Skip to main content

Joe Garner

Joe Garner

Gets himself sent off regularly? Do you know how many times he's been red carded as a North End player?

Well he's sent off regularly if you count one sending off in all his time at PNE as regular. Still, we shouldn't let the facts get in the way of a Tugg rant should we?
 
Intelligent post, but you're wasting your time. Garner is popular with the masses because he's a bit lary and gives it the big one in every game. But when he gets a bit of treatment back from opposition players, he can't hack it.

He has become a liability this season. He was VERY lucky to avoid a red card today and he clearly took a swing at one of their players. OK so the tactics Grayson employs don't help Garners cause, but that's no excuse. He's no use to us if he gets sent off. Once again today Garners antics caused other PNE players to become embroiled in it and instead of concentrating on the game, we lost our focus. It's not the Joe Garner show FFS.

If any other striker on our books had played so many games this season and scored so few goals they would be slaughtered. But because Garner niggles, fouls, winds up the opposition and gets himself sent off regularly (to no benefit of us BTW) he is regarded as some sort of hero. I don't get it. Guess that means I know nothing about football.

So his defending at corners, constant target man play, winning numerous free kicks and running himself into the ground just don't matter then............ok.
 
So his defending at corners, constant target man play, winning numerous free kicks and running himself into the ground just don't matter then............ok.

I'm a big fan of garner but the scary thing for me is that the comments defending his performances - "he doesn't score but look at his work rate, he doesn't score but he brings in others, defends corners well" etc etc are all beginning to sound worryingly similar to the ones made by those who used to stick up for Kevin Davies.
 
I'm a big fan of garner but the scary thing for me is that the comments defending his performances - "he doesn't score but look at his work rate, he doesn't score but he brings in others, defends corners well" etc etc are all beginning to sound worryingly similar to the ones made by those who used to stick up for Kevin Davies.

Garner does it more though, as long as he is creating chances for himself and others he is in the team for me, bet he has a number of assists this season as well.

He could have had 2 today if it wasn't for the marginal offside and amazing save.
 
Ultimately strikers are paid to score goals and he doesn't score in the championship. He's a fans favourite but so was Andy Saville and he couldn't score at this level either.
 
And did you the think the antics of some of brentfords players were acceptable?
Thought the Gamesmanship of the Brentford players was a disgrace, they're a decent footballing side (without creating many chances) but seemed to enjoy copying Tom Daley for most of the game.

It looked like their Number 7 kicked Garner whilst Garner was on the floor at the start of the second half. I guess they were worried about us as they seemed to be trying their best to get our players sent off.
 
Garner does it more though, as long as he is creating chances for himself and others he is in the team for me, bet he has a number of assists this season as well.

He could have had 2 today if it wasn't for the marginal offside and amazing save.
You've just done exactly what I was on about again, Ron. It's all sounding so, so, so Kevin Davies. " he does this though, he does that though, if only so and so. " joe really does need to start finding the net but I don't think he needs to worry about his place in the side. SG seemed happy to play KD a for two years without scoring.
 
You've just done exactly what I was on about again, Ron. It's all sounding so, so, so Kevin Davies. " he does this though, he does that though, if only so and so. " joe really does need to start finding the net but I don't think he needs to worry about his place in the side. SG seemed happy to play KD a for two years without scoring.

I liked Davies for the record.

I think if Garner had a good strike partner or one with confidence he wouldn't be as occupied as he has been in this division and he might have a few more goals to his name.
 
Thought the Gamesmanship of the Brentford players was a disgrace, they're a decent footballing side (without creating many chances) but seemed to enjoy copying Tom Daley for most of the game.

It looked like their Number 7 kicked Garner whilst Garner was on the floor at the start of the second half. I guess they were worried about us as they seemed to be trying their best to get our players sent off.
They did much the same thing at Griffin Park, where they had the home fans howling for blood at every perceived injustice. Lot of timewasting antics at the away game too, they seemed "well drilled" in this stuff.
 
If you asked the opposing defenders who they least like playing against it would be garner every time. His overall contribution is massive, runs his socks off every game,wins more balls in the air than a guy his size should have any chance of. So overall he covers more ground ,wins more headers, worries the opposition defence to death and has scored more goals than any of our other options who by the way dont look like they could hit a barn door with a banjo and yet people are questioning him. Baffles me !!
 
I'm beginning to get fed up of the theatrical head injuries he gets every time he doesn't win the ball. I know that it works sometimes (maybe 1 in 6?) and he gets a free kick, but to be honest, I'd rather he didn't go down so easily - looks bad for us and bad for him.

Apart from that, I think he's doing incredibly well - ok he hasn't been banging in the goals, but he has been setting the up left-right-and-centre just Doyle and other's incompetence has failed to translate that into a decent whack of goals for the team.
 
If you asked the opposing defenders who they least like playing against it would be garner every time. His overall contribution is massive, runs his socks off every game,wins more balls in the air than a guy his size should have any chance of. So overall he covers more ground ,wins more headers, worries the opposition defence to death and has scored more goals than any of our other options who by the way dont look like they could hit a barn door with a banjo and yet people are questioning him. Baffles me !!

As you say, that's not saying a great deal. I would think most defences aren't all that worried about playing against us for the very reason that we don't offer a great goal threat. Our mid-table position is purely due to our good defence.
 
Garner should of been off, they had an issue, but Garner basically swung for the lad and nearly slapped him across the face. Got away with it big time, he knew what he did because he ran away straight away.

I think the 4th official and linesman were in perfect position to see & know what happend so not guilty for me.
Why don't we sign David Nudgen from midlesbough 5 goals and cost 4 million because he is great at this level
He has been brilliant for us has Joe not had Much luck in front of goal with post,bars, and some brilliant saves denying him.
 
He's a chav

Last season in league one he was unplayable at times . And he wound defenders up no end .

This season he has 3goals . Missed a few sitters and looks more interested in getting free kicks than scoring .

He isn't good enough in the championship , it's that simple. Unfortunately we don't have any other options.

He's been playing up front pretty much on his own (or he might as well be with Doyle on the pitch but that's another thread) so he's obviously gonna find it difficult.

If he had someone half decent alongside him (Beckford) you'd see a different player I reckon.
 
They did much the same thing at Griffin Park, where they had the home fans howling for blood at every perceived injustice. Lot of timewasting antics at the away game too, they seemed "well drilled" in this stuff.

And they'll carry on doing so as long as referees allow them to do so. In the second half their time wasting was something Billy Davies would have been proud of and the referee must have told them to hurry up half a dozen times and gestured at his watch the same number of times to indicate he was adding the time on. He booked nobody and added no time on for time wasting - 4 minutes was the bare minimum for the goals, substitutions and bookings.

As for Garner's 'red card' incident, he was fouled, turned round (aggressively admittedly) but was then pushed into their player. The fact the referee, his assistant and the 4th official were all in close proximity and conferred at length with none of them thinking it was a red card implies that to be the case. We don't get to see the official reason for cautions but aggressive intent (for want of a better term) is a yellow card offence.

Having said all that, the content was with the Brentford player's body below the neck so not a red card in any case
 
28 appearances, 3 goals, 4 assists, 60 fouls, 9 yellow cards, 1 red card. What a fantastic contribution. Unfortunately it's the best we've got right now and that says everything.
 
28 appearances, 3 goals, 4 assists, 60 fouls, 9 yellow cards, 1 red card. What a fantastic contribution. Unfortunately it's the best we've got right now and that says everything.

You said he is always getting sent off. He's been sent off once in his entire PNE career.......got an agenda have we tugg?
 
You said he is always getting sent off. He's been sent off once in his entire PNE career.......got an agenda have we tugg?

Ok so you focus on that and completely ignore the rest of the statistics.

I exaggerated with the regularly sent off comment, but he was mistakenly identified last season at Port Vale when he chinned one of their players but the. Ref sent off someone else by mistake.

I've no agenda, just fed up with Garners antics and don't believe they help our cause.
 
Back
Top