Skip to main content

Joe Garner

Joe Garner

His job is to score goals. At this level he can't Andy Saville was a god but when he stepped up a division could not do it.
2 earlier spell at this level plus 1/2 season for us shows he just can't do it at this level for all the effort he puts in
 
He's the same player as last season. The difference is now he's playing in a better league against ex Premier league defenders. He was never ever going to be as prolific in front of goal.
 
Anybody who cant see what garner does for this team should go and watch netball cause they know f--- all about football.
 
I thought Joe Garner was more sinned against than sinner today. It seemed like they came with a premeditated game plan to wind him up and get him sent off. A lot of Brentfords tactics today were unsavoury, snidey and sneaky.
Surrounding the Ref with 3 or 4 Players when they both fouled and were fouled!
We have one Player who maybe goes to ground too easily and constantly moans and whinges. They had virtually a whole Team.
This totally detracts from the fact that they actually played some good football in between their Gamesmanship.
Until today they were a Team I never had animosity towards, very disgusted with a lot of there antics.

Garner might not be scoring shed loads but he does contribute and ALWAYS puts the effort in. Never gives any defenders an easy ride.
I think he himself will be disappointed by his goal return but I bet he is still one of the first names on the Team-sheet
 
Taking to some rovers fans and they were saying they wished they had him as he is a bloody Nuisance and he works so hard for 90 min and never gives up and the goals will come.
For me Joe has been brilliant for us.
The trouble is some people never know what they have got till he has gone.
 
He is a nuisance but we need a goal scorer along side him. Doyle is not the answer ala the miss and I don't think it is a confidence thing just looks unfit and half arsed. Hugill is deffo not the answer looks off pace, puppy fat and gets bullied.
 
I thought Joe Garner was more sinned against than sinner today. It seemed like they came with a premeditated game plan to wind him up and get him sent off. A lot of Brentfords tactics today were unsavoury, snidey and sneaky.
Surrounding the Ref with 3 or 4 Players when they both fouled and were fouled!
We have one Player who maybe goes to ground too easily and constantly moans and whinges. They had virtually a whole Team.
This totally detracts from the fact that they actually played some good football in between their Gamesmanship.
Until today they were a Team I never had animosity towards, very disgusted with a lot of there antics.

Garner might not be scoring shed loads but he does contribute and ALWAYS puts the effort in. Never gives any defenders an easy ride.
I think he himself will be disappointed by his goal return but I bet he is still one of the first names on the Team-sheet
Totally agree !
 
I thought Joe Garner was more sinned against than sinner today. It seemed like they came with a premeditated game plan to wind him up and get him sent off. A lot of Brentfords tactics today were unsavoury, snidey and sneaky.
Surrounding the Ref with 3 or 4 Players when they both fouled and were fouled!
We have one Player who maybe goes to ground too easily and constantly moans and whinges. They had virtually a whole Team.
This totally detracts from the fact that they actually played some good football in between their Gamesmanship.
Until today they were a Team I never had animosity towards, very disgusted with a lot of there antics.

Garner might not be scoring shed loads but he does contribute and ALWAYS puts the effort in. Never gives any defenders an easy ride.
I think he himself will be disappointed by his goal return but I bet he is still one of the first names on the Team-sheet

Agree entirely, they reminded me of a prem team with their antics, diving, time wasting and surrounding the ref. Judge and Saunders were constantly in the refs face. In credible that only 4 minutes were added considering all the stoppages in the second half
 
Agree entirely, they reminded me of a prem team with their antics, diving, time wasting and surrounding the ref. Judge and Saunders were constantly in the refs face. In credible that only 4 minutes were added considering all the stoppages in the second half

They won 3-1 and passed it around us for 75 of the 90 mins. Fully deserved win and we were 2nd best all day long.
 
They won 3-1 and passed it around us for 75 of the 90 mins. Fully deserved win and we were 2nd best all day long.

They did pass it around well and looked the better Team. A draw today would have been a point gained for us.
All the more reason to question why they needed to be petty, underhand and churlish in their Play. Constantly surrounding a weak referee who almost fell for the tactic to get Garner sent off. As I said earlier this seemed premeditated and therefore gives them no credit as a Club.
Shame, as I would have given the Football they Played all the credit if they hadn't taken gamesmanship to an unacceptable level.
 
All this crap about what he does for the team !

Is 3 goals all season good enough from your main striker ?

Well we had better stick him in midfield where he can graft his spuds off then because we need goal scorers .

Can't knock his effort , and his ability . But relying on him when he isn't scoring isn't fair on him, you can clearly see how frustrated he is . And he also looks like he has lost confidence IMO.
 
Sorry I disagree.
Think the Brentfotd lads were deliberately trying to wind him up and his yellow card incident was a farce... From where I saw it. He didn't do much wrong.

Chased defenders down well today and is desperate for a strike partner.

Where did you watch the game from, the moon?

How the hell he got away the "swing" he took at their player is a bloody miracle.

However, I'm glad he got away with it, because he was getting some serious stick.

I agree he has far too much to do on his own and needs a genuine striker to provide some real support.
 
All this crap about what he does for the team !

Is 3 goals all season good enough from your main striker ?

Well we had better stick him in midfield where he can graft his spuds off then because we need goal scorers .

Can't knock his effort , and his ability . But relying on him when he isn't scoring isn't fair on him, you can clearly see how frustrated he is . And he also looks like he has lost confidence IMO.

You really are a numpty aern't you.

Dont you understand that Garner is not being played as an out and out goalscorer?

Do you actually attend games to watch what is going on? Or are you just a clown who see's Garner hasnt scored before sticking the boot in on here?

There is a very good reason Garner is in the team every week despite his lack of goals. Open your eyes and you will see why.
 
All this crap about what he does for the team !

Is 3 goals all season good enough from your main striker ?

Well we had better stick him in midfield where he can graft his spuds off then because we need goal scorers .

Can't knock his effort , and his ability . But relying on him when he isn't scoring isn't fair on him, you can clearly see how frustrated he is . And he also looks like he has lost confidence IMO.

Intelligent post, but you're wasting your time. Garner is popular with the masses because he's a bit lary and gives it the big one in every game. But when he gets a bit of treatment back from opposition players, he can't hack it.

He has become a liability this season. He was VERY lucky to avoid a red card today and he clearly took a swing at one of their players. OK so the tactics Grayson employs don't help Garners cause, but that's no excuse. He's no use to us if he gets sent off. Once again today Garners antics caused other PNE players to become embroiled in it and instead of concentrating on the game, we lost our focus. It's not the Joe Garner show FFS.

If any other striker on our books had played so many games this season and scored so few goals they would be slaughtered. But because Garner niggles, fouls, winds up the opposition and gets himself sent off regularly (to no benefit of us BTW) he is regarded as some sort of hero. I don't get it. Guess that means I know nothing about football.
 
They did pass it around well and looked the better Team. A draw today would have been a point gained for us.
All the more reason to question why they needed to be petty, underhand and churlish in their Play. Constantly surrounding a weak referee who almost fell for the tactic to get Garner sent off. As I said earlier this seemed premeditated and therefore gives them no credit as a Club.
Shame, as I would have given the Football they Played all the credit if they hadn't taken gamesmanship to an unacceptable level.
Agree but Garner and the diving? He was lucky not to walk. Never mind beaten fair and square hence next game is also worth 3 points.
 
Garner should of been off, they had an issue, but Garner basically swung for the lad and nearly slapped him across the face. Got away with it big time, he knew what he did because he ran away straight away.
 
Intelligent post, but you're wasting your time. Garner is popular with the masses because he's a bit lary and gives it the big one in every game. But when he gets a bit of treatment back from opposition players, he can't hack it.

He has become a liability this season. He was VERY lucky to avoid a red card today and he clearly took a swing at one of their players. OK so the tactics Grayson employs don't help Garners cause, but that's no excuse. He's no use to us if he gets sent off. Once again today Garners antics caused other PNE players to become embroiled in it and instead of concentrating on the game, we lost our focus. It's not the Joe Garner show FFS.

If any other striker on our books had played so many games this season and scored so few goals they would be slaughtered. But because Garner niggles, fouls, winds up the opposition and gets himself sent off regularly (to no benefit of us BTW) he is regarded as some sort of hero. I don't get it. Guess that means I know nothing about football.

Gets himself sent off regularly? Do you know how many times he's been red carded as a North End player?
 
Intelligent post, but you're wasting your time. Garner is popular with the masses because he's a bit lary and gives it the big one in every game. But when he gets a bit of treatment back from opposition players, he can't hack it.

He has become a liability this season. He was VERY lucky to avoid a red card today and he clearly took a swing at one of their players. OK so the tactics Grayson employs don't help Garners cause, but that's no excuse. He's no use to us if he gets sent off. Once again today Garners antics caused other PNE players to become embroiled in it and instead of concentrating on the game, we lost our focus. It's not the Joe Garner show FFS.

If any other striker on our books had played so many games this season and scored so few goals they would be slaughtered. But because Garner niggles, fouls, winds up the opposition and gets himself sent off regularly (to no benefit of us BTW) he is regarded as some sort of hero. I don't get it. Guess that means I know nothing about football.

you got the last bit correct if nothing else !!
 
Back
Top