreed. I'd be interested to see Burton Albion fans opinions on Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink. And maybe even Wycombe fans opinions on Gareth Ainsworth. He has prior experience at this level with QPR.

If/when Grayson leaves, I'd have a shortlist of something like Pearson, Lambert, McDermott, Hasselbaink, Dean Smith, Ainsworth, Mike Phelan. Not saying their all ideal candidates, but certainly worth speaking to and seeing their views.
 
Back
Top